April really needed two report cards, one through April 20 and another through the remainder of the month. Are the Pirates the 12-6, first-place team through the first three weeks of the season or the one that lost eight in a row? Is the bullpen terrible or good? Are the starters untouchable or average? Is the offense below average, or … well. Yeah.
The Pirates ended April at 13-14 and in fourth place in the NL Central. These grades are based on the team’s performance in March and April in comparison to the rest of the league and Major League Baseball.
Offense
The Pirates ranked 13th in the NL with 3.33 runs scored per game, more than a run below the league average of 4.52. They missed several contributors — Gregory Polanco, Corey Dickerson, Starling Marte and Elias Diaz — for periods of the month, but some of the starters struggled, as well. Francisco Cervelli hit .175/.250/.238, Jung Ho Kang .160/.222/.360.
The Pirates' on-base percentage ranks 10th in the league at .296 and they are 13th in slugging percentage, at .368. Not helping that second number were the 23 home runs they hit, tied for dead last in the league. When adjusting for league and park effects, the Pirates’ offense was 22 percent worse than average. One thing they did do well: not strike out. Their 238 Ks were the league’s fewest.
Josh Bell has been the bright spot. He’s hitting the ball hard — his 52.9 percent hard-hit percentage (95 mph exit velocity and up) is 18th in MLB, he hit six home runs and he has a line of .286/.363/.592. Melky Cabrera has been a savior in an injury-ravaged outfield (.329/.352/.494) and Bryan Reynolds went 11 for 26 after his promotion.
Read More
Grade: D
Pitching
The staff as a whole had a 3.55 ERA, third-best in the league, in April. Their WHIP of 1.17 ranked third and they allowed 26 home runs, fewer than only the Cincinnati Reds (Wait a minute. The Reds lead the league in fewest homers allowed? What sorcery is this?)
The rotation’s 3.27 ERA leads the NL, thanks to Joe Musgrove’s 2.06 ERA, Jordan Lyles’ 2.42 mark and Trevor Williams’ 3.38 ERA. Jameson Taillon’s 4.06 ERA does not match the way he pitched; Chris Archer had three good starts and two mediocre ones, the latter of which could have been attributed to a sore thumb.
Only the Reds’ starters have a lower home runs per nine innings allowed than the Pirates rotation’s 0.81, and nobody walks fewer per nine than the Pirates starters.
Pirates relievers ranked seventh with a 4.05 ERA, but struck out 11.22 batters per nine. They can thank closer Felipe Vazquez, with 21 strikeouts in 12 2/3 innings, and Francisco Liriano, with 14 in 10 2/3 innings. Richard Rodriguez and Keone Kela got off to rough starts before stabilizing.
Grade: B+
Defense
The Pirates had minus-seven Defensive Runs Saved in April, which ranked 21st in baseball. They converted 69.7 balls in play into outs, right around league average, but it has not looked as good on the field.
Both shortstops that began the season on the active roster, Erik Gonzalez and Kevin Newman, struggled with routine plays; Newman once made three errors in an inning. Bell’s throwing arm continues to be an issue, and among 24 first basemen with at least 150 innings played, Bell’s -0.7 Ultimate Zone Rating ranks 20th (yes, UZR needs more of a sample size to increase in accuracy, as do most defensive stats, but this dovetails with his performance in recent seasons, despite tons of extra pregame work).
Cervelli, Kang and Adam Frazier have all played above-average defense, and Cervelli has thrown out 40 percent of base-stealers.
Grade: C-
Coaching staff/front office
I looked back at last May’s report card to dig up the template and saw this sentence opening the final section: “Do we grade the coaches and executives on their run to first place in the middle of the month, or their fall to fourth in the final two weeks? Little of both.”
Deja vu, huh?
The team dipped into its prospect talent pool early, and while they did it out of necessity, they still did it, rather than calling up a lesser player and worrying about the service-time clock of their prospects. Cole Tucker, Jason Martin and Bryan Reynolds all played upon their promotions, as well.
It’s hard to quibble with the lineup choices when manager Clint Hurdle must pick between so many second- and third-string players, the same as it’s tough to nitpick the bullpen usage when the players who struggled early had good track records in their past. Two situations stood out.
One, when Hurdle did not use Vazquez in a tie game at home in extra innings because he was saving him for a save situation. In extra innings at home, there is no save situation, but if Vazquez were available to pitch in that scenario, why not in a situation where he could get the victory? He’s on a long-term contract, so racking up saves for the sake of arbitration doesn’t matter. The second was when Hurdle did not pinch-run for Kang at the end of a game in the situation where Kang made the final out at the plate by a mile. The rationale was that had he used Pablo Reyes there and then pinch-hit Elias Diaz, Diaz would have been walked to load the bases for the pitcher’s spot with an empty bench. But he did not have to pinch-hit Diaz; he could have let Martin face a lefty, whom he’d handled in the minors and to whom Will Smith almost certainly would have pitched.
As always, the coaching staff and front office bear some of the responsibility for the current record, which the grade reflects.
Grade: C
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.