We’ve seen this script at Pitt way too many times over the past 30 years, haven’t we? No, I don’t mean the popular logo on the side of the helmets. I mean the script that played out for the Panthers on Saturday afternoon at Beaver Stadium in the Pitt-Penn State game.
You know the script, it goes something like this:
The Panthers play a great game, they put up a valiant fight, they make everyone proud because of how hard they play ... and they lose because they just can’t execute a few critical plays in crunch time, or because of some questionable coaching decisions, or because they can’t make a tackle or two.
You get the point. Pitt football would be great with horseshoes and hand grenades because close actually means something in those two activities. In football, though, it means way too many tough losses, way too many wasted efforts, and way too many seasons mired in mediocrity because the Panthers failed to win these kinds of games.
Yep, Pitt was on the road. Yep, Penn State is ranked and was favored. Yep, the Panthers played valiantly and fought until the end. Yep, the Panthers beat the spread. And, of course, the Panthers came away with a loss in a game they really should have won.
Penn State tried to give away the game, but the Panthers just couldn’t take it. Pat Narduzzi’s decision to kick a field goal late and some of the play-calling inside the 5 left a lot to be desired, and there is no question both were a factor. However, James Franklin made more than his share of baffling decisions, so the coaching incompetence was mostly a wash in my mind.
Read More
At some point, players need to make a play, and there were just one or two key plays that could have changed the game. A missed easy tackle led to a long run and eventually a touchdown for Penn State early in the game. A few missed blocks on the goal line led to the plays being blown up.
I, for one, think Narduzzi has the program as close as it has been in a long time to an actual breakthrough. It is clear that the defense has a chance to be excellent over the next few seasons. Kenny Pickett has silenced many his harshest critics, as he has been really good the last two weeks. There is clearly talent — young and old — at receiver and running back.
All of that is great, but none of it matters if Narduzzi can’t figure out how to break this curse of mediocrity and get the Panthers over the top. Pitt has played three very winnable games, and instead of being 3-0, the Panthers are 1-2 and facing maybe the best team on their schedule (Central Florida) Saturday.
The biggest difference between Pitt and Penn State was on full display Saturday, and it had nothing to do with atmosphere or the size of the crowd. The bottom line is that this was the kind of game Penn State almost always wins, and it was also the kind of game Pitt almost always loses.
Penn State is almost always a threat to get to 10 wins, mostly because they don’t lose games they are supposed to win very often. Penn State expected to win and made plays down the stretch to hold off the upset. Pitt just hoped to win, and until that mindset among everyone involved changes, these things will continue to happen.
This isn’t a Narduzzi problem, either; it is a Pitt problem. It doesn’t seem to matter who the coach is, whether it is Walt Harris, Dave Wannstedt, Todd Graham or Paul Chryst. Season after season, there are far too many of these kinds of losses. I don’t know what it will take to get the program over the top, but I’m having a hard time getting excited about yet another close loss.
I hear many Pitt fans come up with all kinds of excuses why the program has had exactly one 10-win season since 1981 and has lost at least three games in every season since then, as well. All of them are nonsense, as it shouldn’t be that hard to figure out. People call my alma mater, Temple, the laughingstock of football, but even the Owls have figured it out with two 10-win seasons in the past four years.
The Pitt players deserve a lot of credit for the heart and toughness they showed. The coaches deserve a lot of credit for devising an excellent game plan, especially on defense. But in the end, it is about winning and losing, not coming close, and until Pitt figures out how to win these kinds of games, they will continue to be the moral victory champions and not much more.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.