Pirates pitching coach Ray Searage was given a lot of credit for reviving the careers of Francisco Liriano and Edison Volquez during the stretch of playoff years from 2013-15.

He was also credited with getting A.J. Burnett back on track when he came to the Pirates from the Yankees, and helping to turn Mark Melancon into an elite closer. Searage may have cemented his status as pitching guru and miracle worker when he helped guide Jeff Locke to an All-Star Game appearance.

All of that was well-deserved praise, although some would argue former pitching assistant Jim Benedict deserves some of the credit. Things have gone south this season for the Pirates pitchers, though, and as a result Searage has found himself on the hot seat.

The problem is Searage seems to now want to point the fingers elsewhere when discussing the Pirates’ pitching success — or in this case, lack thereof.

Advertise with us

“The biggest thing that we’re not doing is executing pitches when we need to, especially in high-leverage situations,” Searage said Saturday on 93.7 The Fan. “We try too hard. We try to enhance the pitch instead of execute the pitch.”

Searage’s thoughts can be summed up nicely this way: “Don’t blame me because I’m coaching the right way. Blame the pitchers for throwing bad pitches.”

That is such a crock and a cop out, especially given all the praise that Searage received over the years for his work with some of the aforementioned pitchers.

Searage can’t have it both ways — either the pitchers such as Melancon, Volquez and Liriano found success on their own or he coached them up to help them find success. Now, Searage should point the finger at himself because clearly he and his staff are not getting the job done.

And while the Pirates pitchers at the major league level have been awful, the worse news is they don’t seem to develop pitchers in their farm system, and there doesn’t seem to be many pitchers ready to help. All of that falls on Searage’s shoulders since that is his domain and that’s why it is ridiculous that he suddenly wants to deflect criticism.

Advertise with us

Searage, though, didn’t just stop at pointing the finger elsewhere. He then doubled down with the most condescending take any athlete, coach or executive can have. Searage said people on the outside who are quick to criticize don’t understand the game.

“It gets frustrating when you have to defend yourself or your pitchers because people are starting to say that the pitching is this or the pitching is that,” Searage said. “OK, so be it. You’ve got that opportunity to sit in the stands, be judgmental and critical of what we do out here. But you don’t know the inside part of the game, the game within the game. That’s where you need to get a little bit better.”

I’ll concede that I don’t know the “inside part of the game.” But I know enough to know this: The Pirates pitchers have stunk this season.

I don’t need to be a pitching guru, analytics savant, baseball insider or “in the clubhouse” to know what I’m looking at, and what I’m looking at is a staff full of pitchers who can’t get outs, walk too many batters and throw too many “mistake pitches” that end up on the other side of the fence.

It doesn’t take a genius to look at the numbers and figure out how bad things are. The Pirates are 14th in the National League in team ERA (5.01), and the only staff that is worse is Colorado, which plays half its games in thin air a mile above the sea. The Pirates are also 14th in batting average against (.264), 14th in runs allowed (582), 13th in home runs allowed (174) and 14th in opponents’ OPS (.803).

Advertise with us

The team stats are abysmal, and the individual stats might actually be worse.

Felipe Vazquez has had a great season by any measure. Liriano, Chris Stratton and Keone Kela have had some degree of success. The rest of the staff has been bad. The starters all have had extended rough stretches and none has a better ERA than Steven Brault (4.33). Joe Musgrove is the only one with a WHIP less than 1.30.

That’s why Searage should have taken a far more humble approach. He hasn’t had a good season, and the proof is in the fact that the unit he oversees — a unit that was supposed to be a team strength, by the way — is not coming close to getting the job done.

He is right that pitchers must execute pitches, but the fact that so many of them seem to struggle in that category this year suggests they aren’t buying whatever Searage is selling.

It’s Searage’s job to fix it, but it is incredibly worrisome that he doesn’t seem to think he deserves any of the blame, especially since he was so quick to take credit for the success.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise