There are many things wrong with the economics of Major League Baseball, but perhaps the worst is the number of teams who are pretending to care about winning and losing. Actually, scratch that because these days owners don’t even have to feel embarrassed about fielding teams that have no chance of winning because, well, it seems like everyone is doing it.

OK, not everyone. The Dodgers and Yankees and a handful of others still spend like they care about winning, but for the most part, it is almost like three quarters of the majors are in some form of rebuilding from “we tore it all the way down” to “we want to tear it all the way down.”

This was and will be on full display these next few days at PNC Park as the Pirates play host to the Cubs. Maybe, instead of calling these teams by their nicknames, we can refer to them by their status as actual contenders. You know, Monday “Year 3 of a rebuild” plays host to “Year 2 of a rebuild” or something similar to that.

There is a big difference, though, between the teams economically, but both highlight what is wrong with baseball. One team can’t compete and isn’t forced to because they don’t make anywhere close to the money the richest teams make. That’s bad enough, but it is markedly worse that the other has the money to compete and has chosen to pocket it.

Advertise with us

If you think there is a lot of pain and misery in Pittsburgh for fans and media following the Pirates, just imagine what it is like following the Cubs. I mean, the Pirates are at least a small-market team and funds are limited and the system is stacked against them. Fans are used to this and all that good stuff, but what the heck is the Cubs’ excuse?

Why aren’t they spending real money and trying to win? Why did they break up a core that included Kris Bryant, Javy Baez and Anthony Rizzo less than a season removed from a playoff berth?

They hadn’t won in the playoffs since 2017 when they got to the NLCS and lost to the Dodgers, but that is a pretty good core of players — especially when you add Wilson Contreras and Ian Happ to the core — to build a team around. And they had just made the playoffs in 2020, so it isn’t like they couldn’t have added a few pieces, kept their payroll among baseball’s highest and taken another run or two at a World Series.

As it is, they have a $148 million payroll, which is a whole lot of money to pay for a terrible team that feels like it might be further away from contending than the Pirates. And that is saying a whole lot because the Pirates are perpetually rebuilding, so who knows how long it will be before they are contenders again.

The worst part is that $148 million is actually propped up by a horrific contract for Jason Heyward that was signed long ago when the Cubs operated like a large-market team. Heyward is the definition of a painfully average player (career .257 hitter, has hit 20 home runs or more only twice in his career, career OPS+ of 101) that somehow tricked the WAR stat enough to get paid like a superstar. He apparently is an incredible fielder, as well, based on the three amazing highlight throws he makes a season to get someone out at the plate.

Advertise with us

Heyward signed an 8-year, $184 million contract in 2016, and the Cubs are still saddled with it, meaning they are on the hook for $49 million over this year and next. That’s a lot of money for a guy slashing .198/.271/.281. That’s precisely why he is still with the Cubs, as there is no way in the world any other team is taking that contract off their hands.

In short, they would love to get that number of their books but are stuck with it, which means their actual payroll (just above league average at $148.1 million) is far higher than their desired payroll of $123 million (payroll minus Heyward).

That number is an embarrassment for a market as big as Chicago and a team and ownership group as rich as the Ricketts family, which owns the Cubs. And embarrassment would be a good way to describe their performance Monday, in which they struck out a bunch, booted balls, walked guys and threw wild pitches in a sloppy loss to the Pirates. The Pirates won 12-1 but mostly because the running clock mercy rule kicked in — or at least it should have.

Chicago Sun-TImes columnist Rick Morrissey scorched the Cubs for this strategy recently after it was made clear Cubs management did not want people to refer to whatever it is they are doing as rebuilding. Wait, does that sound familiar Pirates fans?

Morrissey’s column was the perfect mixture of irreverence, humor and straight heat, but I had to take a few steps back to make sure I wasn’t reading a column about Bob Nutting and company. Of course, as I wrote before, at least Nutting and company have a built-in excuse, are saddled with small-market blues and truly don’t have huge revenue streams from cable deals and things of the such available to compete with the big spenders in baseball.

Advertise with us

Morrissey wrote:

“The Cubs lose at home (7-15), they lose in one-run games (4-11) and they lose interleague games (1-4). They strike out a lot, and they give up a lot of home runs.

They have some players I’ve never heard of, which isn’t a problem. That their parents haven’t heard of them is. If you’re Cubs management (and I’m sorry if you are), is it worse to say you’re rebuilding or to say you’re awful at your job? Me, I’d much prefer the pain of rebuilding to the shame of being awful at my job.”

He later noted, “Here’s the ‘cycle’ the Cubs are in: Their player payroll has gone from the third-highest in the league ($221.6 million in 2019) to the 14th-highest ($147.6 million this season). They’re an alleged major-market team. An alleged major-market team that isn’t rebuilding. OK, got it.”

It is one thing to write these things about the Pirates because, again, there are certain built-in forces that make it difficult for them to compete regularly. But the Cubs have no excuse to be run the way they are being run, and quite frankly, it is embarassing how bad they are and how little hope they have.

Advertise with us

I would say Major League Baseball should intervene, but that would assume the league cares that many teams operate in this manner — pocket loads of cash, put crap product on field — and there is far too much evidence these days that is not the case.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise