Derek Shelton seems like a very well respected and excellent baseball manager with a good plan for the Pirates. It already seems like his laid back demeanor has been a welcome change.
Ben Cherington has said all the right things, obviously has a lot of pedigree and seems to be extremely intelligent. The same can be said about Travis Williams and we’re familiar with his work because of his time with the Penguins.
This should be a time of unlimited optimism for Pirates fans. Unfortunately that doesn’t seem to be the case, and that isn’t the fault of the new management team. Pirates fans as a group are beaten down by the last couple of seasons. They had a taste of success from 2013-15 and got their hopes and expectations up.
Some of that blame is on the shoulders of Bob Nutting. He isn’t the evil puppet master that some people want to make him out to be, but he has certainly made a lot of moves to turn his fan base off. One of them is that he probably stayed with the previous management team one year too long.
I understand why he did, as he, like so many, wanted to believe that they would be able to capture the same lightning in a bottle that they found in that three-year run of wild-card teams. The problem is the team was getting worse, not better, and the management team was becoming more and more detached from reality.
This group, though, is new and deserves a shot, but they won’t get nearly as long of one as they deserve. This is a rebuild job that could take three or four years, and I’m not sure the majority of the Pirates’ fan base is willing to give this group that much time to get it right. Certainly, there needs to be some signs of improvement at every step of the way.
Read More
It isn’t fair to the new group that there is so little margin for error, but life isn’t always fair. Cherington told my colleague Jason Mackey that he believes Nutting will do the right thing and put money into the team once it is ready to win. That is something we’ve all heard in the past, and frankly there’s no reason for fans to believe it this time, either.
“I’m confident [payroll] will increase over time as we get deeper into our team build, there’s opportunity and we get closer with those opportunities,” Cherington said. “I’m confident we’ll have the means to build a winning team and add pieces. We’re not putting any kind of date on when that could happen. We’re going to try and get there as soon as we can. That’s an every-day thing.”
That last part about the fact that there is no timetable is what should have fans a little nervous. If there isn’t a timetable, then it’s fair to ask — when will the time actually be right? And how will they know it is time to spend?
Also, what will spending look like? I mean, the payroll right now is about $51 million. If the payroll were to jump to, say, $65 million, that would indeed be an increase, but what exactly would that do to put the Pirates closer to winning?
Skepticism and cynicism are rampant when it comes to Nutting and the Pirates. He at some point will need to step up and prove Cherington’s words aren’t just more of the same kind of wishful thinking that this team has specialized in for far too long.
In the meantime the best thing Shelton, Cherington and Williams can do is what they have done. They have to continue to say the right things, try to engage fans and be optimistic and realistic all at the same time.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.