Greetings and welcome to my last mailbag on the Pirates’ beat (please hold your applause). You’ll still have plenty of mailbag goodness from Jason Mackey and Nubyjas Wilborn, so make sure to send them questions: jmackey@post-gazette.com and nwilborn@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG and @nwilborn19.

@NickLe1023: What do you think about the trade deadline? I feel like there are too many outfielders. And also how about the relievers? I really do not know there.

Bill: The relievers are already moving. Anthony Swarzak just changed hands as I wrote this. And given the Pirates’ current situation — Keone Kela injured, rookies Montana DuRapau and Geoff Hartlieb involved, Clay Holmes back in the mix — any relief arms the Pirates could acquire would help. The Pirates have been successful at finding usable bullpen arms in the past, and if they’re in contention, I would imagine they’ll do so again this year.

Regarding the outfield, until we see both Corey Dickerson and Lonnie Chisenhall on the active roster and playing, I’m not going to worry about an outfield logjam.

Advertise with us

@dealrichard: The Pirates need to do something about [Steven] Brault, because he just doesn’t cut it in the majors. Would sending him back to AAA and start working on a new pitch be beneficial?

Bill: This one is tricky because Brault has already shown he can dominate Class AAA. In his previous extended look at the level, in 2017, he posted a 1.94 ERA and was the Pirates’ minor league pitcher of the year. I don’t think it’s a coincidence that his best year in the majors was the year he posted the lowest walk and home run rate, also 2017, in 11 appearances, four starts, in 34 2/3 innings. That suggests to me that it’s not so much learning a new pitch as improving the command and control of the pitches he already has.

He did not stop throwing this offseason so he could work on shortening his arm action and stride length in an effort to do just that, but so far the results have been uneven and led to an 8.24 ERA. There is an argument to be made to send him down to work on command on a consistent basis there, but with the lack of pitching depth right now, I don’t know that that would be beneficial.

@RossInsana: Two parter: What is your pecking order of the bullpen, as currently constructed, after Vazquez and Crick? And if they go forward with an opener for a few turns through the rotation, is the plan for it to always be DuRapau or could we see someone like Liriano/Hartlieb?

Bill: The way he’s pitched, I’d put Francisco Liriano next among the healthy, active pitchers. It’s a sign of where the bullpen is right now that I’d consider DuRapau next.

Advertise with us

I could imagine them going with someone else for the opener based on matchup, past history, recent usage, etc. Those two would be at the top of the list for me.

@LasSalamancas21: Way too early deadline predictions. Pretty easy to predict if they sell but buying would be interesting. Long term pieces like last year or rentals like 13 & 15? What prospects aren't available?

Bill: I’m still rearranging my previously conceived notions about what the Pirates will and won’t do at the trade deadline after the Chris Archer trade last year. I still think they prefer to acquire rentals only if they can do so without surrendering upper-tier prospects (think J.A. Happ), and if they’re going to give up prospect capital, it’ll be for someone over whom they have contractual control (like the Archer deal).

I think it depends on where they are and what they need come the All-Star break. If they're still banged up like this, I’m not sure they give up too much, but if they get some pieces back and have a shot at the division, they could make some moves. Right now I’m thinking pitching would be the priority. I don’t see them moving Mitch Keller or Ke’Bryan Hayes. I could see them moving one of the shortstops, but not this year.

@mflynn300: So Newman is swinging a good bat, why not give him the job at SS now, and see if he can’t run with it? Tucker seems fielding-wise ready but his bat isn’t catching up. Wouldn’t it be better to get him back to AAA to get some more time there to find his bat before he is ruined?

Advertise with us

Bill: That would make a lot of sense, and we might be headed in that direction, with Kevin Newman starting two of the past four games after Cole Tucker started 21 out of 23. The Pirates generally like their players to experience adversity in Class AAA before doing so in the majors so that they can learn how opponents adjust to them and how they should counter-attack, and that didn’t exactly happen here, but Tucker is a positive, strong-willed player who could handle going back down and learning from his struggles in the majors. And if they decide to play Newman, Tucker will need at-bats to work on his adjustments (the swing-and-miss has been an issue) and the minors would get him more consistent ABs.

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.