The Pirates are being applauded for remaining competitive even though they have been hit with a rash of injuries. It is true, they are 14-14 and have done that without the benefit of having a number of their veteran everyday players available for the majority of the games.

The Pirates have been forced to bring some players up from the minor leagues before they wanted to. Cole Tucker is the team’s everyday shortstop right now because Kevin Newman and Erik Gonzalez both got hurt. Tucker is considered a star in the making and the shortstop of the future, but the Pirates wanted him to get another year of seasoning in the minors.

Bryan Reynolds was not in the Pirates’ plans to be called up this early, either. He was hitting well in Indianapolis and the Pirates liked him as a prospect, but the plan was to ride with the veteran outfield they had this season.

Elias Diaz was always in the plans to be the backup catcher, but he has had to play when Francisco Cervelli got injured. Diaz has been a reliable backup and is an excellent defensive catcher and the more he gets opportunities to play the better he will become at handling the pitching staff and framing pitches.

Advertise with us

Pardon me, but at this point I can’t come up with one single reason why Tucker shouldn’t be the starting shortstop, Reynolds shouldn’t be the starting left fielder and Diaz shouldn’t be the starting catcher for the rest of the season. These three are all players who are in the Pirates’ plans of the future, and that future should start now.

This team, regardless if Corey Dickerson, Cervelli and Gonzalez/Newman get healthy or not, is not a playoff team. Let’s stop pretending that it is, that losing those three players is the difference between the Pirates contending this year or not. This was an 82-to-84-win team when healthy, and with the three younger players playing, it is probably an 80-to-82-win team.

And that’s assuming all three of the younger players go through the customary growing pains. There is a chance that all three could continue to improve and the Pirates could still get to 84 wins or so. Who cares? What is the difference between winning 80 games and winning 84 games? Both will leave you on the outside of the playoffs looking in, and that’s all that matters.

This is not giving up on the season; it is playing younger players who are part of your future because you want to get them ready for the next two seasons when you might have a chance to contend with a few additions. Dickerson and Cervelli are not going to be here next season, so what is the need to keep them playing now?

Trade them both for whatever you can get, save some money on their salary and maybe invest it elsewhere.

Advertise with us

Tucker is the easiest decision of these three positions. Gonzalez and Newman are not everyday shortstops on a team that is serious about contending. Tucker has the ability to grow into that, so why not dump Gonzalez — who is just not good enough — allow Tucker to take his lumps and keep Newman around as his backup?

Reynolds has been a breath of fresh air, but so has Jason Martin, who is not currently with the major league team. I’d give left field to those two — with Reynolds getting first crack at being the starter — and seeing where it goes. Reynolds is extremely hot right now and is likely to cool off, but manager Clint Hurdle said he has the makeup to be an excellent player.

“He has prepared for this opportunity for a long time,” Hurdle said .”He has worked to a good offensive spot from spring training on. I don’t think he has let anything wide-eye him since he came up here.

“He is no muss, he is no fuss and I don’t think he gets caught up real high and I don’t think he gets real low. He is in a good place, he is seeing pitches, he is controlling the zone he likes to hit in and he is getting some pitches there. He has shown the ability to drive in some runs, he has been a solid defender, he is playing good baseball, he is in the moment right now and just enjoying it.”

It could be easy to get caught up in the moment with a rookie who started off hot, but the Pirates have some options in left field and don’t need Dickerson, as he is on an expiring contract and would be a candidate to be moved at the trade deadline anyway.

Advertise with us

The Pirates aren’t legitimately ready to contend for a playoff spot yet. They are on their way, though, and with maybe one more year of seasoning and a good offseason, they could be. The dropoff from the three veterans to the three younger players would not be significant, and I think fans would rather watch younger, hungrier players every night.

It wouldn’t be giving up on the season to commit to Reynolds and/or Martin, Tucker and Diaz; it would be committing to building a playoff team by getting young, talented players experience.