The Steelers’ season was supposed to be over at halftime of the second game. That’s when Ben Roethlisberger complained of some elbow pain and told trainers he was having a hard time even throwing the ball. Mason Rudolph played the second half, and it was discovered the next day that Roethlisberger would need surgery and be done for the year.
There are plenty of teams that overcome injuries all the time, but few figure out how to replace a Hall of Fame quarterback like Roethlisberger and still win games. It isn’t easy because the team is built around the talents of the quarterback and his replacements aren’t capable of doing the things he can do.
That, however, doesn’t mean that it is impossible to win. It just means a team must find a different winning formula. The Steelers in recent years have been a team that generally won games because they could overwhelm opponents with their high-level offensive talent. Roethlisberger was able to lift the offense and carry it on his shoulders at times, and he had a knack for making big throws at the most critical times in games.
Now that he isn’t playing — and Antonio Brown is out of football — the Steelers aren’t going to beat teams with their passing game. They can be effective with their passing game regardless of which backup is in, but they aren’t going to overwhelm a team like they could when Roethlisberger is playing.
On Sunday against the Chargers, they showed a different winning formula, one that isn’t sexy and is a bit antiquated but no doubt still effective.
It started with great defense, something the Steelers haven’t played much of over the past six or seven years. The Steelers were all over the Chargers from the start of the game until the finish. The Chargers had a hard time blocking the Steelers’ front seven, and that’s why they never really got much of anything going. Bud Dupree and Devin Bush were active all night, the defensive line whipped the Chargers’ offensive line, and the secondary and middle linebackers did a much better job covering Keenan Allen than in last year’s game.
Read More
The defense was not just effective at stopping the Chargers, though; the defense also helped the offense out with big plays. The Steelers’ first touchdown came on a fumble recovery by Bush. The second came on a short field created by an interception by Bush.
That eased the pressure on Devlin Hodges, the rookie quarterback making his first start, because he was able to then just manage the game. The worst thing that could have happened would have been if the Steelers fell behind and Hodges was forced to make big plays to get them back in the game. That didn’t happen, and as a result Hodges was able to have a modest night of 15 completions in 20 passes and 132 yards.
The defense stopping the other team and getting takeaways is one major part of the winning formula without Roethlisberger. The other major part is the running game. The Steelers’ running game still isn’t what it needs to be, but both James Conner and Benny Snell ran hard and got tough yards after contact. And the offensive line had perhaps its best day of the season, and that, too, took the pressure off of Hodges.
The running game can still get better and become more consistent, but this was the first game where the Steelers actually showed the ability to run the ball when they wanted to. Snell had 17 carries for 75 yards. Conner had 7 catches for 74 yards out of the backfield and both developments are crucial for helping a young quarterback survive.
There is one other element to this old school formula for winning games without a great quarterback — special teams. The Steelers’ two specialists, Jordan Berry and Chris Boswell, did their part, as well.
Boswell has quietly had an excellent season (he is 11-for-11 on field goals), and that’s so important to this Steelers team because points are at a premium given the quarterback situation. Berry’s final punt all but sealed the Chargers’ fate, as he pinned them on the 1.
It isn’t sexy to win with a game manager at quarterback, but many teams have done it and made the playoffs. And it doesn’t matter if it is Mason Rudolph or Devlin Hodges — they aren’t Roethlisberger, so the game plan should be the same for both.
The Steelers proved Sunday they can win with great defense, a solid running game and a kicker who makes every kick he takes. This is a formula they will need to stick with, and then hope that from time to time their quarterback makes a big throw. It has worked in the NFL, and it can work for the Steelers, too.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.