There is no crying in baseball, well unless you are a Pirates fan and just got done reading the new collective bargaining agreement reached by the owners and players. There is nothing good in it for the Pirates or any small market team, but frankly we knew that was going to be the case anyway.
Major League Baseball in this town needed this collective bargaining agreement to change some of the fundamental flaws in its economic system. I am actually struggling to find one meaningful thing that has changed that will help the Pirates and teams of their ilk truly compete with the large market teams.
I’m still looking, by the way, and that’s a waste of time, to be honest, because there is nothing in there, nothing at all.
And please, spare me the stuff about international drafts, 12-team playoffs, the luxury tax threshold going up and pre-arbitration bonus pools because none of that stuff is significant and most of it actually hurts the smaller market teams.
Oh wait, my bad, there is a universal DH, doubleheaders will be 9-inning games again and they will no longer put a guy on second base in extra innings! Plus, the Pirates get to play every team in the American League now, and there is some mess about bigger bases.
Heck, that does it, that solves it. World Series parade on the Boulevard of the Allies here we come, baby!
Read More
THIS is what they argued about for six months and wasted all of our time with doomsday scenarios about cancelling the season and going bankrupt?
Please, give me a break and get out of here with the idea that we are supposed to celebrate the fact that baseball is back simply because it is back. There is no better sports experience in this town than a warm summer night at PNC Park, but what exactly is the incentive to go more than a few times a summer when the home team has very little chance to be legitimate contenders?
Teams can still spend whatever they want, teams can spend as little as they want and the richest teams in the largest markets don’t have to share any more of their revenue than they already did. The Dodgers, Yankees and Red Sox will still buy up all the best players, and teams like the Pirates will still sell the idea that bargain basement guys like Jose Quintana have a fountain of youth to tap into.
The worst part of all of this is that the owners approved this CBA by a vote of 30-0. That’s right all 30 owners, including Pirates owner Bob Nutting, voted to accept this deal. They all, including Nutting, signed off on it, and that tells me they are all OK with the economic system as it is.
That is the second part of this that should make Pirates fans cry, but that sadness should quickly turn to anger if Nutting doesn’t now do his part to make the team competitive. He signed off on the deal which means he believes the economic system is fine and the Pirates can compete within it.
As part of this deal there is roughly $60 million per team from the national television deal and another $40-$45 million in shared revenues. That’s a $100 million check given to every team before we even get to all of the local TV and broadcast deals, the tickets sold and all the other ways teams make money.
There are no more excuses for Nutting not to spend money on payroll. None. I don’t want to hear about how hard it is to survive, I don’t want to hear any more pity party stories about how unfair it is that the Pirates can’t sign players they want or — better yet — need.
The Pirates should not be given a single pass for the next five years for a low payroll. They shouldn’t be able to get away with selling pipe dreams about how the calvary is on the way from minor leagues, so just wait a few years and the payroll will increase.
I don’t have a lot of hope that any of that will happen, by the way. My guess is we will still be sold on the idea that the Pirates are building through the draft and acquiring prospects and thus don’t need to spend money on the payroll. I am sure when the quality free agents sign everywhere else we will be lectured on how the goal isn’t to “win the offseason but to win in the season.”
The Pirates never win the offseason and rarely win during the season, either. Thanks to this collective bargaining agreement, we’ve likely signed on for five more years of this.
Nutting signed on for this, though, so there are no longer any acceptable excuses for why the Pirates have a payroll that is ⅕ of the Dodgers’ and among the five smallest in the major leagues.
Fans in large markets may be rejoicing that baseball is back, but Pirates fans should be crying as nothing has changed that benefits their favorite team.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.