Jason Mackey: Hi folks and welcome to my Pirates chat. Been a little bit, but I thought this would be a good week to get back on the horse. If you have Pirates questions, fire away and I'll be back here at noon to answer 'em.
Canyon: Are the Pirates going to have a full on rebuild and if they do who should they trade?
Jason Mackey: I don't think it's going to be a full-on rebuild. Bob Nutting even said as much the other day -- that they're not in a situation for a traditional rebuild, and I agree with him. They could look at trading Starling Marte, but I honestly think it makes more sense to keep him and try to address issues elsewhere. (Catcher, ahem, catcher).
Scott clifford: Hey Jason! Have you heard anything about possible free agents that the Pirates may take a run at. Minus the upper echelon ones obviously!
Jason Mackey: I have not, Scott. That's a little tough to say considering I can't even tell you who would be making said run. The closest thing would be Travis Williams, and he's not gonna make those calls. I didn't think the Pirates would be terribly active in free agency before all this, and I don't think these moves have changed terribly much.
Wayward: I know its early and they still need to hire a GM but did you get a sense that Nutting/Williams believe this team can compete with some additions or that a rebuild is truly in order?
Read More
Jason Mackey: Right or wrong, my sense is they think they can compete. I think they think they need to change a lot about the process, and that's fair. Basically be more like better small-market teams. But I think those guys think there's enough here to get it done without a total rebuild.
J: I believe that Taillon is now arbitration-eligible and would be in line for a solid raise -- except that he's going to miss the entire season. How do things work in this kind of situation? I mean, he should get paid, but if the Pirates low-ball him it would be tough to go to an arbitrator and say "I'm worth more" when he's out.
Jason Mackey: I hear what you're saying, but I also think Taillon could use seasons prior to make his argument. Yes, he's been hurt a lot. But when he's healthy, he's also pitched above his pay grade. And I think they could make the case that he deserves the back end of that now.
PGH Horse: Been a big week for the front office with decisions still to be made. As for on field product, would you say the pirates have a pretty decent core? Like the offense and we’ll see what new manager and especially pitching coach can do to help a depleted staff. Any chance the right on field management could lead the pirates to a surprise season?
Jason Mackey: I do. I like some of the pieces they have: Newman, Frazier and Bell in the infield; Marte and Reynolds in the outfield; with the right pitching coach/plan, I think this staff can be better. I worry about Polanco. I'd like to see more out of third base, either defensively with Moran or offensively with Hayes. And I'd like to see them spend on a catcher who could make the staff better the way Martin and Cervelli have done. Also wouldn't hurt the bring in another starting pitcher.

juniorkrz: What are the odds the Bucs trade Josh Bell to the AL where he belongs.
Jason Mackey: I would never say never, to anything, but unless it's a ridiculous offer that they simply can't pass up, I don't see it happening. He's the type of guy they should be marketing and building their team around. I know the defense lacks, but he's the closest thing they have to a star.
Guest: Painting the rosiest of pictures, if you were a potential GM candidate, why would you want to be the Pirates GM? The minor league system is depleted, the owner doesn't want to spend any money, the team's star has boras as an agent... Why would anyone take this job?
Jason Mackey: Well, one, because there are only 30 of them. Two, the fan base. It's widely recognized around the industry that Pittsburgh could be an absolutely incredible place to work if this team was any good, because of how much people love their sports teams here. Three, people do like challenges. ... I see why people would look at it as being difficult, but you're always going to have good people interested in the job for those reasons.
GPT: Which of the moves made thus far will have the most far reaching effect on future performance?
Jason Mackey: They've only really made one, right? That said, I think you're saying the GM/manager roles in general. That's a tough one. On one hand, I wanna say GM because he controls who comes in and goes, but I might say manager because I do think this club way underperformed this past season. There's so much more that can be juiced from this group, especially pitching.
Optomist: Did Travis Williams address anything with regards to the annually low payroll?
Jason Mackey: Travis did not. Bob did, though. Here is Bill Brink's story on it: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports//2019/10/28/Bob-Nutting-Pirates-Tr...
Retire21: How did Bob Nutting go from praising Neal at the announcement to let Hurdle go to firing NH. Who got in his ear in those weeks in between?
Jason Mackey: It's an interesting question. Have heard people around the industry. Have heard his dad. Have heard managerial candidates. I've also heard that he wanted to make sure he had someone like Travis in place first -- someone to build the front office around. My sense is that it's probably a combination of several of those factors.
Tony: Do you know if Nutting interviewed or considered anyone else besides Travis Williams?
Jason Mackey: I do not, but I honestly can't see how he would do better. And keep in mind, much of Travis' role will be dealing with sponsors, politicians, the non-baseball stuff. Getting a "good baseball man" should and did run secondary to having a smart business man who knows people and the market.
Brian: Jason,
Jason Mackey: Brian,
Wayward: We know the Bucs need both SP and RP help along with a potential catching upgrade. How do they handle other changes? They either have young position players or guys that it may not be in their best interest to sell low on like Polanco.
Jason Mackey: Definitely not smart to sell on Polanco. Doubt you even could at this point. Or you'd get a bag of balls. Gotta ride out Polanco and see if he can figure it out here. ... I think you need to identify a catcher who's good at working with pitchers, who's worked in better pitching systems than the Pirates have, who has been around high spin rates, who can frame and do everything defensively and who is durable. You could probably live with mediocre offense if he does all the other stuff, honestly. They need someone to make their pitchers better.
pozone: Hi Jason, I am thrilled with the housecleaning. Who do you see as affordable players to bring some power to third base and maybe a starter and a reliever? Thanks
Jason Mackey: I don't see why they would address third base. I'm fine with Moran as a placeholder until Hayes is ready, but they could also shift Gonzalez or Newman there with the other (or even Cole Tucker) at short. To me, it's a redundant move. I'd rather take those dollars and spend them on the bullpen, if possible. Starting pitcher wise, someone like Wade Miley would intrigue me more for intel than his arm; they would have space in their rotation, could probably pick his brain, and I could get him cheap, maybe on a one-year deal. But that's me. I have no intel that's what they're going to do.
Tony: Do you see the team trading Marte or Bell for pitching?
Jason Mackey: I do not, honestly.
StuckinNJ: I know that Nutting says he cares about this team, which is probably true. But do you think he thinks about his legacy as team owner? So far, it isn't a pretty picture
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure. That's a good question, one I'll admit I haven't thought a ton about, either. Nutting is a smart man. Presumably he's proud, too. And yeah, he seems aware that he's not exactly anyone's friend around here.
Chuck: Jason, After reading the interview reports from the other day, is there reason for the average fan to have hope that real change is on the way and the organization does have a new commitment? Or is this all just to get us hopeful and involved again only to have it be same old same old?
Jason Mackey: I actually came away from Monday's meetings feeling better about their direction. It's no secret that I'm a big fan of Travis Williams. I'm not saying they're going to compete immediately, but I do think he's going to do good things. Yeah, it'll take some time, but I think it's a smart hire. He's going to look at this thing and figure out where they can do things better and put people in place to do 'em. You should trust that this guy knows what the heck he's doing and that he will get them better.
RS: Thanks for chat! I still don’t trust nutting but he has taken steps to regain this lifelong pirate fan. Impressed with the Williams hire. Are you aware of any other moves such as scouts/player development personnel or will that be addressed by new management? I can’t see how any of them can keep there jobs. Thanks!
Jason Mackey: We are not -- yet. I think they're in the process of that, honestly. And I do expect changes. But I can't give you names at this point. I will say that I texted with Kyle Stark the other day, and he said he's still employed there and awaiting word on his fate.
Jeff: who are some free agent catchers you would like the org to look at
Jason Mackey: Just spitballing here, but I wouldn't complain about Manny Pina. Metrics-wise, he's very good. Also Travis d'Arnaud from the Rays, for intel-related reasons and what he could do at the plate.
GPT: How can the Pirates say they are on the cusp of competing, then follow that by categorically denying that payroll has anything to do with being competitive? You can compete on a low payroll if you have star prospects (like perhaps Meadows and Glasnow). The Pirates don't and need to supplement their roster with a free agent or two.
