It is that time of the NFL preseason when teams are faced with difficult roster decisions.

Cut down day looms, and there are a number of players who are going to get their last opportunity to put something good on tape this weekend as the preseason comes to a close.

I won’t be so bold as to try to predict who will and won’t make the Steelers’ roster. There aren’t likely to be many surprises, as it seems pretty clear who the overwhelming majority of the roster will be made up of.

There may be one or two surprises, but even those aren’t complete surprises, as it usually is a player who played their way on or off the roster in preseason games. We can all watch the games and see who is or isn’t getting it done, so even those “surprises” are generally just because of their status as undrafted or veteran or whatever.

Advertise with us

That’s why I won’t focus on the roster as a whole but rather focus on one key area where I believe there should be a mild surprise on the depth chart.

Najee Harris is obviously the starting running back, and there is no chance that will change any time soon. He will get the majority of carries and be that workhorse that carries the offense, and as long as he is healthy and doesn’t need a breather, he will be in the game.

His backup has long been regarded as Benny Snell. Snell has been with the team since 2019, and he has had some success over the course of time. He has been fairly reliable as a backup, and he has been a good special teams player with some value as a short-yardage back.

It was considered a foregone conclusion he would win the backup spot and be the running back who is one injury away from becoming the starter.

That would be a mistake because he is not the second-best running back on the roster, at least from what I have seen in my trips to training camp and watching the games.

Advertise with us

The first time I watched Jaylen Warren run the football in “inside run” drill periods, I was amazed by how low he runs, how hard he runs and how nimble he is. He is clearly a running back who hits the hole hard. He clearly doesn’t mind — and may even seek out — contact, and he can get tough yards after he is hit.

What sold me most, though, is he can also make defenders miss. He isn’t just a bowling ball. He isn’t just a guy who runs hard and physical. He has really good feet. I know it was just practice, but he was running against the first-team defense because Harris was being held out and Snell was banged up.

This isn’t likely to happen because Warren was an undrafted free agent, while Snell is established veteran. While it as been pretty clear to me which one is better, I am not the coaches and I am not the one watching film of every rep and comparing them.

Warren is more explosive, though, and quicker to the hole. He has more burst if the play bounces him to the outside and into the open field, as well.

My problem with Snell has always been the same: He is about a half-step slow, and he isn’t particularly explosive once he gets the ball in his hands. He is slow to the outside, and even the one thing he is supposedly a specialist at — getting short yardage — has been overrated.

Advertise with us

Anthony McFarland is the other player in the mix for this job, and I actually like his raw ability more than Snell’s. McFarland is fast, has quick feet and can wiggle out of trouble just like Warren. We have seen him used in specialty packages and on certain downs.

He can be a good change-of-pace running back, but he isn’t a full-time, every-down back in the NFL. That’s because he doesn’t have the total package; he isn’t great at getting yards after initial contact.

Warren runs hard. He runs physical. He plays fast. Yes, he has had a few fumbles, and that is ultimately what is likely to hold him back, but I enjoy watching him run.

Snell is sort of “Old Faithful,” and I understand loyalty, but he isn’t the best man for the job. He is limited in what he can be, and he has probably already hit that ceiling. He is not going to be better than he has been, and he is not going to magically find the extra burst of speed he currently lacks.

Mike Tomlin should reward Warren for his skill set, not Snell for his service time. Warren was an undrafted free agent, so he has long odds to even make the roster, but his performance in preseason games and in training camp has proven he is more than capable of handling the job.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise