Zeise: OK let’s get started. Welcome back after a week off!!
Guest: Wouldn't Pitt and Notre Dame work nicely in the Big 10 ?
Zeise: I have yet to hear anyone tell me what Pitt adds to the Big Ten. It doesn’t add a new market and that’s a huge problem for Pitt
Dave: I’ve seen Pirate fans giddy about certain trades we made. Never mind the fact that the team is going to finish 68-94 & the player traded is a cy young contender. When did it not become about winning the games, isn’t that why they are played?
Zeise: It is about winning. They have maybe two pitchers that are gonna be standouts, they have a potential star shortstop of the future, a third baseman locked up, a young outfielder showing power - it is about winning but they are building for the future right now. There are some signs it could get a lot better
Jeff: Thanks for the chats Paul. With it comes to the pens it feels like we are going through this "here we go again" phase with the signing of Desmith and soon to be Letang. Whereas the pens are good and fun to watch they are still long shots to win the cup. If thats the goal then some pieces have to change. If not then we should start the rebuild NOW. I never thought I would say this but might be time to move Crosby for a boat load of pics and young talent. I know it is not a popular idea...but I am sure trading Gretsky wasnt either!
Zeise: I laugh at how defensive Penguins fans are when you point out they lost five playoff series in a row and stars aren’t getting any younger. If the goal is to get to the playoffs and lose in the first round, well they are on the right path
Grumpy Bear: Now we know that Van Meter can't pitch either. Position players pitching in games should be banned. What do you think?
Zeise: I just think there needs to be a mercy rule of sorts. Or expand the rosters to include three pitchers. You could make it like football - 29-man roster with three inactives every day so you still have 26-man active roster for games
Soggy: Good Morning Paul & thanks for the chat. What moves at the trade deadline do you see the Pirates making? If they move Reynolds or Bednar, do you think that diminishes the perception that the Pirates are truly trying to build consistent MLB caliber team?
Zeise: They should move Bednar. His value is never gonna be higher and a closer on a bad team going nowhere is not particularly usefill
Zeise: useful. If they aren’t gonna sign Reynolds long term they should trade him now while he still has a year of control beyond this and that makes him more valuable
Gregg from Shaler: Hi Paul, I’m a fan of your writing and generally agree. I’m nitpicking (but that’s what sports chats are for) but when you wrote that Ben was a “likely” HoFer were you trolling? I would say he’s a certain HoFer and “likely” first ballot.
Zeise: He is definitely a Hall of Famer. But “likely” is accurate because there is that .000001 percent he doesn’t make it!
Dave: Sorry Paul I didn’t see you wrote about the Pirates trades yesterday. But to include your article shouldn’t the Pirates be required to put forth a competitive team so trades like these aren’t necessary. They basically say we are not going to try for years at a time.
Zeise: This is what they are building towards and trying to do. They broke it down and now are trying to build it up
Mercury: Do you think Mitch Keller is ever going to amount to anything with the Pirates? Should they consider trading him while his potential may still be high in other teams’ eyes?
Zeise: No. They should trade him and move on from this ridiculous attempt to prove he can be a great pitcher. At this point he is what he is
ev: Paul, the realigned ACC (football conference) concerns me as Pitt is in an every year showdown with only three (four?) other schools, where neither has been a powerhouse. Is the ACC tiering their teams in preparation for separating from the conference? I am more comfortable with a two division system. With the new one, I would prefer Pitt to play Clemson, Miami or Fl State each year.
Zeise: I think Pitt fans need to chill out. It will all work out in the end. The two mega conferences need someone to play and that means the playoff will include other conferences. Pitt will be fine
Mercury: When was the last time you went to a theatre to watch a movie?
Zeise: A few weeks ago I saw the new Top Gun. What a fantastic movie
ev: Paul, Should Notre Dame join the ACC football conference, will both be saved from irrelevance (in wake of the Bigger 10plus and SEC mega conferences)?
Zeise: Notre Dame is going to join a conference and it will probably be the Big Ten. Their TV deal is no longer competitive with what the Big Ten can offer. They will never be irrelevant and always hold the key to whatever is next in expansion
ralph: Paul, sports in general doesn't align with the spirit of sports even 20 years ago. The $ being thrown around is hard to imagine , with the economy being what it is. It has become a money grab. hard to root for a team because the favorite players are already planning their escape for even more money. Where and when will it end.
