The Pirates gave their fans reason to hope when they rose to within 2½ games of first place in the National League Central. They had won back-to-back series against the division’s top two teams and it looked like their pitching staff might be rounding into form.
Then the All-Star break happened, and any momentum the Pirates seemed to be gaining was lost. The Pirates have lost four in a row and the pitching staff has regressed back to not being particularly effective.
It certainly isn’t time for the Pirates to panic (yet) because it is still July and there is a lot of baseball left. The Pirates are still only 5½ games out of first place and 3½ games out of the second wild-card spot, so they are only a winning streak away from being right back in the hunt. That’s especially true because it doesn’t look like any of the top three teams in the NL Central are capable of running away from the rest of the division.
That being said, the Pirates need to get moving if they really want to have a chance to contend this season. There is a lot of baseball left, but the Pirates are running out of time. It has taken at least 87 wins to clinch a wild-card spot in the National League (since the second wild-card was added in 2012) and the Pirates have a lot of work to do to get to that number.
The Pirates are 44-49, which means they need 43 wins in order to get to 87. They play only 69 more games, which means they’d have to play at a .623 clip (43-26) the rest of the way, which seems a bit unrealistic. They haven’t played that well for any significant portion of the season, and there really is no reason to believe they can or will now.
However, they have played well enough in short spurts that it is too early to give up on the rest of the season. The most important thing for the Pirates will be to somehow find some pitching consistency. That’s been their biggest issue of late and has been the biggest reason they are in this predicament.
Read More
They have had a hard time stringing together a solid run of quality starts and they have had a harder time finding any kind of consistency from the bullpen. A great example is Kyle Crick, who at one point was (at least by numbers) the Pirates’ most consistent and effective reliever. Crick was the eighth inning “setup” man, and the combination of him and closer Felipe Vazquez was at one point formidable.
Crick has been so ineffective recently that he has gone from setup man to mopup man, as evidenced by the fact he was used Monday with the Pirates down 5-0. He didn’t do much to show he warrants consideration to move back into a role of significance in the bullpen as he gave up a two-run homer and couldn’t even finish the inning.
The Pirates have bigger pitching issues than Crick, though. Jordan Lyles is probably one more bad start away from being pushed to the bullpen. Steven Brault had strung together a few good outings, but he was put on the injured list. Trevor Williams is supposed to be the staff ace, but he has been getting shelled since he came back from the injured list. Chris Archer was solid his last time out (though he still gave up three runs in six innings), but he has been mostly underwhelming.
The pitching staff’s inconsistency is what makes many believe this team probably doesn’t have a legitimate run in them. I tend to lean to that side of things, but I am not quite ready to label this team as dead. They have shown a knack for fighting back when they are counted out, so I’m willing to give them a little longer before I bury them.
This current series against St Louis is pivotal, but I don’t believe it is the end of the road even if they lose the next two games. They follow this series with 10 games that will tell the tale of their season. They play three at home against the fading and pitching-starved Phillies, then four at home against St Louis, then go on the road for three against the struggling Mets.
At that point it will be the trade deadline, and if the Pirates are still lingering under .500, it is likely they will be out of the division race. This season isn’t dead yet, but the Pirates are no doubt hanging on by a thread and need to get on a roll here pretty quickly to save it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.