Jordan Lyles
CINCINNATI — Clint Hurdle isn’t ready to think about the totality of it all.
Neither is Jordan Lyles.
They’re also not about to start making excuses.
But as the Pirates suffered yet another injury to a pitcher when Lyles made an early exit during their 11-6 loss to the Reds on Tuesday at Great American Ball Park, it’s getting extremely difficult to ignore reality.
If Lyles, who left after four with left hamstring discomfort, has to miss his next start, the Pirates are down to two starting pitchers from their opening day rotation. Many expected those guys to carry the team this season, but nobody mentioned it would be to the training room.
Are the Pirates cursed? Did Mark Prior design their offseason throwing program? What the heck is happening here?
Read More
While the easy reaction might be for Lyles or Hurdle or another starter to throw up his hands in frustration, that’s precisely what they’re all refusing to do.
“You don’t compare, and you don’t wonder why,” Hurdle said. “You deal with what’s going on. It’s times like these where the leadership in the clubhouse, the leadership on the staff, the leadership I can provide, it shows up.
“You continue to encourage, you continue to coach, and you continue to work. It’s a great opportunity. At the end of the day, it’s going to make a lot of these guys tougher physically and tougher mentally.”
That sort of perspective might be tough to have, as the Pirates dropped their second in a row and seventh in the past nine. They’re now 26-27, under .500 for the first time since May 3, and their pitchers have a 7.54 ERA during that nine-game span.
It also might be difficult given what Lyles — who did say “I don’t see it being anything too serious” — has meant to this rotation.
Kevin Newman
Strange as it sounds considering that he was competing to be the fifth starter out of spring training, he’s actually been their rock, the most consistent member of the group. He entered the game fourth in the National League in ERA (2.81), while the Pirates had gone 8-1 in his starts, winning five straight.
Lyles’ transformation has been a popular topic around the Pirates recently, and general manager Neal Huntington on Sunday heaped the entirety of the praise on Lyles.
Lyles has experienced success in Pittsburgh, Huntington said, because the 28-year-old native of Hartsville, S.C., has been willing to change a few things with his pitch mix.
The Pirates have tried to feature Lyles’ four-seam fastball and his curveball while limiting the cutter, sinker and changeup to specific situations.
Lyles’ dominance showed up early, as he got through three innings while allowing just one run. He ran into trouble in the fourth when Derek Dietrich clobbered the first of his three home runs.
It was the seventh in 23 plate appearances for Dietrich against the Pirates.
“He’s hitting our mistakes extremely well,” Hurdle said. “We pregame plan. These balls are not where want ‘em, and he’s clobbering them. You tip your hat to him from that standpoint.”
After throwing strike one to Reds catcher Tucker Barnhart in the fourth, Elias Diaz motioned to the dugout for head athletic trainer Bryan Housand and Hurdle.
Lyles took a walk. A few test-it-out tosses followed. Then a lengthy conversation between Lyles and Hurdle, in which Lyles pleaded his case.
“I asked him, ‘Do you have a doctor’s degree?’ ” Hurdle said. “He just loves to compete.”
Lyles stayed in the game, retired the next two hitters to end the inning and sat down in the dugout thinking he probably better call it a night; something just didn’t feel right.
If Lyles goes on the injured list, he would be No. 23 this season, the 11th pitcher. It would actually be the second IL stint for Lyles, who earlier this season dealt with right-side discomfort.
It’s probably not the right time to make some sort of crazy assertion that the Pirates’ offseason training program must be revamped, but it does throw into question their ability to stay afloat.
What MLB team can win games with two healthy starting pitchers? The answer: not many.
At minimum, if the Lyles injury is serious, they’ll have to think about recalling Mitch Keller, who was optioned to Class AAA Indianapolis before the game.
This will also continue the chorus of people calling for the Pirates to sign a veteran major league starter, a request that gets more and more reasonable by the day.
On the other side, the Reds got a terrific outing from Lucas Sims, who made his 2019 season debut and wound up with career-highs in innings pitched (7 1/3) and strikeouts (9).
The Reds built a 10-0 lead before one of the few bits of good news for the Pirates unfolded. Kevin Newman hit his first MLB home run, a grand slam, with his father, John, in the stands. In the dugout, Newman’s teammates went nuts.
“The support from them is huge,” Newman said. “Not the ideal situation, but that’s kind of the clubhouse chemistry. We’re just all celebrating one another and the success that each other has. To get the first one and to see them respond like that was special.”
Maybe they were genuinely happy for Newman, who has seemingly seized the shortstop job, or maybe they were simply happy that nobody got hurt on a play.
It’s been a lot.
And although the Pirates don’t plan on using any excuses, how banged up their pitching staff is right now is sort of tough to ignore.
“We have the injury bug this year so far,” Lyles said. “Everyone knows it. Every team in baseball has injury problems and issues. We’re just having a little bit more than normal.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.