Brian Batko: Hi and welcome to the off week edition of our weekly Monday chat about the Steelers and other things, too. Our first one coming off a victory Sunday. Shall we begin?
mrbig: do you start mason after the bye?
Brian Batko: Yes. Duck Hodges is a fantastic story, got the job done last night and proved himself capable of starting for this team this season. But Mason Rudolph was playing well vs. Baltimore before his concussion. He was a third-round investment just last year. You still need to see what you have in him, and it's not like Hodges played much better, if at all. I'd be shocked if Rudolph isn't back in there.
574 Fan: All indications are that the depth chart at qb remains Rudolph 1, Duck 2. Do you think that there are any discussions within the staff at all about flipping that this week? I thought Rudolph met expectations when called on, but Duck got a win against a team that, even though they're 2-4, is far better than Cincy, and he did it (sort of) on the road.
Brian Batko: His poise and composure were the most encouraging things, to me. It's not as if he was making big-time throws. At some point, you still need to trust Mason Rudolph to be able to make some of those throws. But hey, good for Hodges in terms of what this does for him not only the rest of this season but maybe for his long-term prospects in this league. Just a few weeks ago we were under the impression that Paxton Lynch could eventually replace him on the active roster. So much for that.
Retire21: Looks like the Steelers will lose Hargrave to FA in '20. The success of the drafts lately make more losses likely down the line. You only get to retain 6 of the 9 from '17 and '18...Watt, JuJu, Sutton, Conner, Okarafo, Edmunds, Washington, Rudolph and Samuels. Who stays?
Read More
Brian Batko: To quote Mike Tomlin, I don't do hypotheticals
Just kidding
Of that group, if I can keep six, at this point I'd probably go with Watt, JuJu, Samuels, Conner, Rudolph, Sutton
livinthedream: Brian, Even with 13000 Steeler fans in attendance the Chargers can't fill a 27k seat stadium. What is going on in Chargersland?
Brian Batko: The Steelers have a national fan base. The Chargers barely have a local fan base. It's just the state of the haves and have-nots in this league when it comes to tradition, brand, etc. Keep in mind they haven't been there long and the Rams have been far more successful there.
Crazy: The majority, if not all, local media guys picked the Chargers and some seemed certain it would be a blow-out. We had lots of injured players but I'm assuming Duck at qb was a big part of the negative vibe. I thought Duck looked good in camp and had hoped he might become Ben's back-up. Based on their performances, who do you think has run the offense better, Mason or Duck? And, if you pick Duck, would you start him against Miami?
Brian Batko: I thought the Chargers would win, but that Duck would play just fine. In fact, probably about as well as he did play. But what I didn't envision was the Steelers run game finally breaking out the way it did and the defense wrecking the game early and often vs. Philip RIvers, Keenan Allen and company.
tHeFinGeR: any news on Tuitt and if it's a tear out not? Artie acquitted himself well last night. what say you, Brian?
Brian Batko: Haven't seen any updates yet on Stephon Tuitt. And yeah, I thought Burns was solid. Played every snap. Eventually got beat late by Hunter Henry, but I thought the Chargers would have much more success against him, especially with Mike Williams healthy (or healthy-ish). Burns wasn't particularly noticeable, which for him and his NFL future (almost certainly elsewhere) is a great sign.
Erie Bill: Brian thanks for this forum. Look forward to it every week. What is the status of the compensatory 3rd pick if the Steelers keep Montgrief on the roster for the rest of the year.
Brian Batko: You're welcome, Erie Bill. My wife went to Gannon, so, go GU. But anyway, all indications are that if Moncrief is cut by Week 10, the Steelers would get back a comp pick. Gerry Dulac wrote about this a couple weeks ago https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/10/04/l-j-fort-relea...
AllanbTN: Cam Sutton looked like a star in coverage last night. Do the Steelers view him as a starting caliber player?
