Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, former Alcorn State star Larry Smith (aka “Mr. Mean”) and everything in between.
BrianK, @BrianPKos: Ok Joe I will bite. There had to be one underlying thing to cause the uptick in Pitt football recruiting. Was it that Aaron Donald got more involved? If not, what is it?
Starkey: I’m not sure it’s one thing, Brian, and thank you for biting. It can’t hurt that the best defensive player in the NFL went to Pitt and is so visibly involved with Pitt — just as it can’t hurt that James Conner works next door — but I’m thinking it’s more Pitt’s newfound stability at the top, where coach Pat Narduzzi is entering Year 5, and the hard work of the coaching staff that has led to a so-far impressive class.
It’s also wise to keep in mind that ratings fluctuate — and will do so all the way into December.
For now, I think plenty of credit should go to assistant coaches such as Charlie Partridge and Chris Beatty. Here’s a little nugget from Craig Meyer’s story in the Post-Gazette, regarding defensive tackle Timothy Brown of Palm Beach Gardens, Fla. …
“The towering Brown, at 6-foot-4 and 240 pounds, selected Pitt among a crowded group of suitors that included offers from Auburn, Penn State, Miami, Florida State, Central Florida, West Virginia, Florida, Mississippi and Nebraska. He’s the sixth prospect from south Florida to commit to the Panthers for this class, many of whom were recruited by assistant head coach/defensive line coach Charlie Partridge.”
Read More
And you must have seen that highly regarded running back Israel Abanikanda went to Abraham Lincoln High School in Brooklyn, N.Y., which also produced, as Meyer wrote, “a bevy of accomplished graduates, from Neil Diamond to Marv Albert to Arthur Miller to, athletically, Stephon Marbury, Sebastian Telfair, Lance Stephenson and the fictional Jesus Shuttlesworth from Spike Lee’s 1998 film “He Got Game.”
That got me to thinking, Brian, about …
TOP THREE NEIL DIAMOND SONGS
3. Song Sung Blue
2. Kentucky Woman
1. Cracklin’ Rosie
OVERRATED
September Morn
UNDERRATED
Gitchy Goomy
WORST LINE
“No one heard at all, not even the chair.” Not even the chair? Really, Neil? This from the same guy who wrote “I’m a Believer.”
BEST LINE
“Song she sang to me, song she brang to me, words that rang in me, rhyme that sprang from me, warmed the night — and what was right became me.” Yes it did, Neil. Yes it did, although “brang” might be a questionable word choice.
BEST BASKETBALL MOVIES OF ALL-TIME
3. “Hoop Dreams.” And as of 2015, an update on the key players.
2. “Hoosiers.” I feel like Dennis Hopper’s coaching acumen often gets overlooked. His game-ending out-of-bounds play was incredible.
1. “The Fish That Saved Pittsburgh.” Really not close — and to bring things full circle, the film included Marv Albert, of Abraham Lincoln High School.
Matt dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: With Mickey Callaway blow-up in New York have you ever gotten into it with a coach or player?
Starkey: Nah, they’ve all been nice to me.
OF COURSE I HAVE.
In order, my top blowouts with athletes:
4. Tom Barrasso. Challenged me to join a Penguins practice and shoot on him. (I resisted the urge to reply, “Sure — and how about I take one from center ice, just like Tom Fitzgerald?”)
3. Antwaan Randle El: Didn’t like a piece I wrote saying the Bengals had given Carson Palmer better weapons than the Steelers gave Ben Roethlisberger. Sean Morey, believe it or not, was the instigator here, holding a copy of the story as Randle El and I went nose to nose. We later made up, and I have tremendous respect for him.
2. Marlon Byrd: Didn’t like that I mentioned to another reporter he wasn’t taking any more questions.
1. Jaromir Jagr: Suggested I take a framed photo of him to my house and pray to it. (I declined.)
S4mereye, @xXSamereyeXx: In the last 5 years, if you had a lottery pick and only one, who'd be that pick you'd start your team rebuild with? Let's say you're the Suns w/ almost no talent. Not the Lakers w/ LeBron.
Starkey: Luka Doncic, without question. Donovan Mitchell would be next, then Ben Simmons if I’m looking at the past five lotteries (though I’m very curious to see Zion, and unlike many, I think he’ll be great right away). What I notice most in reviewing the past five drafts is how very few truly great players have emerged.
Zack Hough, @Hoagie7187: With this really tough stretch of games for the Pirates, does this stretch determine if they are buyers or sellers? I believe they should sell either way.
Starkey: Yes, Mr. Hoagie, I believe the next 26 games are against teams ahead of them in the standings, and that will take them near the July 31 deadline. Neal Huntington might wait and make his decision then. Question is, if they are around .500 and, say, three games out of the second wild card, does that mean buy or sell? I’m selling, like you, in that case.
Michael griser, @steeltown67: Joe, could you pick the all time Steelers offense? 5 OL, 2 WR, 2 RB, TE, QB. Always a fun bar debate but wonder what your thoughts are.
Starkey: Yes, I could. And I shall:
QB: Ben
RB: Franco, Jerome
WR: Stallworth, Hines (Big Chest might quit the week of our big game, so forget him)
TE: HEEEEEEEEEEEEEEATH!
T: Tunch Ilkin, Larry Brown
G: Faneca, DeCastro
C: Webster
Isaac Summers, @IsaacSummers11: Who will have a better Pirates career, Andrew McCutchen or Brian Reynolds?
Starkey: Wow. A little early for that question considering “Bryan” Reynolds is basically two months into his career, Isaac. That said, I love everything about him. Including his Johnny Cash walk-up music.
And yes, we’ll finish with this:
TOP JOHNNY CASH SONGS
3. Jackson
2. Flesh and Blood
1. Ring of Fire
(Editor's note: Reader David Hunter pointed out that "Walk The Line" is actually the best Johnny Cash song, and he is right. I hang my head in great shame. I simply forgot. It was also a great movie in which Reese Witherspoon and Joaquin Phoenix did their own singing and were as good as the originals. Or better. Thank you, David.)
Adam Perry, @deathglory80: By what year will the Pirates win another division title? It's been 27 years.
Starkey: I’m thinking 3021, for sure Mr. Death Glory, but they might surprise me.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.