The 2019 Pirates were supposed to be built around pitching and run prevention. So far, that formula has led to a 16-15 record entering their midweek series against the Texas Rangers.

Given all the injuries, that record is being hailed as some sort of miracle. But the most surprising thing about the Pirates is that the bullpen has been spotty at best.

The back end has been fairly reliable, although Keone Kela has been inconsistent, but in general the unit has blown too many leads. There have been some injuries, true, but when you strip away the hype about just how loaded the bullpen is, you realize there isn’t much beyond three pitchers to get excited about (Kyle Crick, Felipe Vazquez and Kela).

That is why it is time for the Pirates to do a most un-Pirate-like thing and try to sign free-agent closer Craig Kimbrel.

Advertise with us

Yes, that would require the Pirates to go outside their comfort zone salary-wise, but they can afford him given their payroll. And more importantly, they need him if they are going to be the dominant bullpen they claim they want to be.

Kimbrel was one of the best relievers in baseball last season playing for the Red Sox. He had 42 saves and a 2.74 ERA, and he struck out 96 batters in 62⅓ innings. He is on the market because he is looking to be paid what he thinks is market value. He also wants to continue to pitch the ninth inning (remain the closer) though it isn’t certain that request is a deal breaker.

What would it take to sign Kimbrel? Ken Rosenthal has reported that he is looking for a deal similar to what Wade Davis got from Colorado. That would three years, $52 million or just over $17 million a year. That is probably on the high side, but Kimbrel is out of a job right now, so maybe the Pirates could get him for a few dollars less.

Let’s say, for instance, they are able to sign him for three years at $45 million. While many would scream that is way too much for a closer, it is the price of doing business. That’s especially true with a team that wants to be built on pitching and the ability to close games with a strong bullpen.

Before the season, Pirates President Frank Coonelly explained that the reason the Pirates’ payroll is so low (about $74 million) is because they have so many pre-arbitration or early arbitration players and thus have low salaries. He explained that those numbers will begin to rise as these players move forward in their careers and earn more money.

Advertise with us

That’s wonderful news, because it means the Pirates should have extra money to spend on free agents for the next year or two. The addition of Kimbrel, for instance, would only push the Pirates’ payroll to about $90 million. They would still be well behind the other teams in their division in payroll. They also will be shedding themselves of the salaries of Corey Dickerson and Francisco Cervelli in the offseason, so their payroll with Kimbrel still wouldn’t be bloated next year, either.

Kimbrel as closer would give Clint Hurdle the ultimate weapon — Vazquez as the pitcher who cleans up messes before the ninth. That would also move Kela and Crick back a little, and on most nights Pirates fans could be spared from the adventures of Richard Rodriguez/Michael Feliz/Steve Brault/Nick Kingham.

If the Pirates had one more reliable and dominant arm in the bullpen, they would probably have four or five more wins given how many games they have blown.

Someone is going to sign Kimbrel soon, so why not the Pirates?

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise

Advertise with us

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.