Jason Mackey: You can also compete on a low payroll if you make a couple of smart and shrewd moves in the offseason. They ca still do that. Also, I think compete is a relatively term; they can compete for a postseason spot. I don't think they're going to compete for a World Series.
Groveton: Who do you see as "affordable" free agent catchers?
Jason Mackey: Maybe Pina and d'Arnaud. They need someone who's good defensively, is from somewhere halfway decent and can add something, anything offensively.
Sammy: Should there be any worry that the person hiring a baseball guy has no baseball experience? Also, please tell me they aren't considering anyone over the age of 45? If they want to be true to their word, they need fresh blood, someone young, innovative, and as far from the organization as possible.
Jason Mackey: I don't think there should be worry. Travis Williams had no hockey experience when he took his Penguins job. That seemed to work out, OK. Also, he comes from this line of thinking, that you need to put good people in place and trust them to do the job. The Penguins do that. The Pirates did not. I think you're going to see that change in the future. And Travis is smart. No, he doesn't know everything, but I think he knows what he doesn't know, and I think he knows how to find answers, if that makes sense.
Alan: Forgive me for not sharing in the exuberance that most are displaying with this long overdue house cleaning. With the minor league cupboards bare, Nutting all but confirming he won't be opening up his change purse, I don't see the possibility of a competitive team being fielded for quite some time. Would you agree?
Jason Mackey: You're forgiven. And no, I don't agree, as I said. I don't know how you can just say, "Nutting won't spend, so they won't win." ... A's don't spend. Rays don't spend. Brewers and Twins spend less. They win. Why can't the Pirates? If they hire the right people and align themselves with that stuff, again, why are we saying they can't do that? Hate Nutting all you want. This part of doing business has nothing to do with him.
Sammy: If they aren't committed to necessarily spending more, but also not committing to a rebuild...that kind of sounds like more of the same, no?
Jason Mackey: Not if you overhaul your baseball operations department to look more like teams that are able to win on a tight budget.
Ryan: How much better could you see the new pitching staff being next year?
Jason Mackey: With the right catcher and a revamped pitching plan, similar to what they did with hitting this past offseason, I could see them finishing in the top half of the National League.
LA Matt: Replacing the "best management team in all of sports" was a start. If nothing else, it gives us some hope! Now we just need a lot of patience to go with that hope. As they say, Rome was not built in a day!
Jason Mackey: I don't know, Matt. I just heard from a couple people who have already informed me that this new group has failed. ... Sarcasm aside, I think Travis deserves to be heard out. See what his moves are. See how they work. Give the guy a chance. I get people are really mad at Bob Nutting, and I'm not saying you shouldn't be. But Travis Williams did none of that. He's been part of a winner. Let's see if he can do something positive here, no?
LA Matt: Thoughts on Hurdle or Huttington finding other comparable major league jobs?
Jason Mackey: I think Neal will be back in baseball at some point, maybe as an AGM/scouting guy elsewhere. Clint I could see going into TV soon. Maybe he tries to manage again, I wouldn't rule it out, but I could see him just saying the heck with it and going the TV route for another decade or so.
LA Matt: Will Lonnie Chisenhall be back? Was he ever here?
Jason Mackey: I've had Chisenhall described to me as an Andrew Luck-type situation. I don't know if he ever made it to Pittsburgh, as I was not on the beat. But, no, I don't think I will ever get to meet Mr. Chisenhall.
Groveton: Your thoughts on trying Colin Moran at first base?
Jason Mackey: I don't see a point. If they're going to keep Josh Bell -- and I think they will/should -- then you only really need a defensive replacement late in games. Jose Osuna can be that, in addition to outfield depth and a decent pinch-hitter. Osuna can give Bell a breather when he needs it, too. I would rather Moran focus on his defense at third.
digger: Feel free to call me an idiot. I think the Bucs should bring back Martin. Respected veteran in the clubhouse. Good at pitch framing and can help the other catchers. The alternatives (at the price the Pirates are willing to pay) are too attractive. With the additional roster spot he won
Jason Mackey: You're an idiot. ... I'm kidding. I wouldn't be against it at all. Also, Jacob Stallings could play more than a traditional backup. I think it would depend on money and other offers for Martin. But if they could do something on the cheap, sure, that's a decent bridge plan.
RPK: There's an awful lot of ifs. If they hire the right people, if players play to their potential, if Polonco figures it out, if the stars align. Not a recipe for success! Your thoughts
Jason Mackey: I think that's a lot of ifs. I also think the Pirates are in a bit of a tough spot. That's going to be that way for any struggling team.
Brendan: Do you think either Nutting/Williams has a preference for a heavy-analytics type of candidate, or a seasoned "baseball guy" for GM?
Jason Mackey: I don't think we know a ton at this point; however, if I had to pick, I would say an analytics-heavy guy -- and yes, I know I reported they reached out to Dan Duquette. I think they're just casting a fairly wide net at this point. I thought it was striking that Nutting admitting that they've fallen behind the times when it comes to analytics. I would expect them to address that because it's something where you don't pay a ton, but it could produce massive results.
Danny: Could the pirates look to trade Marte to a team like the Padres for a guy like Hunter Renfroe and catching prospect Luis Campusano? Get much needed power and a potential catcher of the future. 2 big needs
Jason Mackey: They could. I don't think it's likely, but they certainly could. Renfroe just hit 33 homers in his age 27 season. Campusano is a top prospect. I'm not sure Marte, for his contract and at that age, would command that sort of return.
G: Do you think Josh Bell and Starling will be traded? And should they be traded?
Jason Mackey: I don't think they will and I don't think they should. They're more valuable to the Pirates than anyone else.
LA Matt: I know that in the grand scheme of things it ranks low on the To-do list, but I hope that we can get rid of the 1979 uniforms on Sundays and come up with a new third jersey.
Jason Mackey: I kinda liked those, to be honest.
G: Do you think they will lose out on their top Manager candidates since they had to pause the search?
Jason Mackey: Nah, I don't think it's that big of a deal. From what I've heard, Kotsay, Shelton and Banister were the top three. I guess Kotsay could go to the Giants and Shelton to the Mets, but even then, if then, they would have Banister. I think they have some solid options. I think that storyline is a little bit overblown.
Canyon: Why do you think the Pirates fired the minor league coaches
Jason Mackey: They didn't buy in to some of the Pirates' philosophies under Huntington and Stark. The political correct way of saying it is that they weren't preparing players the way their bosses wanted, but it was more nuanced than that. That's all I can say on the record.
James: Who are some of your breakout candidates?
Jason Mackey: Assuming you mean for the Pirates ... I actually think Polanco is going to have a strong year. Don't know if you would qualify that or not. But I do think he's gonna put it all together. Finally.
John: What have you heard on Brubaker and his season ending injury this past year?
Jason Mackey: He started throwing toward the end of the season. He's good. Expected to be ready for spring training.
LA Matt: I liked them too but it is time to move on! To me, the 79 uniforms is just another reminded that it has been over FORTY YEARS since our last World Series! Most Pirate fans were not even born that long ago.
Jason Mackey: A fair point, Matt.
Guest: Hi Jason. In my opinion, Marte is easily the most complete player on the team. Guys with his skill set don't come cheap. So, if they trade him, that sounds like a salary dump and rebuild. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I agree with you. I would not trade Marte, and I don't think they need to rebuild. I think they can get reasonable competitive again with a couple key tweaks.
LA Matt: Who do you like tonight? Who are you rooting for?
Jason Mackey: I like the Astros tonight, but I'm rooting for the Nationals. Scherzer finishing this thing off would be awesome theater.
Canyon: Do you think that Banister is really a good option for managers?
Jason Mackey: I do. I think the world of Banister. But I could also understand if the Pirates thought they wanted to go in a completely new direction. I don't think you could argue with that.
Bryan: Do you think that Cole Tucker can take a step forward and maybe push Adam Frazier out?
Jason Mackey: Gold Glove finalist Adam Frazier? Ha. I don't think he will push Frazier out. But I do think Tucker could change the calculus in the infield. If he hits, he could force Newman to third and to get some time at shortstop. Again, if he hits.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this chat. We'll try to do this again real soon, whenever we have more to talk about. Thanks.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.