The Pirates’ first Hall of Fame class includes 12 former players who are enshrined in baseball’s Hall of Fame, four former Negro League players, two beloved former players who had outstanding careers and a former manager.

That is 19 inductees in all, but they should have either made it 20 or replaced one of the deceased old-time legends with a legendary player who is actually still alive and could attend the ceremony.

The list is impressive, but why in the heck was Dick Groat — who is not only considered one of the greatest athletes in western Pennsylvania sports history but also a Swissvale native and one of the most popular and beloved sports stars in Pittsburgh history — omitted?

It makes absolutely no sense at all to have left Groat off this initial list. None.

Advertise with us

While we are at it, it makes no sense at all Barry Bonds is not included. Bonds is probably the greatest player in Pirates history. He won two (should have been three) MVPs. He carried them to their only three division titles since 1979 and is one of the five best baseball players to ever play the game. Yes, there are controversies about him and steroids, but none of that occurred when he played for the Pirates, so it shouldn’t be a part of the discussion.

That being said, I will at least listen to arguments Bonds can wait a year because of the controversies in his career and because he didn’t handle himself well or treat people well all the time. That argument is still garbage because being a jerk has nothing to do with how well you played baseball, but I will at least listen to it. Bonds is probably more popular among Pirates fans than people think, and it seems like as time rolls by he gains popularity, but he is a controversial figure, so if you want to punish him for it and keep him out, so be it.

I don’t agree with that, but I can at least listen to it.

It makes zero sense for Groat to not be a part of this first class, and that’s especially true when you put four guys in who never played for the Pirates. Now, think about this: You have four players who didn’t play for the Pirates in the Pirates’ Hall of Fame, and you don’t have Dick Groat, batting champ, MVP and World Series winner who grew up less than 10 miles from Forbes Field.

Mind you, I think it is great they included the Negro League players, and I think it is great the Pirates have been so good about honoring Pittsburgh’s glorious history with those leagues. It is an important part of our history, and the four Negro League players are all deserving of being included, especially because the rules of the day didn’t allow them to play in the Major Leagues.

Advertise with us

But the fact is they didn’t play for the Pirates, and I just can’t conceive of a thought process that includes them but doesn’t include Groat, one of the most popular and accomplished players in franchise history.

Groat isn’t a Baseball Hall of Famer, but neither is Dave Parker, Danny Murtaugh or Steve Blass, and I would argue Groat should be on this list given those three are on it. Parker’s and Groat’s Pirates resumes are similar. Groat played in six all-star games as a Pirate. He hit .300 or better three times, and he won a batting title and an MVP. He was a key member of one of the Pirates’ five World Series championships.

And here is the other thing: He is actually still alive, unlike just about every one of the older legends. He should be included in this class, so he can be there to be honored. That doesn’t mean he won’t be around next year — God willing, let’s hope he is around forever — but he is 91 years old. Why not make sure you can have him at the ceremony, make sure he gets celebrated like he should and make sure you have one of the few connections to that 1960 team that is still alive?

Jimmy Trdinich, the longtime Pirates PR guy who now is the team’s historian and one of the driving forces behind the Hall of Fame, was on 93.7 The Fan with the PM Team. He said, quite simply, the 19 players who were chosen were the most deserving based on their status as Hall of Famers. He said Parker and Murtaugh should be in the Hall of Fame, in the Pirates’ opinion, and Blass is in as much for what he has meant to the franchise as a broadcaster and ambassador as anything he did on the field.

“People need to remember there are more years to come; we can’t put 100 in the first year. These 19 are the most deserving members in our opinion,” said Jimmy Trdinich, who said Bonds, Groat and players like Elroy Face were all considered.

Advertise with us

Actually, the fact Trdinich said Bonds’ steroid controversies and off-field stuff were not considered in this makes his omission even worse. He should have went with, “He is a jerk, and we didn’t want to reward him.” At least that makes sense.

And if Parker and Murtaugh were given credit for “should be in the Hall of Fame,” why the heck is Bonds not in this Pirates’ Hall of Fame? I mean, his controversies were not included. He is maybe the best player in Pirates history. He should be in the Baseball Hall of Fame, but he has been kept out. For exactly what, then?

Halls of Fame are going to be controversial because there are always omissions. I get it. But Bonds and Groat being omitted from this first class is a farce. There is no way you can tell the story of the Pirates without either man, and Groat is a local and extremely popular former athlete and living legend. They should have both been included but especially Groat.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise