Neal Huntington said Sunday during his radio show that he believes the Pirates, despite being 32-39 and in last place in the National League Central, can get on a roll and get back into contention for a wild card in the next few weeks. Huntington’s comments were met with some polite snickers, but he is actually not as delusional as he seems.
I don’t know that the Pirates have a realistic shot of catching the Brewers or Cubs in the division race. The math in that regard is daunting and not in the Pirates’ favor. Let’s say the Cubs and Brewers both go .500 the rest of the way. That’s not likely because both teams are among the best in the National League, but let’s say they do that — both will end up with 85 wins. The Pirates would have to go 53-38 down the stretch to get to 85 wins, and that is not likely, either.
The wild card will even be a test for the Pirates, as they would need about four teams to fold in order to catch up.
That being said, the Pirates could be poised to make a little bit of a run. The Pirates have a five-game homestand starting Tuesday night against two bad teams. The Tigers come in for two games, and then the Pirates host the Padres for three more. This is the kind of stretch — combined with the three they just played against the Marlins — that a team with hopes of turning the season around needs to take advantage of.
More importantly, the Pirates appear to be getting some reinforcements back for their pitching staff. Trevor Williams will return to the team and make his first start since May 16 because he had a strain in his side. Williams has been the Pirates’ best and most consistent pitcher since the All-Star break last year, so his return will go a long way toward solving some of the most pressing issues.
The Pirates will also get Jordan Lyles back in this homestand, and that is a huge development, as well. Nobody in their right mind would have said something like that about Lyles at the start of the season, but he was in the midst of an excellent season (relative to expectations) before he went down with a hamstring injury June 8.
Read More
The return of Lyles and Williams means the Pirates can go back to having some semblance of a major league pitching staff. It means they now have a solid rotation again and don’t have to go to the “minor leaguer of the week” or some version of the opener to start games. It also means that there is less pressure on Joe Musgrove and Chris Archer to carry the load, and perhaps that will help both relax a little and pitch better and more consistently.
Steven Brault has given the Pirates three solid starts in a row, and that’s another huge development for the Pirates. His development means the Pirates can now set a rotation and set up their bullpen. And if Archer and Musgrove get going and pitch like they are capable of consistently, the outlook will suddenly improve dramatically.
Archer is in many ways still the key. He hasn’t been anywhere close to the pitcher the Pirates thought they were getting when they traded for him last year at the trade deadline. It is worse than that, though, as he hasn’t just been an underachiever, he has been bordering on a total bust.
It is pretty telling as to just how far expectations have fallen for Archer that Clint Hurdle was praising him Sunday — after the Pirates beat the Marlins — for battling through an awful fourth inning and getting through the fifth. Forget that he needed 42 pitches to get through the fourth inning and got lit up like a Christmas tree by what is essentially a Class AAA lineup; he works hard and he never quit!!
Archer needs to be much better and not just because of the haul the Pirates gave up to get him. He was expected to be one of the cornerstones of the team and an anchor of the rotation. He needs to be better because the Pirates are still without one of their aces, Jameson Taillon, and that means he needs to pick up some of that slack.
I don’t know if the Pirates will get into playoff contention or not, and a big part of me thinks they have too steep of a hill to climb. However, I don’t think Huntington is out of line to suggest that things are pointing in the right direction for them and that they do have a chance to get on a roll.
The combination of a homestand (even though they haven’t exactly played great at home this year so far), two bad visiting teams and a pitching staff that is suddenly healthy gives them a chance. And as we saw last summer when the Pirates got hot and won 11 in a row around the All-Star break, winning can become contagious.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.