Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

James Eathorne,@letanglambert58: What should the Penguins’ playoff defensive parings be? And who should sit?

Zeise: The best thing the Penguins have going for them defensively is that they have depth, and that means they have options. I think Mike Sullivan would mix it up based on matchups and who is playing well. I think, though, the first candidate to sit would be Olli Maatta — assuming Brian Dumoulin is playing, which he is supposed to. That isn’t because Maatta isn’t playing well; the other players are either playing better than he is or they are in a pairing that is playing too well to break up. That’s why I see no way Marcus Pettersson or Erik Gudbranson are sitting out, as they have played well together and Sullivan likes that group. You aren’t taking Justin Schultz out, and while some would say Jack Johnson should be the odd man out, management has been all in with him, so I don’t see that, either.

Advertise with us

John Fecik, Las Vegas, NV: I was a Pirate fan since 1959 until last May when I finally gave up and have not looked back. We all know there is no commitment from ownership to win. Every player in baseball knows the same. When I hear talking heads talk about locking up players such as Jameson Taillon, do they think he is stupid? If you were a quality player would you want to play for them? Hell no!

Zeise: Taillon has a history of arm troubles. He is 27 and the Pirates have him under control for this season and three more. He would actually be wise to work on a deal with the Pirates because it will give him financial security for the rest of his life. The Pirates will buy out his arbitration years in return for a few of his free agent years. There is no guarantee he will be healthy three or four years from now, and he has already lost a lot of time with injuries. It is a deal he should make.

Greg Parrpenick, Mount Pleasant: Why are the Pirates so bad defensively? I thought their organization was based on analytics and run prevention. How can they be this bad?

Zeise: They are bad fielders, that’s why. They don’t have many players who are even above average at their positions. The infield is bad, though shortstop Erik Gonzalez is supposed to be better than he has been. It is a clear issue with this team and won’t likely improve any time soon. They need to hope they score more runs than anticipated or strike out more hitters than they usually do because the defense is going to let them down often this season.

Justin Kessler, @justinkess18: What is more likely to happen: AB winning a Lombardi Trophy or a spelling bee?

Advertise with us

Zeise: It is more likely that he will win a Lombardi Trophy but mostly because he won’t enter a spelling bee any time soon. I mean, he can’t lose it if he doesn’t enter it!

Frank Joski, New Stanton: Do you think AB would still be in the NFL today if he was a sixth-round pick of the Raiders in 2010?

Zeise: Yes, he’d be in the league because he is an extraordinarily talented player. The larger question is: Would he be the superstar that he is? My gut tells me no. That isn’t to say that Ben Roethlisberger made him, but playing with a Hall of Fame quarterback has certainly helped him rise to stardom. It will be interesting to see what happens this year when he plays with Derek Carr, who isn’t nearly as good as Roethlisberger.

Doug Bigley, Scottsdale: Is Antonio Brown slowly but surely vindicating Ben Roethlisberger by the way he acts and the things he has said on social media?

Zeise: Yes, and this is why I said the Steelers’ best approach is to just not respond. They have taken the high road and it has paid off, as the narrative has pretty much changed overnight. A guy like Antonio Brown can’t help himself, and he is so narcissistic that he doesn’t know when to keep his mouth shut. His attack on JuJu Smith-Schuster has really turned a lot of the people who were buying his story against him. That’s how the Steelers will win this in the end — by taking the high road and letting Brown self-implode.

Advertise with us

Blessed, @Blessedfather34: Do you think the Steelers will win the division?

Zeise: Yes, I do. I think they are better than the Browns, the Ravens quarterback situation I think is overrated, and the Bengals still stink. The Steelers are the best team in the division still.