Brian Batko: That's probably something they'll want to figure out over the course of these final 10 (or more?) games. Next year will be the final season of his rookie deal, along with TJ Watt, JuJu and James Conner. It could be a busy 2020 offseason for this team, and Sutton likely won't be a priority given that draft class, but he was very good last night. Only played half the snaps but a slot corner like him is valuable in the NFL these days.
rman: The Ram's home game had over 50% Forty Niner fans. The Charger's home game 80% Steeler fans. Why was the NFL so desperate to locate there?
Brian Batko: It's L.A., it's Hollywood, La La Land, City of Stars, n'at. If you get a really good team to have success there consistently, the allure is obvious. I guess.
Ryan : Good afternoon Brian is there any update on Stephon Tuitt is he there today in the locker room to
Brian Batko: Steelers are off today, so we won't be in the locker room. They'll practice Tuesday and Wednesday, then enjoy the off week.
Javiermmori1971@gmail.com: Hello Brian. Im thinking Steelers may finish 8-8 or 9-7.Will that be enough to win division if we split with Ravens?Who do you think has tougher schedule Ravens or Steelers from here on out?
Brian Batko: Ravens have it tougher the rest of the way. Steelers-Ravens in Week 17 certainly could have major implications. But, obviously, the Steelers are still in a hole compared to the guys from Baltimore.
Roy: I agree Devin Bush is worth the first round pick , he is a play maker, but his size may be a factor when tackling one on one. I've saw some missed tackles too.
Brian Batko: Yeah he had a few whiffs last night. But they came with the Steelers up pretty comfortable, and it seemed like he was trying to make the big play (again). I think his size is a bigger liability in coverage at times, but hey, he's balling lately. It's not like the fumble recovery or the pick were some incredible feats of athleticism or football IQ, but as his teammates keep saying, he just always seems to be around the ball. And his interception last week against the Ravens WAS a phenomenal display of body control and ball skills (even if he might've trapped it).
In Duck We Trust: Remember reading before the season that some PG writers predicted a 2-4 or 3-3 start but that Steelers would still win the division. Know there's no Ben, as of now Duck is the starter, there's a myriad of injuries, etc. but will this defense carry and can this offense do just enough to get them to 10-6/11-5. Think they'll need this for a PO birth or Div title. Looking at schedule it's possible IMO but unlikely as would require them to play nearly perfect and be injury free. Unfortunately, team could be 5-1 had they not hurt themselves with mistakes that just shouldn't happen.
Brian Batko: Yeah, I always thought they'd start slow based on the schedule, but figured they'd bounce back and be a fringe playoff team. I'm not ready to crown them after beating a reeling Chargers team. But they could still be in the mix to finish between 7-9 and 9-7. That might've been unthinkable a few weeks ago, right? People in this very chat were worried they were headed for a top-5 pick!
NickFromVA: Where do I buy SuperBowl tickets?
Brian Batko: Meet me under the West End bridge
KA: Am I the only one wondering how McCullers makes the team every year?
Brian Batko: No
Brian: Who is your favorite all time Shaler athlete ? Ken Karcher, JP Holtz, Guy Junker, Yuri Demetris, Dan Fortson, Dan Kite, Matt Stennett, Art Howe
Brian Batko: Current Clarion baseball standout Nick Fugh
Gravel: Why so few targets to the TE last few games?
Brian Batko: Vance McDonald coming off injury still might be limiting his involvement in the plan. Nick Vannett was always brought in to be more of an in-line blocker, and he seems to be doing a swell job of that. I wouldn't say this group is playing poorly.
DaveInCincy: Brian, after last nights game and injuries, the bye week came at the perfect time.
Brian Batko: I agree, Dave
LA Matt: It is hard to believe but, with a little bit of luck and a few less injuries, we actually could be 5 and 1 right now instead of 2-4. Considering the injuries, especially to our QB's, things could be far worse?
Brian Batko: Sure, but lots of teams can say the same thing and finding a way to win close games is something good teams do.
TXSteeler: Did anyone speak with Pouncey regarding the cause for all errant snaps last night?
Brian Batko: Not sure, I wasn't in California last night
Philip R: Am I destined to suffer the plight of that Dan Marino fellow?
