Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. You can also chat about all sports with Paul at noon Thursdays. If you want to ask a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Marty: Why isn’t Bud Dupree the Steelers number one priority to sign this offseason? The defense really needs him, there was a clear step backwards when he was out.

Zeise: I think he is a priority, but I don’t think they can ultimately afford him. There is some pipe dream out there that he is going to take a hometown discount and take a small one-year deal to prove he is healthy. I still have not had a single person who floats that out there explain to me why he would do that. It makes absolutely no sense when other teams are willing to give him big money, a multi-year deal and a decent chunk guaranteed. The Steelers don’t have the luxury of doing that and have made it clear that their priority is signing T.J. Watt and giving him big money.

Advertise with us

Dasken L: What is a deal for T.J. Watt going to look like? Aren’t edge rushers getting quarterback money these days? Should the Steelers think hard before signing him?

Zeise: Myles Garrett got 5 years, $125 million so that’s where Watt will START his negotiations. I think that is lunacy but I get it — in a passing league, rushing the passer is critical to success. I think the Steelers need to sign him, but man, that is a huge chunk of change for one player who doesn’t have the ball in his hands every play. The Steelers defense is predicated on getting pressure on the quarterback and Watt is one of the best in the business.

Don: Isn't if possible that one of the main reasons that the majority of fans "don't want Ben to return" is actually the disappointment with our salary cap situation? If Patrick Mahomes came here for a $41M cap hit how far could the Steelers really go with their situation. Even a restructure isn't likely to make 2021 Super Bowl run. Misplaced anger in the City of Champions?

Zeise: No, I think people are on the right path, actually. Roethlisberger’s cap hit is not justified by his performance. And the biggest thing is if they cut him, they could make the rest of the roster better with the money they saved. I actually agree with the people who say it is time to move on from Roethlisberger. He doesn’t make the Steelers a Super Bowl team, so what is the point of bringing him back? That’s just how I see it.

Earl: Doesn’t the last ten years prove the Steelers need to move on from Ben Roethlisberger? He no longer leads them anywhere except the island of disappointment every year.

Advertise with us

Zeise: Well there is that, too. The Steelers have paid him roughly $193 million over the past decade, which translates into about $64 million per playoff win. That isn’t what I would call getting bang for your buck. I am willing to bet that they could have achieved three playoff wins and spent a third of that on quarterbacks. Yes, it is time.

Amy: Is there any chance at all that the Penguins could trade Evgeni Malkin at the trade deadline? He looks like he doesn’t want to be here any more and I think the Penguins would be better off without him and with some younger talent to come back in return.

Zeise: I don’t think you make yourself better when you trade a superstar midseason in most cases. There are exceptions, but I don’t know that selling when his value is low is the way to go. He needs to just get his head out of, well, you know where, and start playing better. Tuesday night was a good start, but there is an asterisk: He always plays well when Sidney Crosby is out. The Penguins need him to start playing better — that, not trading him, is how they will get maximum value out of him.

Jason: Does the fact that there are severely restricted limits on attendance at Pirates and Penguins games mean the ticket prices will be sky high? Can normal people still afford to go?

Zeise: I just looked online to see what the secondary market is for Penguins tickets and was pleasantly surprised. Don’t get me wrong they are expensive, but hockey tickets are expensive in any year. But they didn’t seem way out of line as I saw some as low as $90 or so. Again, that is a lot, I know, but it doesn’t seem to be that out of line. As for Pirates tickets, well, at any capacity the law of supply versus demand will kick in at some point so just wait until later in the season, and I am sure you can afford to go.

Advertise with us

Nate: What do you think of this new spring-training rule that MLB Managers can end innings or the games whenever they want to? How does that help prepare players for a 162 game season?

Zeise: The thinking is that pitchers need to ease their way back into pitching on a regular basis. There has been a lot of down time the last two years for all of the players, and they are trying to avoid overworking pitchers. So they have a mercy rule which states managers of the team playing defense can end an inning if the pitcher has thrown more than 20 pitches. Also, games can be shortened. It is important to remember that the entire premise is to try and gets players prepared, slowly but surely, for the regular season.

Lucas: Heather Lyke has been the Pitt A.D. for 4 years now. How much blame should she get for the blah state of the university's athletics programs?

Zeise: I think you are letting the plight of the football and basketball programs cloud your judgement. And yes, in many ways those are the only two that really ultimately matter in terms of revenue and exposure but the rest of the sports all seem to be doing well. The soccer programs are really good, and the men were ranked No. 1 at one point. The women’s volleyball team is excellent. The baseball program and softball program are improving a lot as is the women’s basketball program. I think basketball is on its way back, it seems like the right coach (Jeff Capel) is in place. And football has a lot of players coming back and may have its best year in a long time next season. The athletic department also has achieved something that hasn’t happened in a long, long time over there — a level of stability and consistency of leadership. I think Pitt’s best days are ahead.

Eddie: I heard your interview with Pitt baseball coach Mike Bell the other day. What are his roots and Is it realistic to believe Pitt, a school in the Northeast, can ever get to the College Baseball World Series?

Advertise with us

Zeise: That’s a great question. I did a little research and it is worse than I thought. Since 2000, the total number of “northern” teams not from the West Coast to make the College World Series is four: Kent State (2012), Michigan (2019), Notre Dame (2002) and Stony Brook (2012). So yes, the odds are stacked against northern teams but the fact these programs did it suggests there is a chance. Pitt has a great manager in Bell, and if he can continue to build the pitching staff like he has, the sky is the limit.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise