The Pirates dropped two of three in St. Louis, so they are now 1-5 since the All Star break. That is obviously not how they wanted to start the second half of the season, but those games are over now and it is time for the Pirates to look ahead.
The other day, I wrote that the Pirates should be either buyers or sellers and that the only wrong decision would be to stand pat. I still believe that they could go either way, but it is beginning to become clear that they will need to be sellers.
That brings us to this weekend when the Pirates will play host to the Phillies for what appear to be three hugely important games. It is a dangerous game to play to put too much importance on any one series or set of games, but this seems to be the Pirates’ last stand — at least before the trade deadline. That is July 31 at 4 p.m. and the Pirates will play 10 games before then.
Seven of those games are at home, starting with the Phillies series and followed by four games with the Cardinals. The Pirates are running out of time and options, so it seems pretty clear that they need to do some serious damage this homestand if they want to continue in their quest to contend for the playoffs.
The front office has been very guarded about their intentions, but the one thing we learned last season is they can be influenced by what happens on the field. The Pirates were said to be definite sellers last July but then got on a hot streak just before the trade deadline and it forced the front office in a different direction.
They then made the trades for Chris Archer and Keone Kela in order to boost the pitching staff for the stretch run. It didn’t work, as they faded in August and fell out of the race, but they could be in a similar situation this year.
Read More
There was a report from Jon Heyman that the Pirates are only shopping Jordan Lyles, Melky Cabrera and Corey Dickerson. That would suggest they aren’t looking to move a big piece like Felipe Vazquez or Starling Marte, at least not yet. That could change, though, if the Pirates don’t make some noise in the next seven games.
The same could be said about the opposite approach as buyers. Huntington hasn’t tipped his hand but did say he’d be hesitant to unload prospects to add players again like he did last season. The thing is, if the Pirates make a push in this homestand — and then follow it with a strong showing against the lowly Mets — it would be hard to justify not at least trying to give the team a chance to compete in the second half.
The Pirates’ greatest need is pitching, and Huntington is correct that the price tag on pitching can be very high. I don’t think he should sell the farm under any circumstance, but they don’t need to, despite Huntington’s rhetoric. I look at recent trades around major league baseball for players like Homer Bailey and even Andrew Cashner as proof that he can obtain pitching help for very little in return.
The A’s picked up Bailey for basically a middle-of-the-road Class AA prospect, and the Red Sox got Cashner for two players who are currently in rookie ball. That tells me the Pirates could go out and find a couple of pitchers to give them some depth and beef up both their rotation and bullpen without touching any of their most significant prospects.
Again, it all depends on the way the Pirates play over the next week, and that starts this weekend against the Phillies. Meanwhile, the Pirates are honoring the 1979 World Series champion team on Saturday night. That not only is the last time the Pirates won the World Series, it is the last time they won a playoff series. They haven’t won a division title since 1992 and they’ve never won the National League Central.
It is all a distant memory at this point, but the Pirates’ front office claims it wants to change that. I take them at their word, but if they do they will have to make some tough decisions in the next week that could have ramifications not just for this year, but beyond. And all of it could be dictated by the way the Pirates play in this homestand.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.