Brian Batko: Yep
Brian Batko: But you aren't as good as he was
Franco: if Tuitt out long term, how much does this impact this defense thats playing the best it has in years?
Brian Batko: It would definitely hurt. Tyson Alualu impressed me last night, but Stephon Tuitt was a beast the first five games. And the trickle-down effect of the DL rotation would likely mean a little more Dan McCullers, a sprinkle of rookie Isaiah Buggs, and obviously more Javon Hargrave, whose 63 percent snap share last night was a season high.
Hank: Why do you not go to the games to cover them? Get interviews contemporaneous to the event etc?
Brian Batko: Because I live in a bubble at my home.
Just kidding. We had Gerry Dulac, Ray Fittipaldo, Gene Collier, Joe Starkey and photographer Peter Diana there last night. I join them at every home game and will also do so for the divisional road games.
Steeler in Virginia: How long is Washington supposed to be out? It would be nice to have him back after the bye.
Brian Batko: Week to week, but aren't we all?
Clinton: Clock management issues yet again for Tomlin. Your thoughts on Tomlin not calling times outs before 3rd and 19 for the Chargers before half or before the 4th down play.
Brian Batko: Just picking nits. He was happy with that halftime lead given who he was starting at QB, and I don't blame him.
Jorge: More carries for Benny Snell going forward and less for Samuels, when healthy and Conners?
Brian Batko: Sure. I remember back during preseason when he wasn't gaining many yards and people wanted to write him off, call him a wasted pick, say he shouldn't make the team over Trey Edmunds. Yeah, I think Benny Snell is just fine.
Brian Batko: But Samuels should still be involved, for sure. Have to see how he recovers from his knee issue. He's still the best pass-catching back here.
Scuba Steve: Through six games Ju Ju has only 25 receptions. I understand the QB situation has been less than ideal...but was he truly a star because of Ben and a number one receiver whose name I won’t mention.
Brian Batko: Obviously, both of those men helped him succeed. But have you already forgotten his touchdown against the 49ers? That was all him. And the touchdown against the Ravens? Excellent play by JuJu. He's still really good, folks. Is he a top-10 receiver in the league? Maybe not. But only 10 guys are.
Al: Call me crazy but we need a guy like Gary Kubiak to come in and coach us when Tomlin goes to Skins to be the second 10 million dollar coach man. I’ll explain. He will hire an extremely expertises NFL staff and will take us back to fundamental football offensively which has been lacking on O for some time. What I mean is use of a full back, misdirection plays, play action, sprinkle in some no huddle and crossing rub routes and whoala!
Brian Batko: OK
Tom in Dallas: I may have lost count, but it seemed liked the defense had their hands on at least 4 other Rivers' passes that could also have been intercepted. If one or two of those were pulled in, this game would have been more of a blow out. Agreed?
Brian Batko: Yeah, Mike Hilton dropped an easy one. He couldn't believe it. But I'm with you, they were all over Rivers. TJ Watt is truly a sight to behold the way his motor is constantly running, he's jumping at passes, getting back on his feet, pushing again to try to collapse the pocket. He might be the Steelers' best player regardless of position.
Quick Nic: Chances of a new special teams coach next year?
Brian Batko: I don't know, but special teams were great last night. Let's give Danny Smith props when they're due.
BB: Brian - Are number 6 jerseys trending today?
Brian Batko: No. 6 SHIRSEYS are getting printed up with the quickness
SpeechDr: Ben seems very involved on the sidelines post-injury, but was noticeably absent last night. What or who decides when he travels with the team at this point? Does he just do home games?
Brian Batko: It's probably up to the training staff to a certain degree, and then to the player at some point depending on the individual injury. Steven Nelson also wasn't there and he practiced with limited reps all week with a groin injury. I imagine it's a case-by-case basis and don't think it's a big deal either way.
Cliff: Will you hear about the injuries to Connor, Haden, Tuitt, Nelson et al early this week or will the Steelers go radio silent with the week off?
