Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Thomas: Convince me the Buccos aren’t just rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic?

Paul: You know, when I walked into the interview with Bob Nutting the other day, all I could hear in my head was ‘“near, far, wherever you are.” OK, that was bad, I know, but it made me laugh. I would say this — Travis Williams is not an old guy. He has a big future and long career in front of him. I don’t believe a guy with his pedigree would get into a situation unless he believed he could have success. If he takes the job and it fails, it really would harm his career. I think even if you don’t trust Bob Nutting, you should give Williams a chance. I think he is smart and has a good plan and good idea where he needs to take the Pirates.

Advertise with us

Jared: Do you think Bob Nutting only planned on firing Clint Hurdle, then changed his mind and fired Frank Coonelly and Neal Huntington when fan backlash grew?

Paul: I know there are some who are convinced the pressure put on Nutting had an impact, but I don’t agree. In talking with him and listening to what he had to say I think he had a plan to clean house starting in about August. I think the timing of it all seems to be because he wanted to do his due diligence and have a transition team in place. He said he thought about making changes back in August.

Teddy: I think the Steelers should trade Ben and get a pick or player(s) for this year. With Ben coming back it will be the same old one dimensional passing game ultimately going nowhere. It’s over. The future is in Rudolph and Hodges. What are your thoughts?

Paul: Ask me in about five or six games when I have a better idea of who they have in Mason Rudolph. If he proves he can be a competent NFL quarterback and leads the Steelers to wins, then I’d say yes. If Rudolph is the future and he essentially plays an entire season at a high level, why would you want to put him on the bench for a year or two? At that point, I’d say trade Roethlisberger and get some of the picks you’ve traded away back.

Harold: Sunday is the halfway point of the Steelers’ season. Who are your picks for the offensive and defensive MVPS at this point? I don’t know if there is a good candidate on offense yet.

Advertise with us

Paul: The defensive MVP is easy: TJ Watt, right? I don’t know that there is an offensive MVP yet. There hasn’t been anyone who has distinguished himself. I suppose I will go with the default in Rudolph. He hasn’t been great, but he has nine touchdown passes and he has made some good plays at key times. I only pick him though because he is the QB and not because I think he has been special. Nobody on that side of the ball has stood out to me at all.

Dan: This appears to me to be Pitt's best overall defensive unit since 2009. Is this an aberration, or do you think that Narduzzi has the program in a place where fitting in new talent to keep the performance at/near this level is finally sustainable?

Paul: I think it is real, and I think Pitt will have a great defense as long as Narduzzi is here. He has recruited for that side of the ball, he rebuilt the defensive line and he has added some good things to his defense when he brought in Randy Bates. I fully expect the defense to be deep, experienced and loaded with speed and athleticism for the long haul.

Ron: Why does Pitt QB Kenny Pickett look like a Heisman candidate against legit teams like Penn St. and Central Florida, then plays like a Division 3 backup against mediocre at best Miami?

Paul: I think Miami has a very competent defense, and that was a factor. The Hurricanes’ front seven is athletic and it gave Pitt’s offensive line fits the entire game. Their speed probably gave Pickett the most problems because he tried to force some throws he doesn’t normally force. He hasn’t been consistent, but neither have the offensive players around him. And I thought the receivers were bad on Saturday, which contributed to a lot of his struggles. It is hard to be good at QB when your line is struggling to block for you and your receivers can’t catch the ball.

Advertise with us

Joe: What do you set the over/under on ACC wins this season by the Pitt men's basketball team?

Paul: Great question. I don’t think they are an NCAA team yet, but they should improve from last year. I’ll say the over/under is 19 wins overall and eight ACC wins. If they get over both numbers, it would be an excellent season and one to build on.

Matt: The World Series has proven that while good pitching stops hitting, good hitters can overcome great pitchers, as well. How do you see Game 7 going? It seems like Max Scherzer gives the Nationals a huge edge but I predict that neither starter will factor in the decision.

Paul: I have a weird suspicion that the Astros are going to find a way to Scherzer and win the game 4-3. I just refuse to believe that we will go seven World Series games without a single win by the home team. I think we will see Gerrit Cole tonight at some point, and he will lock down two or three innings to help preserve the win.