James Conner has one of the most inspirational stories in recent sports history, beating cancer to become a Pro Bowl NFL player. JuJu Smith-Schuster is by all accounts a good citizen and a player who has immersed himself into the Pittsburgh community.

They are deservedly fan favorites, and both are supposed to be the stars of the Steelers offense. But when we write list of things that went wrong with the Steelers this season, both will be at or near the top of it.

Neither player has given the Steelers anything close to what they needed from them. They are both putting the finishing touches on disappointing seasons, and while there are a variety of reasons for that, it doesn’t change the fact that both need to be much bigger factors in 2020, regardless of who is the quarterback.

Smith-Schuster has dropped too many passes, made too few plays and fumbled once too many times to be considered anything but a disappointment. He has only three touchdown receptions and is averaging 49 yards receiving per game.

Advertise with us

Conner hasn’t been anywhere close to the dominant rusher he was last season, averaging just 46.4 yards per game and scoring only four touchdowns.

Conner has played in 10 games, Smith-Schuster has played in 11. Yes, injuries have been a factor, but injuries are a part of the NFL. I can’t honestly give you more than a few impact plays either made while they were playing.

Look, its one thing if we were talking about the third or fourth receiver or one of the cavalcade of practice squad running backs on the Steelers, but we aren’t. We are talking about the two players who were supposed to step in and be the top receiver and top running back.

Conner showed glimpses that he can be that last year but took a step back in 2019. Smith-Schuster showed last year he can be a star when he was the No. 2 and playing with Antonio Brown. Many people assumed his transition would be easy. Many people were wrong. And it looks like they were not only wrong, they were dead wrong.

There is absolutely something to the fact that the two suffered without having Ben Roethlisberger around and had to play with subpar quarterbacks all season long. But the quarterbacks aren’t the reason Smith-Schuster is dropping passes and not making plays, nor are the quarterbacks the reason Conner didn’t break many tackles or make many people miss.

Advertise with us

The Steelers obviously have a lot of issues on offense that need to get fixed. Some of them will be fixed when Roethlisberger comes back. Some, however, will not and even Roethlisberger will struggle to be successful if Conner doesn’t revert back to form and Smith-Schuster doesn’t become the playmaker he was last season.

The good news is the Steelers have one more game this season for both players to try and help win. Conner may be out, though, as he left the game Sunday against the Jets with an injury, but Smith-Schuster can play. It’s possible both players could at least end this season on a high note (assuming Conner can play) by helping the Steelers win and get into the playoffs (with some help).

Short of that, though, this will go down as a really disappointing season for both players. It doesn’t mean they are bad, and it doesn’t change that they are both fan favorites. But it does mean they have a lot to prove in 2020.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise