Neal Huntington said Sunday he is still “working through” whether the Pirates are going to be buyers or sellers at the trade deadline. He said he would love to add enough to this team to give it the help it needs to make it to the postseason, but he has to see what the market is to acquire those players.
In other words: We’d love to add, but in the end the price will be too high.
This shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone because it is just a slightly different version of the same speech he gives every trade deadline and offseason. The good news for Huntington is that the Pirates have made his decision easy by going in the tank. They are 2-7 since the All-Star break. They are now 7½ games out of first place in the National League Central and 5½ games out of the second wild card.
It’s over, and now Huntington and company should be able to give up the pipe dream and do what they really want to do — shed some salary.
A perfect trade deadline now in the eyes of the Pirates front office is one that saves the most money for the rest of the season. I don’t even think baseball trades will be a part of the equation.
That means Corey Dickerson and his $8.5 million salary could be headed elsewhere, as could Melky Cabrera, even though he is only going to make $1.15 million this year. Jordan Lyles and his $2.05 million salary could be moved as well.
Read More
It isn’t a coincidence that those three were reported to be on the trading block by Jon Heyman last week. I don’t know the exact prorated math on their remaining salaries, but the Pirates will save themselves somewhere in the neighborhood of $5 million if they get rid of those three players.
The problem is trading that group won’t make the Pirates better either now or in the future. Dickerson and Cabrera have been two of the Pirates’ best hitters. They are two veterans who know how to conduct themselves, and their leadership would be missed by this young ballclub. Lyles has been inconsistent, but he has had enough good starts that it is hard to imagine whoever replaces him will have as much overall success.
It is hard to make any argument that the Pirates will be better without those three players. They may be able to maintain what they are doing now but, well, they are 46-52 entering Monday’s games, so that isn’t a good thing. They won’t be better this year by subtracting three players who have helped them win games, and that’s especially true because they won’t get much in return for any of them.
I understand the need to save money, and if a team isn’t going anywhere, why not shed a few players, right? The problem is this seems to be standard operating procedure for the Pirates, no matter what the situation is. And I think fans could get more excited about the savings in salaries if they knew that money were going to be reinvested in payroll next year.
The speculation about big trades is what makes baseball at this time of year exciting in many circles.
Unfortunately, Pirates fans will likely be extremely disappointed after this trade deadline because the front office won’t make the team better for this year nor will it make the team better for next year and beyond.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.