It’s easy to say the Pirates should fire Neal Huntington and Clint Hurdle. The team was on a 4-24 freefall heading into its game against the Los Angeles Angels on Monday night, one of the worst runs in baseball history. Somebody has to pay. Pittsburgh deserves better.

The problem is finding someone better to replace Huntington and Hurdle. If you were a good baseball man, would you want to work for Bob Nutting? When you have almost no chance of winning because you get so little financial support from the owner?

I know, there are only 30 such jobs in the big leagues. A lot of baseball people would do just about anything for one, even the worst one. Everybody has an ego and thinks he can be the man to win when everyone else fails.

I’m not talking about those people.

Advertise with us

I’m talking about proven baseball people who think they might have a better opportunity with another organization, any organization. They have to know it’s a career killer to come to Pittsburgh to work for Nutting. It’s an absolute career killer.

Sure, it’s possible there is another Syd Thrift-Jim Leyland combo waiting to be discovered. Thrift was out of baseball for nine years when the Pirates hired him as general manager in November 1985. He hired Leyland — little-known as the Chicago White Sox’s third-base coach with 11 years of minor-league managing experience — two weeks later to be his manager.

The two took over the Pirates at the worst time in franchise history, worse even than now. The 1985 team lost 104 games. General manager Harding “Pete” Peterson was fired in May, manager Chuck Tanner after the season. Attendance was just 735,900.

“I don’t believe the people of Pittsburgh want baseball here,” infielder Jim Morrison said back then. “I think it’s time to move on to a town where they appreciate baseball.”

That almost happened.

Advertise with us

The darkest moment of 1985 happened in September. Known as the Pittsburgh drug trials, several Pirates — superstar Dave Parker, among them — were called to testify about cocaine abuse in baseball. Even the Pirate Parrot was implicated.

The Galbreath family wanted out as owners. A consortium of business leaders led by Mayor Richard Caliguiri and prominent local attorney Carl Barger stepped up to buy the club in October 1985 and keep it in Pittsburgh. Thrift and Leyland did the rest, leading the Pirates to three consecutive division titles from 1990-92.

“It ain’t easy resurrecting the dead,” Thrift said, famously.

Pittsburgh gladly would settle for another Thrift-Leyland management team.

It’s a nice thought, anyway.

Advertise with us

It’s more likely the Pirates would end up with another John Russell as manager. He was hired by Frank Coonelly and Huntington — on the job as general manager for just six weeks — in November 2007. It’s a mystery to me what Russell could have said in his interview to get the job. He had zero personality. His teams went 186-299 from 2008-10, losing 105 games in his final season.

Jeff Banister is an obvious replacement for Hurdle. He is back in the Pirates organization as a special assistant to Huntington and had success as Texas Rangers manager, winning division titles in 2015 and 2016. But I have to think Banister could do a lot better than the Pirates job if he has a little patience.

Tom Prince — Hurdle’s bench coach — is another candidate to be interim replacement as manager. He has 11 years of managing experience in the minor leagues. Maybe he would be the next Leyland. Or maybe he would be the next Russell. Who knows?

I’m not saying the Pirates should keep Huntington and Hurdle out of fear of not being able to get someone better.

The two probably aren’t going anywhere anyway, because they have guaranteed contracts for two more seasons. It’s not like Nutting to pay them for doing nothing. You might have heard he doesn’t like to do anything that lessens his profits.

Advertise with us

I’m just suggesting there is no guarantee the Pirates will find another Thrift and Leyland.

I’ll ask the question again:

Would you want to come work for Nutting?

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.