Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
Bruno: Is JuJu capable of being a #1 WR, and will he catch over 100 passes? And who besides Vance McDonald will be Ben's best 2nd target?
Paul: Yes, I don’t know why he wouldn’t be. He has a lot of physical talent and proved last season he can be a big playmaker. He runs good routes, he’s a physical receiver and can catch the ball in traffic and even after he gets hit. He has every tool a receiver needs to be a star. I also think there is a great chance he won’t have nearly as much focus on him as people think because Ben Roethlisberger will spread the ball around. If a team is going to load up to stop Smith-Schuster, well, that’s going to leave a lot of other receivers wide open. He will make a lot of plays, but I doubt he will have 100 catches.
Jason: If you had to choose, who are you trading at the trade deadline, if anyone, and why?
Paul: I will assume you mean the Pirates. And I honestly say it would depend on where they are in the standings. If they are still under .500, then I say clean it all out. I’d look to trade Corey Dickerson, Melky Cabrera, Francisco Cervelli, Chris Archer, Felipe Vazquez and Starling Marte and call it a day. They would all have some value on some level. I’d then DFA or trade (if he starts hitting) Jung Ho Kang and bring up Ke’Bryan Hayes and start him at third base for the rest of the season. At that point there is no reason not to move those players, save some money, get some playing time for the younger players such as Hayes and look to take a real shot in 2020. If they are in playoff contention, I probably don’t trade anyone except maybe Dickerson, then try to flip some prospects for a starting pitcher and a reliever.
Jason: Are the Pirates trending up with key members getting healthy? And when it’s all said and done with everyone healthy, who would you like to see in our final starting rotation?
Read More
Paul: They are getting healthy, which is a great development, but there is now a very difficult road ahead of them. We shall see which way they are trending rather quickly, actually. Jameson Taillon is probably down for the season, so the rotation should be eventually Trevor Williams, Archer, Joe Musgrove, Jordan Lyles and Steven Brault. If Brault falters a little, maybe give Mitch Keller a few more shots — especially if the Pirates fall out of contention.
George: With the success of Bryan Reynolds and after trading Andrew McCutchen and getting him, who could have imagined the Pirates could have traded Starling Marte or Gregory Polanco instead of Austin Meadows last year and be better off now? If only the Pirates had this foresight. What do you think?
Paul: I’ll use a Clint Hurdlism “Hindsight is 20/15...” That being said I don’t think Tampa would have taken Polanco. He is injury-prone, a terrible fielder and a streaky hitter. And Marte is a 30-something, and the Rays wanted younger players. I think the Pirates gave up too much prospect equity for Archer, but it was a deal they thought they needed to make, and those deals require a team to overpay. Reynolds has been a steal so far. The funny thing is we would never have seen him if Lonnie Chisenhall and Dickerson stayed healthy.
Chad: Why do you think Pitt football doesn't schedule Duquesne for a nonconference opponent? They surely would draw better than Youngstown St., Villanova, and any other FCS team.
Paul: I don’t know, other than they like to spread the wealth to those FCS schools, so to speak. And I don’t think it would change the attendance all that much. It is a game I’d like to see from time to time, but are we sure Duquesne would want to play it? They can go elsewhere against a Power Five team for a guarantee game and get a lot more money than they’d get from Pitt since they wouldn’t have to travel. I think we will see this game at some point soon, but I’m really not sure either team would have much to gain from it.
Gapper: Paul, if you could pick one outcome what would it be: Have a hole in one during a round or breaking 70?
Paul: I would definitely choose the latter. A hole in one is almost 100 percent luck. Yes, you have to hit a good shot to get a hole in one, but guys hit great shots off the tee on par 3s every day and they don’t roll perfectly into the hole. To break 70, you have to play great golf from start to finish, and that is a lot more about ability than luck.
Mark: Hey Paul, what do you think of Ed Henry as a coach?
Paul: Well, I was all for putting him in the Hall of Fame until he got beat by the “Fake 23 blast with a Backside Georgia Reverse” for 75 yards on the last play of the game. I mean what kind of prevent defense is that? How in the heck do you allow the Rev to run 75 yards with time expired? And come on, man, you let “Sunshine” Ronnie Bass block all your guys? Yeah, I was a big fan of Henry’s gameday prowess until he botched the end of that championship.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise. Get Pittsburgh sports news in your inbox Monday through Friday by signing up for our PG Sports Feed newsletter.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.