The Steelers play their fourth and final preseason game Thursday at Carolina, and there will be several roster spots on the line. This is the final chance for all of those players on the bubble who are either trying to make the roster or move up the depth chart. We won’t see many, if any, of the starters and we will probably see only a few players who are expected to play key roles as reserves.

Thursday’s game will also mark the end of the battle to become the backup to Ben Roethlisberger at quarterback. Mason Rudolph and Josh Dobbs have been embroiled in a fierce competition for the spot. Rudolph has seemingly had the upper hand for most of training camp and through three preseason games, but Dobbs will get the start against Carolina.

Mike Tomlin said that we shouldn’t read into anything about the order of quarterbacks in the game and that both will play and get plenty of opportunity to show what they are capable of. Tomlin is obviously trying to keep both players engaged in the competition, and by publicly stating that it is still ongoing, he’s accomplished that.

But with all due respect to Tomlin’s request, I can’t help but think the Steelers are trying to showcase Dobbs for other teams by giving him the start. Dobbs has some talent and has shown some flashes that he perhaps can be a solid NFL quarterback, so he may have some trade value if he continues to put down good film.

Advertise with us

Dobbs wouldn’t bring back a huge haul, but he might bring back a late-round draft choice or maybe even a tight end. If he plays well in the Carolina game, it could enhance his value. And even if it doesn’t help his trade value, the Steelers are giving him the opportunity to get some good tape to show to other teams when he likely becomes a free agent this weekend.

The good news is Dobbs has done enough to prove he deserves a shot somewhere, and I can’t imagine that he won’t be on an NFL roster this season. The bad news, at least for Dobbs, is that he hasn’t done enough to beat out Rudolph for the Steelers’ backup job. The Steelers could still opt to keep three quarterbacks and make Dobbs third on the depth chart, but that would be a dumb move.

Rudolph has outplayed Dobbs, he is younger, he was a higher draft choice and he is a more polished NFL-style passer. He doesn’t run as well as Dobbs, but that isn’t relevant, particularly in the Steelers’ pro-style offense.

Rudolph has competed 65.6 percent of his passes as compared to 53.6 percent for Dobbs. He has also thrown three touchdowns and one interception while Dobbs hasn’t thrown a touchdown pass and has two interceptions. And Rudolph’s passer rating is almost double (106.6 to 55.5) that of Dobbs.

Numbers sometimes don’t tell the whole storym but in this case they align perfectly with what we have seen play out on the field. Rudolph has been in command of the offense when he has been in the game and he has proven he can make all the throws an NFL quarterback is asked to make. That is not to say that Dobbs hasn’t had some good moments and made some big throws, he just hasn’t had as many as Rudolph nor has he been nearly as consistent.

Advertise with us

The Steelers have already made it somewhat clear that they want Rudolph to be their quarterback of the future. That’s what they believed when they drafted him in the third round of last year’s draft and they have cleared a path for him to earn the backup job this preseason. And nothing he has done thus far would suggest he isn’t up to the job.

Roethlisberger is signed through the 2021 season, which means Rudolph will spend a few more years maturing before he is ready to take over. Roethlisberger is durable for the most part, but he has missed some games in recent years, so Rudolph will get some opportunities to gain experience in games that count along the way.

In the meantime, he just needs to bide his time and make sure that he continues to improve and is ready to go when his number is called. He will no longer be looking over his shoulder at Dobbs because the job is his to lose now.

Thursday night’s game with the Panthers will tell us a lot about a number of different positions on the Steelers roster and will settle some battles that have been ongoing through camp. It won’t, however, tell us anything we don’t already know about the backup quarterback spot because Rudolph has already done enough.