Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. You can also chat about all sports with Paul at noon Thursdays. If you want to ask a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Bob L: If Pitt wins the ACC championship, will Pat Narduzzi leave for a better job or will he use it to get a raise? And do you think the new contracts for James Franklin and Mel Tucker will impact what Narduzzi can ask for?
Zeise: I honestly don’t think Narduzzi is going to go anywhere else. I know he has had his name thrown into the Notre Dame situation, but it sounds to me like they are just going to promote their defensive coordinator. Narduzzi is loyal and more importantly he knows he has a great job and now he has some leverage. It won’t shock me if he pushes for a new contract, new facilities and more money for his assistants — or some combination of those three things if he wins the ACC. And you better believe the market that has been set, not just by Tucker and Franklin, but Brian Kelly and Lincoln Riley, will be on the mind of Narduzzi’s agent when he approaches Pitt.
Hammer Z: Has Kenny Pickett made himself a first round draft choice by the way he has played? Will Jordan Addison stay at Pitt or decide to go to the NFL draft?
Zeise: I think Pickett has definitely elevated his draft stock, but I would be careful trying to guess where he is going to be drafted. You have to remember the NFL hasn’t even begun the formal scouting process on these guys. There is the combine, There are the interviews, the private workouts, the pro days — it is a long process and a lot of players will get evaluated and some players’ stock will rise and others will fall. The process is just beginning. And I think Addison has to stay one more year before he is eligible for the NFL draft.
Read More
Hal: If the Steelers moved on from Mike Tomlin as everyone suggests they should, who could they get to do a better job? Why do people forget so quickly that they won a Super Bowl with him and almost won a second?
Zeise: I have said many times the line of “who can you get that’s better” is the worst and dumbest reason to keep a coach in place. I don’t think they should fire Mike Tomlin. He has earned the right to try and work through this rebuilding process. But the idea he has a lifetime contract just because he won a Super Bowl more than a decade ago is silly. It is a bottom-line business and the bottom line is production. When the Steelers hired Tomlin, nobody knew who he was. And he has been an incredible success. There are a lot of great coaches out there, many who just need a chance to show what they can do.
Amy: Do you think that the Steelers will get the most out of TJ Watt’s contract? He seems to have a lot of injuries and miss too many games. Is this just a bad stretch for his health or a trend?
Zeise: That is a great question. I have no idea what the future holds, but so far it hasn’t been a good start to his new contract. He has the profile of a player whose body breaks down because he plays so hard and is in involved in so many violent collisions. It happens to a lot of players in the NFL, so it wouldn’t be unique to him.
Jason: Why did the Steelers draft Najee Harris if they are going to use him correctly? Why don’t they give him the ball more early in games and see if he can get some momentum?
Zeise: I think they abandon the run too quickly. I think they did it last year, too. I know they haven’t had a lot of success, but offensive lines need time to come together. It is really difficult to do that when you run one or two times in the first quarter of a game then fall behind. I think they need to commit to becoming a better rushing team. I think the offensive line will only get better at run blocking if they are given the opportunity to actually do it early and often.
Engstock: Do you like James Franklin's extension at Penn State? If they lose him there's no guarantee they find someone who'll do as well or better. But there's really not much protection for the school. Even having to pay back $2 million if he leaves in two years isn't much disincentive.
Zeise: I do not. I do not think Penn State needed to give it to him this year. He was already signed through 2025, so what was the hurry? He is 11-10 in his last two seasons. I think he is a good coach. I think he has recruited well and the future is bright. But Penn State should have told him, “Prove it next year and then we will talk about a big raise and extension.” I just don’t see what the hurry was, especially since it was clear he was not at the top of the list of either LSU or USC, so he didn’t really have much leverage.
Lucas: Why in the world would Penn St. Athletic Director Sandy Barbour give James Franklin a 10 year contract extension? He is just 11-10 since last season.
Zeise: Well, I just made that point in the above answer but I will go further — the Penn State administration (president and AD) are lame ducks. They don’t need to worry about the consequences. And I don’t think they wanted their last act to be losing a football coach who has had some degree of success. They also want part of their legacy to be they left the football program in great shape and in doing this, there is at least a plan for long-term success.
Marty: What is the plan for the Pirates? I can’t figure out what the end game is here. Why are they still trading and waiving players who they could actually win some games with if they build around them?
Zeise: I have no idea what they are doing, either. These moves they have made in the past week suggest they are planning on another year of not being competitive. And they are trying to compile prospects and young players again. It isn’t going to go over well with their fans, so for their sake, I hope that in the long run it works out. But this plan doesn’t seem to be an actual plan at this point.
Engstock: And what about the Jacob Stallings trade when you have no catchers on your 40 man roster?
Zeise: Well, you get two questions this week because this is a good one. The Stallings situation made no sense. He is one of the best defensive catchers in baseball and they had a few more years of control of him. He should still be here. Trading him is one of those moves that suggests next year is not important. And then they go and sign Roberto Perez, who isn’t as good at the plate and isn’t as good behind the plate. I don’t quite get why they would move on from Stallings.
Rob S: Should the Pirates trade Ke’Bryan Hayes or Bryan Reynolds or both now and get as much as they can for them since they are still apparently in rebuild mode?
Zeise: I am beginning to think so. I am beginning to think that this team is so far away from contention that by the time they are ready to win, both Reynolds and Hayes will on the verge of becoming too expensive. My thing is if they are trying to acquire talent now, they should trade these two and get a large haul of quality prospects. I can’t imagine those two would want to be a part of another season or two with no hope of winning.
Chad: Do you think the Pittsburgh market could support a 4th major sports team, I.E.-the NBA, MLS, etc?
Zeise: No, I do not, at least not an NBA team. You need a lot more corporate money than there is available in order to pull that off. It just isn’t viable. And I am not sure there is enough of a market in this town for soccer for an MLS team to fly. I mean, the Riverhounds have been here for a long time and have a loyal following but it is small and often they don’t even fill Highmark Stadium. That’s not to say there isn’t a market for soccer or basketball in Pittsburgh, it is to say I don’t think there is enough of a market to sustain a major franchise in either sport.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.