Joe Maddon was upset that Pirates pitcher Jordan Lyles was pitching inside to Cubs hitters Thursday. We know this because he angrily ran onto the field and had to be restrained after Lyles nearly hit Javier Baez in the head with a pitch.
We also know this because he said as much after the game.
“I mean, pent-up frustration is one thing, but when your guys keep getting thrown at their head, that's another thing, too," Maddon said. "It's an industry-wide concept that we know that they are into and I have it from really good sources."
Maddon then added, “It was getting way too out of control, culminating in David [Bote] getting hit in the head. I have no issues with pitching inside. I'm an advocate, but when you [throw] that many pitches, not just tonight, but it's been that way somewhat during the entire series. They have their pitching philosophy which again I appreciate outside, I don't appreciate up and in. Neither do the rest of us, they just need to be careful."
Maddon isn’t the first opposing manager to point out that the Pirates’ philosophy is to pitch inside. He also isn’t the first opposing manager to take exception to it. Maddon is arrogant and somewhat of a jerk, but in this particular situation, he was absolutely right.
The Pirates do like to play the victim a lot when some of their hitters are hit by opposing pitchers, but in large part they bring it on themselves. The Pirates are not shy about their pitching philosophy and make it clear they will always try and move batters off the plate with inside pitches.
Read More
If that is the philosophy, that is fine, but then don’t be shocked when other teams get fed up with it and retaliate. Honestly, I was shocked that Tyler Chatwood didn’t plant one in the middle of Josh Bell’s back with two outs and nobody on in the eighth.
I keep hearing people apologize for the Pirates by saying they don’t hit batters any more than anyone else. I’m not sure where that idea comes from, but the numbers in recent years seem to suggest something different.
Pirates pitchers are fourth in the National League in hitting batters this year (39 HBP). Last season they finished fourth in that category. They were indeed below the league average of 59 in 2017, but they were fourth in 2016, first in 2015 and first in 2014.
Now, that doesn’t mean all of those are intentional, and probably very few of them are, but at the end of the day they are still hitting a lot of batters relative to the rest of the league. And that’s why they can’t complain when their guys get hit, because that’s the way baseball is played — “You hit one of ours, we hit one of yours.”
Pirates fans and people around the team often react in outrage when one of the Pirates’ players is hit by a pitch. They also often want the Pirates to retaliate and they would celebrate it if Clint Hurdle went out to raise a stink and got ejected for it. They would talk about how he has his players’ backs and how he is willing to protect them.
Maddon didn’t really do anything different here. For one thing, a big part of it was a theatrical production. He is feeling the heat, the team is in trouble, the general manager is threatening to break it all up, they aren’t playing good baseball — this looked a lot like a desperate manager looking to provide a spark.
Beyond that, though, Maddon was simply sticking up for his players because Lyles came inside and high at least twice before he nearly hit Baez. That’s what a good manager should do. The fact that he didn’t have one of his pitchers throw at one of the Pirates’ batters shows how desperately they needed a win.
Maddon and the Cubs are an unlikable bunch. They are overly arrogant considering they have only won the National League pennant and World Series one time in these past five years. They are clearly an aging group trying to hold on for one last run and thus they are getting cranky because nobody fears them any more.
That being said, they weren’t wrong Thursday at PNC Park and Maddon wasn’t wrong to object to the pitches getting thrown high and tight at his batters. It wasn’t overly bright of him to essentially threaten the Pirates by saying he can’t wait to get them at Wrigley next week, but the sentiment isn’t wrong.
I fully expect the Cubs to retaliate next weekend, and when they do, I won’t have any issue with it. The Pirates are good at a lot of things, and hitting batters happens to be one of them.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.