Brian Batko: They won't go radio silent. There will be post-practice interviews tomorrow and Wednesday with coaches and players. But I can't guarantee you they'll be forthcoming about injuries.
Guest: Top needs in next draft?
Brian Batko: Edge-rusher, assuming Bud Dupree isn't re-signed. Wide receiver if James Washington doesn't show much the rest of the year. Maybe some young blood on the OL.
Quick Nic: What record wins AFC North?
Brian Batko: Uhhhh, 9-7?
East End Greg: How would you evaluate Joe Haden’s year to date?
Brian Batko: He got paid a lot of money. On the field, he's been good, but probably not as good as Steven Nelson.
John S.: Any comment on late pass call that was intercepted? Gave SD a spark and hope when offense was chewing up yards and clock.
Brian Batko: That was a curious call. Not a good throw by Duck, but also not a good job by Johnny Holton on allowing the DB to pick it off so easily right in front of him. In general, though, I don't have a problem with offenses continuing to attack. There's a place for being aggressive and a time for being conservative. I actually thought the punt was a good decision on 4th-and-1 given the way things were going.
Chris: Really like this kid duck any chance at all steelers let him play the rest of the way
Brian Batko: I don't think so
BamBam Murray: After last nights game do you see Benny Snell getting more first team reps and replacing conner as the starter
Brian Batko: No way, Conner was really effective last night, too. But it showed the coaching staff they can trust Benny Snell to spell Conner. I'm still of the mind that good RBs are kind of a dime a dozen. It's an unfortunate reality for guys that play such a demanding and grueling positiobn,
ABowers: What did Bush do (or say) that drew the unsportsmanlike conduct penalty?
Brian Batko: Not sure, that was kind of a weird one. It must have been really bad or just really right in front of the official.
NickFromVA: When Bush was hurt, it made me realize how different the defense is with him and Barron in there. With those 2, Nelson, and Fitzpatrick, this has the makings of a truly great defense. What say you?
Brian Batko: I don't think Barron has been particularly good, but yeah, Bush and Fitzpatrick really change the complexion of this thing down the middle. Nelson has been terrific on the outside. And the DL/pass-rush can dominate games, as we've seen. Positives all around, really.
Frosty: What a difference a day makes, eh? Are the Steelers finding their "identity" now?
Brian Batko: Their identity might be that they can win against sub-.500 teams?
WPASTEEL: Defense is starting to look better and better every week. Offense is still a serious work in progress. What bothers me is the first possession of every game on O is so predictable. Pass on 1st down usually incomplete...run on 2nd down for a loss and throw on third down either incomplete or for short yards... punt. That has happened every game this year on Offense's 1st possession. Was quite the same last year as well. Where is the creative part from OC???
Brian Batko: I'll tell him to run the fumblerooskie next time on their first drive!
What the Duck: After last nights game do you see Duck getting more first team reps and them getting rid of Ben...just kidding. However, do you think the 2 and 3 QBs we have are promising enough for Colbert to focus on other needs in next year's draft?
Brian Batko: Yeah, for sure. No need to draft a QB in 2020.
John S.: Bush looks a lot like Joey Porter.
Brian Batko: I don't know about that, but he's doing the 55 proud. Porter's legacy was complicated a bit by his coaching tenure and off-field incidents, but he sure was fun to watch as an outside linebacker.
Rivera: Justin Layne tried to pull a fast one on the punt. Almost got away with it too. Why wasn't a penalty enforced?
Brian Batko: I was confused by that too. Savvy attempt by a rookie to pull that one off. And he nearly got away with it too! (Scooby Doo villain voice)
Baghdad_Ben: As a Steeler fan it was great seeing the stadium filled with black and gold, but as an NFL fan that was embarrassing. Why would anyone in LA connect to the Chargers? The NFL has crapped on their fan base in California in my opinion. Good to know the Steelers will never move, or will they?
Brian Batko: Eventually, with advances in science and modern technology, every NFL team will play on Jupiter
Franco: Devin Bush is the best Rookie Defensive player we have has since who....?
