Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
Rob:How is it that Neal Huntington has been drafting mostly pitchers for over a decade, yet the Pirates’ depth in that department is so poor?
Paul: Drafting is only part of the equation. Development is a much larger part, and I think the Pirates have failed in that regard under Huntington. There have been too many misses among their early draft choices to think otherwise. I refuse to believe they are bad at evaluating players. I think they are drafting the right players; there just seems to be a disconnect when it comes to development. The Pirates should have better pitchers available by now and more depth than they do.
George: Now I have to suffer watching Jordan Luplow hit homer after homer for the Cleveland Indians. Why did the Pirates miss on this one too?
Paul: Isn’t it fun being a Pirates fan? I know he hit two home runs or whatever the other day, but let’s pump the brakes on putting him in the Hall of Fame. He is hitting .247/.303, and he has six home runs and 11 RBIs. Players will get traded away and succeed; it is a part of the game.
George: Will the Pirates win one game against the Dodgers this year?
Read More
Paul: There are few guarantees in life. The one thing I can absolutely guarantee is that the Pirates will not beat the Dodgers once in the 2019 regular season. Of course, that’s mostly just because they don’t play the Dodgers again this year, but who is paying attention to that? The Dodgers have dominated the Pirates this season. They have, in so many ways, shown just how far away the Pirates are from being a legitimate contender. They are 0-6 against the Dodgers and have been outscored in those games 44-20. It hasn’t been that close.
Justin: Is there another team that would even consider starting Colin Moran at third base? How about Cole Tucker at shortstop? What about Adam Frazier at second? Is there any other staff that Nick Kingham would get multiple starts for? The Pirates’ biggest problem is they have too many part-time players as regulars.
Paul: That is a very good point. Frazier should be a utility player, not an everyday second baseman. Moran is a nice bat off the bench and a solid option as a pinch hitter and occasional starter in the field. He isn’t a good enough fielder to merit putting him out there unless he is going to hit a heck of a lot better than he has. Tucker is young but has become basically an automatic out. Kingham isn’t particularly good in any area. Some of this has been driven by injuries, but some of it is the Pirates trying to convince anyone that would listen that they could have success despite the lack of depth they had in certain spots.

Charles: You Fan guys were at Seven Springs last week. Did you notice the new ski lifts? They have to be there because Bob Nutting isn’t spending money on the Pirates payroll so he has to be paying for something. What do you think would have to happen before MLB would step in and force him to sell the team?
Paul: No, I did not notice new ski lifts, though they were remodeling the main lobby at the ski lodge. So there’s that. I do agree that Bob Nutting needs to spend a little more money than he did this year, but I also think sometimes — like this question — people go overboard crushing Nutting for not spending money.
Greg: Who do you blame most for the state of the Pirates: Bob Nutting, Clint Hurdle or Neal Huntington? I feel like Nutting gets too much blame and Huntington gets too much of a pass.
Paul: Nutting signs the checks. Nutting hires and fires people. Nutting sets the budget. Nutting has the final say over just about anything. In other words, I am not sure how you can blame any of this mess on anyone other than him. The buck stops with him, and he has to do a better job of giving his front office the tools necessary to be fully successful.
Douglass: How can you defend a jerk like Derek Dietrich? His antics are amateur hour, and I wish someone from the Pirates would bury a fastball in his chest.
Paul: I have not defended him and will not defend him. His antics, his home run trots and bat flips are amusing on some level, but they are also immature and selfish. I simply said if you defended Antonio Brown when he did his silliness, you need to defend Dietrich, too. You can’t have it both ways. Either you hate all celebrations or you hate none of them.
Edward: What is the point of bringing back Corey Dickerson now? He doesn’t have a spot anymore, he is a free agent after the season and he will just steal at-bats and reps from Bryan Reynolds.
Paul: The Pirates need to showcase Dickerson a little bit if they want to get anything in return for him.He needs to prove he is truly healthy and capable of coming back and contributing to a winning team. I will be shocked if he is still a member of the Pirates at the trade deadline.
Ron: Is Drake the most annoying celebrity fan of all time, or do you think there were/was worse?
Paul: No doubt Barbra Streisand, noted Dodgers fan. She is obnoxious for many reasons, and this is just one more.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.