Those of you who have read my columns over the years know I don’t do hot takes. I don’t say things to be shocking or just try to stir the pot. I never have and I never will.
When I write something, it is because I actually believe it and know it to be true.
That is why what I am about to write in this next sentence is something I thought I would never write but is the absolute truth.
NCAA women’s basketball is currently a better product than NCAA men’s basketball. And that was never more clear than on the biggest and brightest stage both games have to offer — the NCAA tournament and Final Four.
I have been a huge fan and advocate of women’s basketball for decades and have followed the sport as closely as anyone. I understood some of the criticisms of the game in the past. Many of them weren’t far off, but that never deterred me from watching because I never compared the men’s to the women’s games.
And never in my wildest dreams did I ever think that the women’s game would actually be a superior product to the men’s game, but here we are. It has happened, and I fear, for the men’s sake, it won’t be going back to the other way any time soon.
Read More
The biggest difference between the two?
The amount of star power that drives the best teams and the age of the superstars.
The women’s tournament had four of the best players in the country — Iowa’s Caitlin Clark, South Carolina’s Aliyah Boston, Virginia Tech’s Elizabeth Kitley and LSU’s Angel Reese. Boston will be the first pick in the WNBA draft. Kitley would be a top pick, but she is opting to return to Virginia Tech, and Reese and Clark both have at least one more season to play.
All four are elite players who helped carry their teams this season, but you know what else they have in common? None of them are freshmen or even sophomores. They have played at least three seasons of college basketball, and that makes a huge difference, as the biggest superstars are also seasoned veterans.
That is the biggest problem the men’s game has right now and in the future: The brightest stars, the elite, NBA-level talent is almost all freshman. What that means is the teams that have the most elite players are young, and it has become abundantly clear youth is not an asset in the NCAA tournament.
I’ll put it in more clear terms — imagine if Duke and Alabama kept all of their current freshmen together for four years. What would those two teams be like in Years 3 and 4?
Would anyone beat them? Both, however, fell victim to older, more physical teams, and that’s a part of it, too. Some people think parity is good for the product. I think, when you contrast the women’s tournament to the men’s tournament this year, it highlights just how much parity is really better described as mediocrity.
The women’s Final Four was exciting. It was full of high-level play from the game’s brightest stars. The men’s tournament was a whole lot of blah. As I wrote before the Final Four, there was exactly one player in the entire field of the Final Four that is projected as a first-round pick.
The advantage the women have over the men is that nobody leaves early. There is no one-and-done for the pros on the women’s side. If the women’s side were the same as the men with regards to going pro after one year, none of those four players I mentioned would have been in school to lead their teams anywhere. They would all be in the WNBA.
There are some people who need to be dragged kicking and screaming to understand the women’s product is better right now, but that’s mostly because they never watch it. I laugh when I hear people throw out the same dumb stereotypes about women’s basketball that may have loosely applied 20 years ago but certainly don’t apply now.
As I wrote before, I want to see the best players, the stars, the elite future pros play in the NCAA tournament and go at it in the Final Four. You can’t do that anymore in the men’s game because almost all of them are freshmen.
The women’s tournament was far better this year because the stars that drive attention to the sport were on full display the whole way through it. Clark put on a show, but so did Reese, so did Boston and so did Kitley throughout the tournament. So did so many of the best players.
One other thing — I am clearly not the only one who feels this way, as television ratings for the women’s championship game Sunday on ESPN set an all-time record, while the men’s ratings were down 16% from a year ago.
In fact, Sportico sports media reporter Anthony Crupi said this looks to be the fourth-least-watched Final Four in the Nielsen PPM era (1987-now).
Star power adds juice. People love watching stars. The women’s game, because all of the stars stay in school for four years, will always have that over the men’s game and now the talent around the stars is deep enough that it has better teams, stories and competition than the men.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.