Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Chad: Who will and who should take the fall for the Pirates’ collapse? This is at least the fourth or fifth time since 2011 that they have completely fallen apart in the second half of the season. Someone should take the fall for it.
Paul: Great question. Who should? Well that’s easy — the guy who is most responsible for this mess, Neal Huntington. And if he takes the fall and they replace him, a whole lot of other people would, too, as the new general manager would then clean house. I don’t anticipate that, though, as he has two more years on his deal. Clint Hurdle also has two more years on his deal. I can’t see this owner paying the kind of money it would take to buy either of those two out. He would be paying them to not work. I could see a scenario where Hurdle is made some sort of special assistant to the general manager and a new manager is put in place, but I can’t imagine Bob Nutting will pay Hurdle $6 million to go away. Regardless, the question is who should take the fall, and my answer is Huntington, Hurdle and a whole bunch of others in charge of scouting, drafting and development of players. Who will take the fall is a different answer. It won’t shock me if we get some minor moves like a few scouts, maybe someone like pitching coach Ray Searage and a few minor league instructors getting fired. I just don’t see this owner making the kind of changes necessary to get the thing fixed.
Brian: Let’s say the Pirates fire Neal Huntington and Clint Hurdle. OK, what does that solve? Who would take this job? And given how cheap the owner is, what candidates would even be attracted to it? It would just be more bargain basement shopping.
Paul: The old “who can you get that will be better”? — and this is some version of that ridiculous line of thinking — is a terrible reason not to make a change. There are only 30 major league manager jobs in the world. There are only 30 major league general manager jobs in the world. That’s it. Those jobs are coveted and a lot of really good and qualified people would be interested. The idea that the Pirates couldn’t attract quality candidates for either job is downright dumb.
Read More
Ron: Why do some people excuse the job Clint Hurdle has done by saying the manager isn't really important? If that's true, then shouldn't John Russell still be here?
Paul: I think most people give Hurdle a pass because of the three playoff years. And many people think he has an impossible job and is being asked to rearrange the chairs on the deck of the Titanic. His roster is almost always compiled of misfit parts and young players. There is no margin for error. He has been asked to win with a group of players who just aren’t collectively good enough. That’s why many people who call my show, email me or interact on social media with me say it isn’t fair to put this on Hurdle. With no budget, no roster and no margin for error, it is an impossible job and it doesn’t matter who does it, they will ultimately fail.
Jason: Are the Pirates moving back into the territory they were in when it took them 20 years to have a winning season?
Paul: Yes, I think they are, and that’s sad. A few nights ago, when the Pirates lost that debacle of a game 11-6, it felt every bit as embarrassing as the 20-0 loss to Milwaukee a bunch of years back. The helplessness and hopelessness with this team is back. What exactly are fans supposed to look forward to? What is the future for this team? The pitching staff is thin and not particularly loaded with talent. The bullpen is a mess. The lineup has a few good pieces but is about to ship out two of its best hitters. There just isn’t much to get excited about for the future.
Rob Gateway, @RobGateway: Does Mike Tomlin only getting a one-year contract extension send a message that he needs to do better?
Paul: I don’t think so. I think it was a compromise deal between the majority owners (Rooneys) and a few of the minority owners who didn’t want him to get an extension. The Rooneys aren’t going to make a move on Tomlin no matter what happens. Sure, Tomlin needs to do better, but I don’t think this extension is a sign that he was being put on some sort of a hot seat.
Rob: What word would you use to best describe Yaisel Puig?
Paul: Whackjob. Is that a word? The guy is nuts and he is in his own little universe at times. I love watching him play baseball, though, as he is an incredible talent. He is just a bit of a goofball, he is nutty and he sometimes blows a gasket.
Amy: Who is going to win the ACC in football? Also is Dabo Swinney the cutest coach in the conference?
Paul: I do think Dabo Swinney has the best team in the ACC again, so I will say Clemson. I don’t think anyone will really even challenge them. They have become an SEC powerhouse, only they play in the ACC. Their defensive front seven is absurd. They have athleticism, speed and talent all over the field and, oh yeah, they have the best quarterback in the country, as well. I think they will win the ACC again with relative ease and will again be in the national championship game. As for whether Dabo is cute or whatever, I don’t believe I am qualified to answer that.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.