We have reached the point of the NFL season when many national media hot-take guys begin to pontificate about just how great Steelers fans have it and how thankful they should be that Mike Tomlin is the coach of their favorite team.
It is almost always done in a condescending tone and almost always framed as “you spoiled, entitled fans don’t know how great you have it.”
The latest to pop off in this regard was NFL Network host Rich Eisen, who said Steelers fans and people in this town are “out of their freaking minds” to want to get rid of Mike Tomlin. ESPN radio’s Mike Greenberg has been beating the drum about Tomlin being the coach of the year and underappreciated in Pittsburgh, and there are a host of others out there who all say the same thing.
I’ll couch this by writing that I think Eisen is extremely smart — he isn’t a hot-take guy — I listen and watch his show often and love it, so this isn’t about him. The same thing when it comes to Greenberg and guys like Stan Verrett, also a “Tomlin coach of the year” guy, as they are smart and do a good job.
But all three of them and many others like them are dead wrong on this. In fact, they couldn’t be more wrong. And I would be willing to bet that they have no idea what Tomlin has or hasn’t accomplished recently, but these talking points are always built on many of the same pillars.
Let me say this unequivocally and as clearly as I can: Tomlin is a very good coach, and nobody would argue otherwise. Tomlin has done a good job with the Steelers for the most part, and very few rational people would even argue against that.
Good coaches, though, at times have a shelf life. And Tomlin is rapidly reaching his. If the Steelers care about remaining the Steelers, he should be coaching for his job these next five games and into (assuming they make it) the playoffs. At the very least, he should be coaching to stay off an extremely hot seat next year, and the minimum to stay off of that should be to win a playoff game.
Tomlin’s career in Pittsburgh can really be divided into two careers. Actually, one that consists of his first four seasons and one that consists of the last 12+ seasons. The first five seasons, he was Bill Walsh. These last 11+ seasons, he has been somewhere between Marvin Lewis and Marty Schottenheimer. And the problem the Eisens of the world have is their entire argument is built as if we are supposed to focus on his first five seasons and act like the last 11 didn’t exist or are better than they actually were.
The Steelers won three division titles, had double-digit wins three times, won a Super Bowl, got to another and went 5-2 in playoff games in Tomlin’s first four years. And while I don’t fully subscribe to the “he won with Cowher’s players” stuff, there is no denying he inherited a Super Bowl-caliber roster that was one year removed from winning its fifth Lombardi Trophy. Yes, they were 8-8 in Bill Cowher’s last year, but that was almost 100 percent because Ben Roethlisberger started the year trying to recover from a motorcycle wreck and an emergency appendicitis surgery, and the Steelers were 2-6 (but finished 8-8).
Still, Tomlin deserves all the credit in the world for how elite the Steelers were in those early years. The problem is the Tomlin that these national pundits want so badly to continue romanticizing about. But to do that, they need to ignore that in the last 12+ seasons they have won three playoff games, they have missed the playoffs (five times) almost as many times as they have made the playoffs (seven times), and they have only won four division titles.
Tomlin is 3-8 in his last 11 playoff games, and while he has “never had a losing season,” he actually has — the postseason, where he is 8-9.
The most damning numbers about Tomlin, however, are that he is in his 17th season, and he has only won playoff games in four of the previous 16. Also, he is in the midst of a six-year drought of not winning playoff games, which is the longest in Steelers history since before Chuck Noll was hired. In his last three playoff games — despite all of his accolades as some sort of a defensive savant — the Steelers gave up a total of 135 points, an average of 45 per game, and two of those games were against Blake Bortles and Baker Mayfield.
They not only lose playoff games in recent years under Tomlin — they get skull-dragged and downright embarrassed.
These are facts. They aren’t emotions. They aren’t narrative-driven nonsense. They are facts and the fact is it has been a long, long time since Tomlin has been an elite coach in the NFL. And I don’t care that he wins regular-season games. The Steelers are a team that is supposed to be judged by how much they win playoff games. It isn’t realistic to think any team should win the Super Bowl regularly, but is it too much to ask an “elite coach” to win more playoff games than he loses?
Eisen also went to the bag of the tired oldies but goodies and talked about how if Tomlin were fired, he would have a job instantly and that the Steelers wouldn’t be able to hire anyone as good as him.
The problem with both arguments is that one is irrelevant, and the other is based on an assumption that the only “great” coaches out there might not be available.
The other nonsense I hear quite often is that Tomlin has done more with less than others, as if he has presided over the Little Sisters of the Poor and consistently gets them to overachieve. That is so idiotic, and I don’t even have to, nor will I dignify it.
Good coaches get fired all the time. Great coaches get fired from time to time. And they go on to get different jobs, but who cares?
There are times when a change is needed for both the coach and the franchise. The Steelers probably could benefit from fresh new ideas, and Tomlin probably would benefit from going somewhere else and being forced to find an edge and his fastball again. And given that the Steelers have only had to hire three coaches since 1969, it would seem they are good at getting the right guy.
Who that is, I don’t know. But I would simply say, “How about the next Mike Tomlin?” — a young, hungry riser with a fresh face and great energy and plan. If I had given a pen and piece of paper to 1,000 Steelers fans and said, “Write down your top ten choices to replace Bill Cowher,” there would be 10,000 names written on those papers, and I don’t know that Tomlin’s name would appear on a single on. Nobody knew who he was, but it turned out okay, so there are many good coaches available that may not even be on anyone’s radar.
The Steelers have five games left to try to get to the playoffs, and I guess it will take three wins for them to do it. If they do and then go on to win a playoff game, then Tomlin will have proven that maybe he still is the right guy for the job. Anything short of that, and I think the Steelers front office needs to at least think about making a change. Tomlin shouldn’t have a lifetime contract, and his recent history has been far closer to mediocrity than anything resembling elite.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.