The Pirates have been remarkable in their ability to overcome a plethora of injuries this season. They entered Tuesday 24-20 and in third place in the always-tough NL Central despite the fact that they have had 20 players put on the injured list.
They have lost players at just about every position, but they continue to win games. They have had to piece together a pitching staff and even used the “opener” just to get through a rotation cycle. They will likely use the opener concept again Wednesday night against Colorado, and they will toy with the idea of putting Nick Kingham back in the rotation.
The Pirates right now are without their top two pitchers, Jameson Taillon and Trevor Williams. Taillon looks like he might have a long-term injury, perhaps even be out for the remainder of the season. Williams’ injury is relatively new, but there is some hope that he might be able to come back and get into the rotation soon.
Regardless of what happens with Williams, though, the Pirates remain one pitcher short of truly being able to compete for the long haul. And given the way the injury bug has hit them, the fact that they already have less than zero margin for error is troublesome.
Chris Archer has struggled to give the Pirates a lot of innings in his starts. He has been inefficient and throws a lot of pitches, and thus his outings have generally been short and required a lot of bullpen work to finish the games.
That fact, combined with the idea of an opener, means the Pirates’ bullpen could be taxed at least two starts through the rotation. And that assumes the other three pitchers all do their jobs and don’t have an off night. That, too, is not a recipe for long-term sustained success.
Read More
That’s why nearly everyone agrees the Pirates need to find starting pitching help, and sooner rather than later. There may be an internal option with Francisco Liriano, but he’d need to get stretched out and he has been a valuable member of the bullpen. He also has struggled in starting roles in recent years as he seems to be most useful in short stints and only when facing batters once.
There has recently been an outcry for the Pirates to bring up their top pitching prospect, Mitch Keller, from Class AAA Indianapolis. This isn’t a surprise because baseball fans often are eager to see the top prospects even if they aren’t ready. Keller has been one of the Pirates’ top prospects for several years and has worked his way up through the minor league system. He has, at times, been impressive and that’s the kind of thing that gets fans excited.
But Keller hasn’t been all that impressive at Class AAA. And the Pirates say he is trying to add one more pitch so that he can become an effective starter at the major league level, and he isn’t there yet. He has been fairly average this season so far, and if that’s the case at Class AAA, what makes anyone think he is ready to make the jump into the starting rotation for a team trying to contend for a playoff spot?
Keller is 4-0 but has pitched 40 innings with a 3.83 ERA and a WHIP of 1.5. He is walking 4.3 batters per nine innings, which is the worst he has done since his rookie season in 2014 in the Gulf Coast League. He simply isn’t ready yet, and he may need an entire season to be ready.
There is no reason for the Pirates to use him yet and risk starting his service-time clock prematurely. I often criticize the Pirates for their insistence on trying to maximize every single player’s years of control and arbitration years, but in this case they are correct to do it. Keller needs more time and he isn’t going to solve the Pirates’ problems.
That means the Pirates must find an external option and preferably one that is pitching currently in the major leagues. Dallas Keuchel is the easy name to bring up and the Pirates should indeed try to sign him, but he won’t be ready to help a team for at least a month while he gets in shape.
The Pirates need help now, and that means that they need to start to explore trade options immediately. It is true that a lot of teams are still trying to see whether they will buy or sell at the deadline, but there are some teams that already know they are out of it and may be ready to start selling assets.
The Pirates have been one of the best stories in baseball thus far, but they won’t continue to be if they don’t shore up their rotation. It is nice to dream about Keller getting the call and dominating hitters, but that just isn’t realistic. The Pirates have to look outside their organization and find a player to fill this cavernous void on their roster.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.