Tony Clark again has expressed his concerns about Major League Baseball teams not spending enough money on players and not trying to win. He said the players’ union is concerned there are too many teams pocketing the money from revenue sharing and not investing it into the teams.

“The system we have now allows for dollars to be moved from one club to another,” said Clark, the MLB Players Association executive director. “The MLBPA anticipates that each team will use those dollars in a fashion that improves the product on the field. That is what the agreement suggests.”

Clark this week also discussed the grievance that was filed by the MLBPA citing four teams, the Pirates being one, as not investing enough in players. His thoughts are that teams should spend more money, get better players and put the best product as possible on the field. Clark said fans in some cities, including Pittsburgh, are frustrated because their favorite teams won’t spend money to win.

“Our industry is driven by fan engagement. Fans in Pittsburgh were already showing their frustration before the grievance,” Clark said. “We want fans in all 30 markets to feel excited about what the team they’re following is putting on the field. It’s not going to be a surprise if fans raise concerns. Our industry is in the best place when fans know the team is doing everything it can to put the best product on the field. Fans want to see their team find the best players possible and put the team in the best position they can to be the last team standing.

Advertise with us

“We want a healthy game, and the game is at its best when teams have the incentive to win. Fans in Pittsburgh and everywhere else shouldn’t have to question if their team is trying its best to win.”

Of course, this required a response from MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred, who said Clark’s assertions are not supported by facts. And then Manfred went one bridge too far with his line of defense when he said, “Every single one [team] wants to win.”

Um, no, Mr. Manfred, every single one of your teams is not trying to win. Some of them are embarrassing the MLB brand with the product they put out on the field. It is ridiculous that in some cities, fans know before the season that their team is headed for somewhere in the neighborhood of 100 losses.

I don’t agree with Clark that spending more money on players is necessarily the answer because there are so many good players to go around. Teams shouldn’t just artificially inflate the salaries of players who haven’t earned it, are mediocre or just barely hanging on as major leaguers.

Clark and his union do have a point that star players and players who have proven to be really good major leaguers far too often are getting nickel and dimed instead of compensated properly. The annual offseason ritual where teams wait around to sign players until they are basically desperate and willing to take far less than their value is a disgrace.

Advertise with us

All of that being said, there is a very simple solution to all of this, and Clark holds the key to making it happen: a salary cap. I want to believe that Clark is competent at his job, but the fact that he won’t begin to approach this subject makes me wonder. A salary cap is seen as the enemy of the players when in fact it’s the opposite.

Clark, who in many ways is just a puppet for the most powerful and influential agents, is resistant to any suggestion of a salary cap. And that is mostly because he is stuck on the word “cap” and doesn’t seem to want to acknowledge that with that cap would come a salary floor. And a sensible salary cap system will still allow the star players to get their big dollars.

A salary floor, though, would help the middle-class of players. A team like the Pirates would have to spend more on salaries to get to the floor and that would mean the middle-class players’ price tags will increase.

The NFL, NBA and NHL all have different, yet successful, examples of what a salary cap can look like and do for a league and its players. The MLBPA, though, refuses to acknowledge that the quarterbacks and pass rushers, the superstars in the NBA and the best NHL players are all getting the big money they deserve despite the salary cap.

Obviously, it would take some work to figure out a salary cap system that makes sense in baseball, but it would improve the league. It would also force teams to sign free agents for their values instead of waiting until they have to come crawling for scraps.

Advertise with us

I want to believe Clark is truly fighting for his players’ best interests. I just can’t quite get there, though, because he has been so resistant to standing up to agents and pushing for a system that will actually benefit the majority of players and not just the top ones.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise