Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. You can also chat Steelers with Paul at noon Thursdays. If you want to ask a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Hunter: Why is it out of the question to alternate series between Rudolph and Duck and then stick with whoever is doing the best as the game goes on? The Arizona Cardinals did this with Matt Leinhert and Kurt Warner to some degree of success.

Paul: I’ve heard lots of theories and lots of different ideas about how to improve the Steelers offense. I can honestly say this is one I had not heard, and there is probably a good reason: No offense, but it is the worst idea I’ve ever heard. These are two young quarterbacks who struggle even when they get all of the snaps all week long at practice. It is not even something they should consider. This would be a disaster. It is bad enough we have the rotating door at running back and receiver, could you really imagine what would happen if we threw quarterback in that mix, as well? There is no way this could work with the two quarterbacks we are talking about. The Steelers just need to simplify their offense and stick with it.

Advertise with us

Joe: Does the Pirates’ first "big" free-agent signing, that being a catcher who has a career batting average of .198, signal that nothing has changed with this franchise?

Paul: But wait, he is an elite-level pitch framer! I would say you should not read anything more into this signing than what it is - they got a very low cost insurance policy at a position of need. I bet they will sign at least one more catcher. They are not done ... they are just getting started. And Luke Maile is a perfect backup catcher because of his defense. I will be shocked if they go into the season with Maile and Jacob Stallings as their only two catching options.

Jonathan: Don’t get me wrong, I love Minkah Fitzpatrick and know he is a great player, but I still think it was a big mistake for the Steelers to trade their first round pick away to get him. They are going to need that to get a quarterback because it is clear they don’t have their quarterback of the future on their roster. What are your thoughts?

Paul: I have to disagree. Fitzpatrick has been the missing link to that defense. He has made everyone else better on that defense because they know he is back there to clean up their mess. They can all take some chances now and that’s why they are able to be so aggressive. And look at what he has done to help Steven Nelson and Joe Haden. Those two have played great but a big factor is what Fitzpatrick does. It is true they gave up a lot, but who is to say their quarterback of the future would be in next year’s draft, anyway? And they are going to draft around No. 20 or so, which means they weren’t going to get one of the best quarterbacks on the board anyway.

Coach TJ: Is there any chance at all that if Pitt loses to Eastern Michigan that Pat Narduzzi will be fired? I like the idea of continuity but is it really smart if all it means is that things are stagnant and not getting better?

Advertise with us

Paul: You bring up a really good point — when is continuity for the sake of continuity actually a bad thing? I never really thought about it like that. I understand what you are saying but there is no way Narduzzi will or should get fired even if they lose the Quick Lane Bowl to Eastern Michigan. Narduzzi has built a good foundation, he has recruited well and he has established an identity for Pitt football. He seems to be close to a breakthrough. To quit now would be really dumb. He definitely needs to be put on notice that he needs to start winning more, but this is not the time to change course on the program. If he has another mediocre/subpar year next year, then maybe that is a discussion that needs to be had. But he needs to be given another offseason and recruiting class to prove he can get it all the way right.

Ron: Any idea why Pitt and Duquesne men's basketball teams didn't have the City Game this year?

Paul: Yes, Pitt didn’t want to play it. More specifically, Jeff Capel didn’t want to play it. He was not on board completely with playing at Robert Morris to open the Colonials’ new building. And he basically didn’t have much of a choice in that one, so the compromise was simple — take a year off from the Duquesne game. I think it is silly, but all of these coaches are ridiculous when it comes to these scheduling discussions. Pitt should play both Robert Morris and Duquesne every year, and Duquesne should play both Pitt and Robert Morris every year. It shouldn’t even be a question.