Zeise: I believe the law of diminishing returns will kick in at some point and the money will have to be scaled back some everywhere except maybe the NFL
ev: Paul, Agreed, the return for the Jameson Taillon trade has benefitted the Pirates. But, wouldn't the Pirates be benefitted with Taillon, Cole, and Josh Bell still on the roster? Would they not be contending now?
Zeise: If ifs were fifths we would all be drunk. Those guys are gone all we can do is look forward
Retire21: Bad things come in threes. No wait transfer portal, NIL, conferences poaching new members. Pitt is a net loser in all this, don’t you think?
Zeise: I do not
Retire21: Cruz=Polanco?
Zeise: Cruz has shown me he has better instincts for baseball than Polanco did. But he needs to move to the outfield. That much seems clear to me from watching him at short so far
ev: Paul, who do you see the Pirates trading in the next few weeks? Newman, Gamel, Bednar?
Zeise: Camel and Yoshi. I would think Bednar perhaps. If someone takes Newman they should do it tomorrow!
Guest: While seemingly iron-clad, I have to think that somehow, lawyers for ACC institutions will find a way to get out of the grant of rights agreement. If/when that happens, do you see Pitt getting snapped up by the B1G or SEC; or, will they be destined to hope they are part of whichever conference sets themselves up to be #3? Basically, is Pitt attractive enough to sit at the 'big boy table' when this round of conference realignment gets sorted out?
Zeise: Again, I think Pitt will be fine. These leagues all need teams and will exist in some form. Pitt will be aligned with other really good institutions and programs and sustain a major program. I don’t know what it will all look like in the end but the doom and gloom stuff is silly
Retire21: Mason was gone the minute they drafted the second QB because they can’t count on the 7th rounder clearing waivers. Over/under August 1 as departure?
Zeise: I would say end of training camp unless there is an injury somewhere else and a team needs a quarterback. The number of trade partners won’t expand until the end of training camp when teams realize they don’t have a good backup or injuries or whatever. The Steelers will likely keep the charade going until they can find someone who will trade for him
Guest: Could you throw your two cents in regarding where Pitt and WVU will land with conference realignment and what's going to happen to the ACC and big 12?
Zeise: The PAC 12, Big 12 and ACC will look different and may even have some sort of partnership but I see almost none of the current teams - especially WVU and Pitt - being left out like UConn was the last time around. UConn was left out because their football program is worthless and in the end they are back in the league they should have been in all along
Tom in Punta Gorda: Hi Paul, I'm not in Punta Gorda anymore, Slippery Rock for a couple months. However I like saying Punta Gorda so I'm not changing the heading. Golf is great up here.
Zeise: Slippery Rock is very similar to Punta Gorda!
The Real TP Hunter: The Penguins seem convinced that bringing back the band will result in a better result next season. Is Hextall delusional or just hapless?
Zeise: i would say “not exactly a visionary” and not very creative. Hey if you bring back Malkin and Letang the Pens will continue to be a playoff team….. and not much more
Tom G: Why is such a big deal being made about Oneil Cruz's height in relationship to him playing Short?It would seem to be an advantage in his range and vertical leaping ability:Coupled with a cannon for an arm I don't understand the problem.
Zeise: I’ve seen some balls he should get to that he hasn’t and not because he wasn’t where he needed to be but because he couldn’t get his glove down
The Real TP Hunter: Have you ever seen a baseball team outside of Little League get clobbered as often as the Pirates this season? Will they have to teach all of their infielders how to pitch?
Zeise: It is ridiculous and makes a farce out of the sport
Where is My Clark Bar?: Paul, what percent chance would you give PITT basketball making the big dance this year?
Zeise: I’ll say 50/50. I mean they have clearly upgraded but they were 6-14 in ACC games last year so what is realistic in terms of a turnaround? I think they will definitely be an NIT team but the NCAA may be a step too far
Jerry: Paul let’s assume the rumors are true and Letang re-signs but Malkin departs for Carolina. Under that scenario I think the Penguins still make the playoffs for a 17th straight season. They did well enough last year when 71 was on IR. What are your thoughts?
Zeise: I would agree. But at this point, who cares if you can’t win in the playoffs
Where is My Clark Bar?: Paul, love reading your Steeler articles. As you point out, it is unlikely the Steelers give D. Johnson a new contract. What would be the harm in them restructuring his current contract for just this year giving him a little more money (out of respect and to keep him happy this year). He can then test the FA market at seasons end.
Zeise: There is no reason to do that he is either going to get a long term deal with the Steelers or find another homw
Bernard: Odds Notre Dame ends up in B10?
Zeise: I would say 65-70 percent chance
Mary Kay Cabot: Hi Paul. Baker & I shared a good laugh yesterday. He said the $3 Million he lost was worth it to get out of that hellhole situation. He also said he will make that back, make more in commercials down there.
Zeise: He has to be happy he is out of Cleveland. But he is playing with a bad team
Andrew Ross NYC: Listen, I know every PITT fan wants to see Pickett start from day one. I get it. I grew up in squirrel hill, near Oakland where Dan Marino played. Only reason Steelers didn’t take Marino is because they thought he smoked dope. They missed bigly. Pickett couldn’t carry Marino’s jock strap. He’s old and has a low ceiling. Now trubisky has tools and could be the next great one. Better than the guy that resurrected his career with titans. What day you ? Still scratching my head about drafting cam’s brother and the late QB selection.
Zeise: I think the Steelers have the right path - play Trubisky this year and let Pickett grow and learn and take over next year. That’s the right approach
The Real TP Hunter: Penn State seems certain of locking in a berth in whatever college super football conference emerges from the current turmoil, but I wonder why Pitt is overlooked? The Nittany Lions, for all of their success on the field, have won only two national championships. Pitt won nine. Granted, Penn State's facility and fan base is much larger, but if Pitt continues to trend upward, why is it seemingly relegated to the second tier by the college football "experts" when super conferences are discussed?
Zeise: Because Penn State has the largest alumni base in the country and 110,000 fans in the stands. They bring fans and ratings and attention
Andrew Ross NYC: What up with trade of ex Cleveland #1 pick, QB Baker REGAN mayfield. I guess his parent’s were from the GOP? I think he is better than Mason R. We should have swapped Rudolph for him! Good riddance! That guy weren’t same after helmet incident when uttered slur.
Zeise: I have no idea what that word salad means
Andrew Ross NYC: What is next with football conferences
Zeise: There will be a lot of movement, it will be declared over as everyone is happy and 5-7 years down the road we will do it all over again
Andrew Ross NYC: will WVU join SEC. just the thought of it gets my JUICE to flow !
Zeise: I am not sure what WVU adds to the SEC
Manny Banuelos: Hola Paul. Should I worry after last night about being DFAed again? I haven't really unpacked everything yet.
Zeise: You will survive a few more weeks. But what we saw last night was not encouraging!
Andrew Ross NYC: shout out today my man Ed Lev and the salads he makes
Zeise: OK!
Andrew Ross NYC: big ups to narduzie recruiting class. Pitt is a middle of the road program and he recruits a little better than that. But he better for the booku money tax payers pay him !! LOL
Zeise: Your
Zeise: You are proving true the idea that it is Happy Hour somewhere, every minute, every day!
Ryan: Good afternoon Paul who do the pens need to sign when free agency starts or what changes do they have to make
Zeise: If they resign Malkin and Letang they won’t have money to make any significant moves or changes
Bruce: If the ACC breaks up, like many are predicting, where does that leave Pitt football?
Zeise: Pitt will be fine once the dust settles. Pitt will be fine once the dust settles. Pitt will be fine once the dust settles. Rinse, repeat, rinse repeat
Jack Johnson: Hey Paul. You were away. Jack Johnson is a Stanley Cup Champion! Repeat that! Plus The Penguins still have to pay off part of my salary after my buyout. So life is good, brah.
Zeise: You are doing it! A lot of people in this town doubted you but here you are a champion!
chuk: How long will we have to watch Shelton prove he is a terrible manager? The man is clueless on how to use a pitching staff and has no feel for the game and players.
Zeise: At least another year. I can’t see them moving on from him until after next season no matter er what happens
Zeise: Thanks for joining us!!! Let’s do it next week!!




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.