The Pirates were baseball’s laughing-stock franchise when Neal Huntington arrived in 2007. They were clearly one of the worst teams in Major League Baseball and clearly one of the worst-run franchises. Huntington and his staff rebuilt the Pirates talent base and guided the team to the playoffs three years in a row from 2013-15.
The 2013 season not only marked the Pirates’ first playoff appearance since 1992, it was also the team’s first winning season in that span. Nothing more clearly illustrates the impact Huntington and his staff had on transforming the Pirates into a competitive franchise.
That’s all in the history books, though, and the world of professional sports is a world where “what have you done for me lately” is what really matters. Huntington deserves all the praise and credit he got for what he built from 2007 until 2015.
The problem is this is 2019, and Huntington and company have not had nearly as good of a run in the last four years. Huntington has had a number of bad trades and bad decisions and maybe even got too full of himself and his knowledge of analytics, and the result has been a team that hasn’t been to the playoffs since 2015.
This season had some promise, but injuries have really hurt the team’s progress. The injuries have also, though, shown just how poorly Huntington has built the organization’s pitching depth he so often raves about.
The Pirates’ bullpen is a mess right now and has far too many pitchers in it who are not good enough to be in the major leagues. Yes, there have been injuries to Keone Kela and Edgar Santana, but the loss of two relievers shouldn’t result in the mess we’ve had to watch the last few weeks.
Read More
Huntington likes to point out they also lost Nick Burdi, whose legend seems to grow every time Richard Rodriguez gives up a home run, but the reality is he gave up more runs (9) than he had innings pitched (8⅓) and his WHIP (1.62) was worse than that of Clay Holmes (1.58) and the aforementioned Rodriguez (1.59).
Nick Kingham and Steven Brault were the “depth starters” that Huntington was so proud of in the preseason. Both have been called into duty and, for the most part, have been a disaster. Brault has some usefulness as a left-handed reliever and opener-type starter, but Kingham has shown nothing that suggests he should be in the rotation.
Kingham, Rodriguez and Holmes have plenty of company on the staff in the “not good enough for a team serious about winning” category.
That is precisely why Huntington has to earn his money now. The Pirates may not be a World Series contender, but there are enough pieces in place for them to at least contend to be a playoff team. And despite all of the injuries, they are still in the hunt, only five games out of first place.
Huntington talked on Sunday about all of the “challenges” of making trades this early in the season. He talked about how the Pirates would have to “overpay” for the help they’d need and that there aren’t many teams out there ready to start selling off assets. To his credit, Huntington acknowledges that he hasn’t done a good job in building pitching depth and said that is something he will look to correct.
“The weakest part of any team is your middle relief,” Huntington said Sunday. “We’ve struggled there. I haven’t done a good job in getting the right guys at the right times from the right spots. It’s hurt us. There’s no doubt about it. … Our run differential is not good.”
What Huntington needs to do is stop talking about the challenges, stop talking about how teams want too much in return and stop talking about how the Pirates may not have the assets to make the necessary deals. That stuff might have flown in 2010 or 2011 when the team was still rebuilding, but all of it is excuse-making now.
Huntington is being paid to fix the problem, period. That’s especially true because it is a problem he created, and he has nobody else to blame but himself. He needs to stop talking and go out and find the help this team so desperately needs and — given how much they have fought and battled to stay in contention — deserves.
The three playoff seasons were a wonderful ride for the Pirates and a well-deserved feather in Huntington’s cap. They are ancient history now, and the Pirates’ fan base is past being excited about a young team working hard that finishes with 82 wins.
This team is in a critical part of the season and lacking enough firepower to realistically survive it, and it is up to Huntington to make sure that he gives them the necessary parts to stay afloat until their starting players get healthy again.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.