Brian Batko: Ehh, TJ Watt was still good as a rookie. But Bush is in pole position to win DROY. Should be between him and the Bosa in SF. I can never remember which one is which. I think he's Nick.
Artie: 3 dropped int's last night by Chickillo, Hilton and Haden. How bad would Putt have won if they'd held onto the ball?
Brian Batko: That's right, I forgot about Chickillo's dropped INT. That one was much worse than Hilton's.
Jason Jones: Hey Brian thanks for the chat. It was a fun game last night but I'm a realist too. That wasn't KC or NE spreading us out and going up tempo. But I did like the fight and the energy the team had last night. Do you think we win the next three games at home?
Brian Batko: Thank you, Jason. The chat would be nothing without you loyal readers. And yeah, it wasn't KC or NE, but it was still Philip Rivers with a half-dozen legitimate weapons at his disposal. Bad OL though, and it showed. I'll say the Steelers win the next two but lose to the other team from LA. Not that they're looking like their Super Bowl selves either at this point.
ALB: Any word on what was wrong with Bush when he was obviously hurting pretty badly for a bit?
Brian Batko: Looked like an ankle and he walked it off
Alan F: Maybe you as a reporter/journalist can answer this question: why do fans gravitate towards back-up players? Especially back-up QBs. During the Cowher and Noll years, I don't remember getting excited about a back-up QBs (Stoudt, Woodley, Jim Miller, Tomczak, etc)
Brian Batko: Because hope is a powerful thing, and the unknown always offers hope.
Bernie: The O-line last night was spectacular in both the passing and running games. What changed from earlier in the season?
Brian Batko: They must've brought back Mike Munchak to be a shadow assistant
sean: Good afternoon Brian! thanks for your time...was it just me or were the TEs mainly there to block last night and maybe thats why the running game looked a lil stronger? thanks again have a great week!
Brian Batko: You too, sean. They're definitely allowing the Steelers to play more 12 personnel, which they were really good in last year with Jesse James. Using Xavier Grimble as your second TE wasn't nearly as encouraging.
Sidney: Boswell was money yet again. Time to sign him to another extension!
Brian Batko: One hundred percent on the year, can't argue with that. Would've been interesting to see if he'd hit the long one when the Steelers punted late.
Rudolph: Steelers have the next 3 at home. Sounds like 5-4 to me. Your thoughts?
Brian Batko: So the Steelers will be 7-8 going into Week 17 at Baltimore? Yeah, I think that's realistic.
Steeler Nation · peasant '63: Rivers is the father of 10 if I recall correctly... Was that fatherly 'advice' he was giving Hilton at the end?
Brian Batko: He said Hilton was waving at the LA sideline and that he was just sticking up for his team.
Guest: Good game until foolish deep pass that was intercepted. It gave a beaten team life and a spark. Offense was chewing up yards and clock until that play call. What was an easy win became a nail biter.
Brian Batko: And then Hunter Henry got me 8 billion fantasy points, so that was nice
SamPitt: It was nice see that DuPree showed up to play. Every week he seems to be more involved. Do you think this can continue?
Brian Batko: Yeah, he's playing for big money in the offseason, likely from another team. Ski Mask Bud is having a nice year so far. https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/10/01/bud-dupree-str...
Adam: Do Gerry, Gene, Ray and Joe fly with the team on the charter or separate?
Brian Batko: Separate
Chris: Rumors really heating up ,what would take for steelers to trade Tomlin to skins.
Brian Batko: If anything, rumors are cooling down
This Guy: 9-7 win the division and make it to AFC championship game. You heard it hear from this guy first! Are you on board with that prediction?
Brian Batko: No, I'm sticking with my 7-9 since Ben Roethlisberger went down. But I've been wrong before (many times) and will be wrong again (many times). Just ask my wife.
Brian Batko: OK everyone, that's all the time we have for today. Thanks again for a lively and question-filled chat. If you have more or something I didn't get to, hit me on twitter or email for my weekly mailbag. Have a nice Monday!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.