Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. You can hear Paul’s show on 93.7 The Fan from 6 -10 p.m. most evenings or after the Pirates play. 

Football is back, yet this week’s mailbag is again dominated by angry Pirates questions. I suppose anger is better than apathy. Let’s get started:

Jason: Who will have a better season — LeVeon Bell, Antonio Brown or the Browns? Which one of the three is most likely to fail, and which is most likely to succeed?

Paul: I love this question, Jason, because it gets me a break from the angry Pirates questions and is actually a little bit fun. I think LeVeon Bell and Antonio Brown will both have big years. As much as we like to make fun of Brown’s nonsense and Bell’s rapping, you have to remember how talented both are. They are both among the best players at their positions and when healthy are among the best players in the NFL. I’ll give the slight edge to Bell for one reason — he isn’t relying on a mediocre, injury-prone quarterback like Derek Carr to get him the ball. That’s just the reality of being a receiver. You can be great, but if your QB can’t get you the ball, it will hurt your production. The Browns are still the clowns and always will be until they prove otherwise. I can see that outfit blowing up and becoming a disaster this year. They’re most likely to fail.

Advertise with us

Ron: What do you think the Steelers will do about their lack of depth at tight end behind Vance McDonald? This should have been addressed more vigorously in the offseason.

Paul: It is a problem, but they will address it Saturday when teams cut players. A lot of teams are carrying multiple tight ends who will need to be cut, and as a result the Steelers should have an opportunity to add one or two who will bolster depth. It isn’t ideal, but it is a good way to address things.

Joe: Do you think the Steelers will keep rookie kicker Matthew Wright on the practice squad as an insurance policy for Chris Boswell?

Paul: I don’t. There are enough kickers available on the market that they don’t need to waste a practice squad spot on one. If Boswell fails, the Steelers will do as they always do — hold a tryout for a few kickers at Heinz Field and pick one. That’s worked for them in the past, and I am sure it would work this year, too.

Robert: WHY is Clint Hurdle SO Hesitant to make Pitching Changes within an INNING??????

Advertise with us

Paul: Wow, the all caps for emphasis on certain words tells me you are REALLY angry. Looking at the time and date stamp of your email, it was sent around seventh inning of a Pirates game, and I am sure Hurdle did something that prompted your anger. His philosophy is that he likes relievers to come in to a clean inning. It isn’t always possible and sometimes I think it’s to his detriment, but that’s what he believes is best for the success of his relievers. Also some relievers, such as Francisco Liriano, prefer coming into a clean inning and aren’t as effective working out of jams.

Granson: Do the Pirates have any plans at all to upgrade their catching position for next year?

Paul: It doesn’t sound like it if you listen to what Neal Huntington has said. He is enamored with the progress of Jacob Stallings and believes Elias Diaz is just in a slump. That would be a huge mistake, and it is surprising considering one of the most important pieces in jump starting that recent playoff run was Russell Martin, whom they went outside of the organization to get.

Joseph: Much has been made of the Pirates’ awful starting pitching, but who can you see other than Vazquez,(if he's not traded), coming back from the bullpen next season?

Paul: Kyle Crick, Felipe Vazquez, Richard Rodriguez, Michael Feliz, Chad Kuhl, Edgar Santana will all be back. Keone Kela, I think, is a candidate to be traded and the rest of that group are mostly journeymen so they could hang around as depth. I don’t think Liriano will be back.

Advertise with us

Thomas: Why does Frank Coonelly get a pass in all of this stuff? I keep hearing “Fire Huntington” and “Fire Searage” and “Fire Hurdle.” How about “Fire the man who is in charge of the entire operation?”

Paul: I think because he really has nothing to do with the actual baseball side of things. The face of the baseball franchise are Huntington, Hurdle and Searage, so they are the three that most people direct their anger toward. I actually think Coonelly has done a great job of selling the Pirates given the product they have on the field. He gets people into the stands, and that’s his top priority. He needs to make changes to the baseball side of things. Then if he doesn’t, then maybe it is time to talk about him going.

Brad: There is no way Clint Hurdle can survive this season. Who, in your mind, would be an adequate replacement? I hope it is an external option.

Paul: I agree, if they are going to make a change, make a change. I like Jeff Bannister and Joey Cora, but neither of those names inspire me. I’d say the Pirates need to go out and get a younger, hungry guy out to prove himself. It should be one who understands the way the game is played these days and can relate to players. New energy is what this franchise needs more than anything.

Nate: I saw on Twitter where you wrote that the Pirates should pick up Chris Archer's option for next year. Why? I'm pretty sure there are other free-agent starting pitchers that can do better than an ERA over 5.

Advertise with us

Paul: He is a legitimate major league pitcher who has proven he can get outs and, at times, pitch at a high level. Those aren’t easy to find. He is only going to cost $8.5 million, which is dirt cheap for a legitimate starting pitcher. The issue with Archer isn’t that he should or shouldn’t be in the rotation; it’s that he is a fourth or fifth starter and shouldn’t be seen as anything more than that. If he is at the back end of your rotation, then you are good enough. If he is at the top of your rotation, then you are not.

Steven: Why are the Pirates so bad fundamentally? They are terrible at running bases and terrible at defense and they can’t bunt properly, either. What coaches are responsible for teaching these things and why haven’t they been fired?

Paul: This is an easy answer — because they have bad, or extremely flawed, players. I’m sure they are taught fundamentals; they just have too many players who aren’t quite good enough, and that’s why you see so many mistakes.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise