Pirates president Frank Coonelly told KDKA-TV that the team is in the planning stages of extending the safety netting at PNC Park to at or near the foul poles. Coonelly said the Pirates are doing this on their own and are not going to wait for a directive from Major League Baseball because they want to ensure the safety of everyone who attends Pirates games.
I say good for Coonelly. Good for the Pirates. Good for Major League Baseball. And good for anyone else who has helped move the “debate” about netting in the right direction. There is no reason teams shouldn’t extend netting in the lower deck at least through the area where fans are in danger of getting directly hit with a line-drive foul ball.
Of course this has sparked the predictable push back from a certain segment of fans that say netting is not necessary and it is an overreaction to relatively rare occurrences when a fan has gotten hit with a ball and seriously injured. The latest incident happened at Minute Maid Park when a foul ball off the bat of Albert Almora Jr. struck and injured a young girl.
That incident not only has MLB considering measures to prevent further injuries, but a number of players have also called for extension of the netting to protect fans from errant line drives.
There simply is no reason for this not to happen in every park in the league. It is idiotic that it hasn’t happened, and I am one who doesn’t like knee-jerk changes. These things happen from time to time and they are easily preventable.
I have to laugh, though, when I hear the arguments against netting. I’m as libertarian as anyone and agree with the idea of personal responsibility. I also know that people in general aren’t responsible, and if we can save them from themselves without infringing on their rights, we should. I think it is OK to use common sense, and this is a very easy common sense fix for an infrequent yet serious problem.
Read More
You don’t have a right to sit at a baseball game without netting. This is a private entity understanding that it can make an environment a little bit safer.
I’ve heard the counter arguments, and every one of them is weak and really grasping at straws.
“But you will ruin the atmosphere of the game if you make people watch it through netting...”
Really? Because the people who sit in the most expensive seats have been watching games behind netting for years. And they seem to continue to keep coming back to the ballpark ever year. And the reason they do is because they quickly adapted to the fact that there is netting between them and the field. This thing that somehow your experience is ruined if you have to watch through nets is downright dumb.
“But part of the experience is catching foul balls...”
You can still catch foul balls; many are pop ups and go over the netting anyway. People in the upper decks catch foul balls, so it isn’t like the balls wouldn’t go into the stands over the netting anyway. And often when a foul ball stays in the park, the players get it and then toss it into the stands anyway. This is not an argument that holds any water at all.
“But you will take away the chance to get autographs...”
I didn’t realize you needed to get an autograph to enjoy a baseball game. And here is the thing, again: The people in the most expensive seats have figured out how to get autographs pregame, as have the people who sit in the outfield seats. Is it the same as being able to reach over the railing and get a ball signed? No, but it isn’t impossible to get them even with netting and it wouldn’t render them rare.
All told, the netting debate shouldn’t even be a debate. I look at hockey, where fans are separated from the players and games by glass and wonder how those fans could ever have fun or get autographs at the games. I also think the “people should leave their babies at home” crowd is ridiculous.
It would be one thing if there weren’t a logical and easy fix to make the games safer for kids sitting in the lower deck, but there is and it is one that should be implemented. Nets aren’t going to cut down sight lines, and they aren’t going to change the ambiance of the park or the smells of hot dogs and burgers or change fan experience enough for people to notice.
It is time for every team to follow the Pirates’ lead and extend their netting to make the game a little safer for fans who attend the games.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.