Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and radio host of KDKA-AM and 93.7 The Fan answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask a question, tweet him @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Amy: Why has Mike Tomlin been so protected by so many from the fact that he inherited a winning team and won with “Bill Cowher’s players”? Why are there some people who actually try and deny this? I don’t think that it is the negative that some people act like it is but it is a fact.
Zeise: I think it is a dumb argument but it isn’t irrelevant, either. Mike Tomlin is basically Barry Switzer, who won with Jimmy Johnson’s team. There is something to be said about inheriting a team versus building a team. Tomlin inherited a team, but he still added to the roster and coached them to two Super Bowls. I just don’t know how anyone can deny that. If you look at Switzer, he inherited a team and coached them to a Super Bowl title. I would have been interested to see him guide the rebuild after all those stars retired. The bottom line is Tomlin has done a really good job, but he did get off to a great start to his career by taking over a team that was already built. Also, the defenders who say “Cowher didn’t win with those players” are being silly. They were 8-8 the year before mostly because Ben Roethlisberger was injured in a motorcycle accident before the season and wasn’t fully healthy until about six or seven games in the season. The two years prior to that, they lost in the AFC title game and then won the Super Bowl. And even that final season of Cowher’s time, they finished the season as one of the best teams in the AFC, but they missed the playoffs because they lost too many games early.
Scott: True, the Steelers last 3 coaches have all been “Who’s that?!?” hires and worked out. No one heard of Noll, Cower or Tomlin till the Steelers hired them and gave them repeated contract extensions when the masses wanted them fired. So yes they (i.e., Dan Rooney) have gotten it right 3 times but will Art Rooney II have the same success?
Zeise: That is a good point — the Steelers’ last three coaches were hired by Dan Rooney and he is one of the best football men in the history of the NFL. I think Art II would be fine making the hire because there is still a good structure in the front office and Omar Khan and Andy Weidl are very smart football men, as well. It is a great point, though, that the Steelers ability to hire great coaches was a product of Dan Rooney and he is no longer around.
Read More
Ferdinand: Mike Tomlin is one of the better coaches in the NFL. My opinion on what needs to be improved is the quarterback. Look at New England without Tom Brady. Would you fire their coach?
Zeise: In short, yes, if I were Robert Kraft, I would fire Bill Belichick at the end of this year. The Patriots need a restart and a new voice. It is time. And it is also clear Belichick’s fastball as a personnel and draft guru is long gone. The Patriots’ roster is bad and the quarterback position is only the tip of the iceberg. It is time.
Ray: How can so.many be blind to the obvious truth about Mike Tomlin? I don't get it. Art ll is not like the ones before him and if they don't change at coach position next year will be a total failure also. Guys like TJ will suffer like so many greats who never won the big games. I'm 53 and season ticket holder and the steelers game play makes me sick to watch. I still do and go to games but it's from history not excitement anymore.
Zeise: I think the number of people who still are firmly all-in on Tomlin is declining every year. Many people are starting to wonder if the Steelers are sort of stuck in neutral as long as he is the coach. I don’t think he is a bad coach; I actually think he is a really good coach. I just think he might have hit his shelf life here and both he and the Steelers could use a change.
Roy: I personally think an order for the Steelers to look like the Steelers again we need to bring in old school Steelers and try to change everything back to the way it used to be. Guys like Mike Munchak should come in maybe Hines Ward as a receiver coach. And I know it would never happen in 1 million years but if you want to bring the Steelers back to be in Steelers in and Out of that building? I think bring back in Whisenhunt to coach us and Mike Munchak on the line and things will instantly change, do this for five years then maybe go get your young coach of the future.
Zeise: We, in this town, seem to love these “Back to the Future” hires and I say NO. Heck no. That is a huge part of the problem with the Steelers. They need new ideas and new blood and need to get out of their comfort zone.
