The Major League Baseball season is moving quickly toward that time when teams must make a decision on whether to buy or sell at the trade deadline. There are still about six weeks left before the deadline, but front offices must now begin to realistically look at what their club is capable of and begin to devise a plan
It is true fortunes can change quickly and so none of these plans are written in stone. The Pirates last season were a great example, as they were approaching the trade deadline as sellers but then they got hot and put themselves into the playoff hunt. That forced the front office’s hand and they acquired pitchers Keone Kela and Chris Archer.
Those moves didn’t translate into a playoff run, but both were made with the future in mind because neither player was of the “rental” variety and the team had multiple years of control.
This season has not gone as planned for the Pirates, though, and it is looking again like they may be approaching the deadline as sellers. They are 30-35, have lost 15 of their last 21 games, and have had to deal with a rash of injuries to key players. Their pitching has not lived up to expectations and that’s especially true with regard to the bullpen, which was supposed to be a team strength.
It is very clear the Pirates should let go of any flights of fantasy about a playoff run and commit to being sellers. And that should not change even if they get hot and reel off 11 consecutive wins again like they did last year. It is a tough position to be in if you are the Pirates, though, because you are still trying to sell tickets to a fan base that has increasingly lost faith in ownership.
That can’t be a consideration, though, as the Pirates need to focus on next year. The first step is for them to shed some salary, create some spots on the roster and give as much playing time as possible to the rookies and younger players.
Read More
The second step is to be aggressive in the offseason and try to build a better, deeper roster for the 2020 season. This second step hasn’t been something the Pirates have done in the past, but they need to now. They need to give themselves a real chance to compete in 2020 and the only way to do that is to spend some money to acquire talent.
That is down the road, though, and the first step is the trading deadline. The Pirates have some players that seem like obvious candidates to be on the trading block. They have some veterans on expiring contracts or players like Starling Marte who have a big club option the Pirates aren’t likely to exercise.
Here is the rub: The realistic return for almost all of what the Pirates have to sell is not particularly significant. The Pirates will not be able to bring in a haul of prospects or younger players under control for a few years because they just don’t have that many assets that are likely to be in demand.
That is unless they are willing to part ways with closer Felipe Vazquez, who has an extremely team-friendly contract through 2023 (two contract years, two club option years). And there is an argument to be made that they should think about trading Vazquez because he would be in such demand. He is the one player the Pirates have that teams would overpay to acquire.
Marte could have some value in a trade — especially if there is an injury that makes a contending team desperate enough for an outfielder — but I don’t know what exactly he would bring. Marte has been a bit of an enigma for most of his career. His numbers never seem to reflect his enormous potential, but nevertheless he is an excellent defensive player and a team might give the Pirates something for him.
Corey Dickerson and Melky Cabrera would bring minimal return, as both are basically depth players. There would be some interest in Jordan Lyles and even Archer, but Lyles is now hurt and Archer is supposed to be a cornerstone of the rotation the next two years.
There is no question the Pirates can find a place for all of those players as they all are legitimate major leaguers. The problem is they will basically have to give them away for almost nothing, and I am not sure that helps them improve other than it frees up salary money to be used elsewhere.
This will be an active trade deadline period for the Pirates, and it should be because they are selling off assets and creating roster space for younger and new players. That should happen and it is the right approach. Don’t be shocked, though, if the return on their trades is underwhelming because outside of Marte and Vazquez, they have very few players who will command much of a market.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.