Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. You can hear Paul’s show on 93.7 The Fan from 6 to 10 most evenings or after the Pirates play.

Let’s get started:

Joe: Does Ben being out for the season possibly save Tomlin from being fired at the end of the year?

Paul: Mike Tomlin was in no danger of getting fired at the end of the season regardless. The Steelers don’t operate that way and never have. He was going to be back no matter what happened. Now, to your point, there is no chance he will be held accountable and lose his job if the Steelers have a losing season. If you lose your franchise quarterback, it makes it difficult to win games consistently. Bill Belichick has missed the playoffs twice in the Tom Brady era — and one was the year Brady was out and Matt Cassell was the quarterback. It happens to the best of them. I think Mason Rudolph will be OK, but he will have a learning curve and some growing pains this year.

Advertise with us

Jon: What are the percentages you would put on Ben Roethlsberger returning to the Steelers? Has he played his last game as a Steeler in your mind?

Paul: I would say it is 50/50 right now. Ask me in about eight or nine weeks, and I may have a different number. It really comes down to how well Mason Rudolph plays. If Rudolph is who they think he is and plays well this year and improves every week, it will be difficult to bring Roethlisberger back. Rudolph is the starter of the future, and if he plays a whole season, it would make absolutely no sense to go back to Roethlisberger. Now, if Rudolph is below the line and doesn’t get it done, well, Roethlisberger will be back in the saddle next season.

William: Why would the Steelers waste a first-round pick on a safety? This is ridiculous. They are not one player away from contending so what was the point? Do you agree with me that this was a really dumb trade?

Paul: Think of it like this — they needed a safety. They are going to lose Sean Davis in the offseason to free agency, so it would have been an area of even bigger need for next year. They likely would have targeted safety as one of their top priorities in the draft and may even have used their first rounder on the best safety available. Well, they just didn’t wait — they took their first-round safety now and unlike the one they would have drafted next year, they have proof (in the form of 18 games played in the NFL) he can actually play at this level. It is a great move for them, made even better by the fact that they have control of him through the 2022 season and at a very cheap price.

Jan: I was ready for Mason Rudolph to take over even before Ben’s injury. It is time for him to retire. Do you think Roethlisberger would accept a trade and play elsewhere or just retire?

Advertise with us

Paul: I think he would probably just retire. I know all of these guys have a big ego, and he wants so badly to prove he can do it without Antonio Brown, but I just don’t think he is at the point in his life where he wants to uproot his family and move. I think he will either be the Steelers’ starter next year or he will be retired. I just don’t think he wants to play anywhere else.

Jared: Do you think the Steelers should have tried to trade for five-time Pro Bowl WR Demaryius Thomas, what with him costing the Jets only a 6th round draft pick in 2021?

Paul: No, I actually think they are fine at receiver. I know the group as a whole hasn’t distinguished itself yet, but I saw some good things in the second half Sunday against Seattle. James Washington is the key — he needs to get in gear and get going now in Year 2. If he takes that next step as a player this season, the receiving group will be fine. Also, I just don’t know how much Thomas has left in the tank.

Joe: What are the Steelers going to do with Donte Moncrief? He's been an absolute disaster of Limas Sweed proportions.

Paul: I would say he is running out of chances, big time. Something tells me he is going to get one more opportunity this Sunday to prove he is capable of getting the job done. And if he has a big game or just plays well and catches the balls thrown to him, he will continue to get chances. If he goes out and drops another pass or two, he will be buried so far on the bench that he might not ever be able to recover from it. He needs to play really well this week for the good of the Steelers and for the good of his career.

Advertise with us

Robert: So after the Pirates’ record-setting runs allowed in a 3-game disaster in Chicago this past weekend, do you think the chances of Bob Nutting firing everybody just went up?

Paul: I think I’ve written this multiple times, but let’s go one more: Anyone who thinks the Pirates are going to make wholesale, sweeping, meaningful changes is kidding themselves. I will say this, though, I am actually coming around to the idea that Clint Hurdle could become the sacrificial lamb, but even that I will have to see before I believe it. The clubhouse has spiraled out of control and all of the incidents with coaches fighting players and players fighting each other and now this Felipe Vazquez story has made the Pirates an embarrassment off the field, too. That’s the kind of stuff that might force an owner’s hand and Bob Nutting may have to pull the trigger and fire Hurdle to salvage some credibility.

Greg: Did the Pirates know about what kind of creep Felipe Vazquez actually is? Is there any chance that scum will play for the Pirates again? If he ever returns to the Pirates, I will not only not go to games I will work hard to lead massive boycotts and protests against the Pirates. This guy is sick.

Paul: No, they didn’t know about this criminal activity until he was arrested. And there is zero chance he plays for the Pirates again and maybe less than 1 percent he ever plays for anyone again. Just based on what he has admitted to, he is going to be looking at some jail time. He may get out and be young enough that some desperate team gives him a chance, but I have a hard time seeing that. Then again, it is incredible what teams will overlook to sign a talented player.