Ryan: Does any other sports city live-operate in the past more than Pittsburgh? Mike Sullivan and Mike Tomlin are given extensions despite neither of their teams having playoff success for several years. The Pirates are almost never in "win now" mode. If there is another city that is worse in this category, I can't think of one
Zeise: This town is stuck in the past in so many ways. And frankly the teams operate as if change is always a bad thing. That is why there seems to be so little motivation to change coaches, change the way the Pirates are operated, etc. And while some fans push back against it, most like the stability model and believe it gives our teams a chance to compete every year. I think stability is good to a point, but I also don’t think change is a bad thing.
J
oey: Do you think all these Pitt football players leaving and entering the transfer portal will hinder the program in the short term future?
Zeise: No, I don’t. The Pitt coaching staff and the 412 Alliance are out looking at other players and will just replace them with new guys. I am not a fan of the way the transfer portal is used by both coaches and players, but it is the way college football and basketball are played these days. It is the way of the world and us old heads can either embrace it or wax poetic about the good old days of college athletics and be miserable about it. There are something like 1,800 players in the transfer portal right now, so what has gone on at Pitt is not unique to the Panthers.
Jim: Why won’t Pitt play a game like [West Virginia] versus Dukes?
Zeise: Jeff Capel does not want to play the game. He does not value the game. He does not think it helps Pitt overall and thinks it is a no-win situation for his team. If Pitt wins, they are supposed to, so who cares; if they lose, it is a bad loss. And once he made it clear that he didn’t want to play the game, Keith Dambrot said basically as long as Capel is the coach, the game won’t be played because they aren’t going to be able to work together. It is absolutely ridiculous that the Pitt-Duquesne game is not played every year. It is an embarrassment that the City Game was killed for the dumbest reasons possible.
Jack: I see Penn State fans are all upset because Manny Diaz is going to take a head coaching position. The thing is, if Manny Diaz is such a great defensive coordinator, why couldn't he figure out how to stop Michigan who ran the ball 32 times in a row?
Zeise: Has there ever been any coach who has benefitted more from taking over a loaded roster than Diaz? Yes, he is a great defensive coach and his defensive teams have been really tough to score on. But James Franklin recruits well, Penn State has a lot of really talented players, and as long as whoever replaces Diaz is reasonably competent, the defense will be fine. As for the Michigan game, there is no game plan that can overcome “we got our butt’s kicked up front.” Michigan basically just said, “The only way we lose is if we throw interceptions, and you can’t stop us running right at you.” Diaz is now a hot candidate for head coach, but he was the head coach at Miami and the Hurricanes were very mediocre under his watch and he got fired.
Engstock: What's your take on the Florida State-Alabama business? Could they have inadvertently hurt their cause at the start of the season when they were letting everyone know they didn't have the best opinion of the ACC? Do you think this situation will motivate them to buy their way out of the ACC as soon as possible even no matter how much it costs? And if they can get out soon where do you think they'd land? I've read that they'd love to go to the Big Ten but would the Big Ten want them?
Zeise: It is a farce. The College Football Playoff committee kissed the brass ring of the SEC and their broadcast partners. There are three major conference champions who are undefeated and Texas and Alabama. If Texas had a win over someone other than Alabama, they would have been left out. But the committee knew they couldn’t leave Alabama — and the mighty SEC — out so they drew up this idiotic story about Florida State’s quarterback injury. It came down to the fact that they were less scared of the ACC than the SEC. And teams leaving the ACC is a pipe dream. It is going to cost way too much money right now to make it worth it.
Chad: Do you happen to know where the money goes to colleges/universities when they receive a payout for a bowl game? I.E.- The athletic department in general, the football program, or the college/university itself?
Zeise: The bowl money is part of a larger bundle of funds, from broadcast rights to NCAA tournament payouts and several other things, that is divided up by the conference and distributed to each athletic department. That’s the way bowl money is distributed to each school — bowls pay the conferences, then conferences split the money, and conferences pay the athletic departments.
Paul Zeise:pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.