The Pirates made four errors in their 10-0 loss to the Cubs on Monday. That shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone who has paid attention to this roster and the way it was built.
Monday was somewhat of an outlier and the Pirates aren’t likely to make four errors frequently. But they also aren’t likely to get any better defensively than what we have seen so far.
This team was built on the idea that pitching and defense could carry it a long way. And the pitching has held up its end of that bargain. The starters have been, for the most part, fabulous. The bullpen has had some leaks, but some of that was due to bad defense and some was due to the fact that Steven Brault is still on team. It’s amazing the Pirates haven’t been able to come up with a better left-handed option out of the bullpen.
Regardless of what the pitchers have done, though, the defense has been mostly bad. That makes perfect sense because you get what you pay for, and the Pirates’ payroll and budget has made it impossible for general manager Neal Huntington to upgrade this area the way he needed to.
Sure, he went out and got shortstop Erik Gonzalez, who is generously described as a light-hitting defensive whiz, but he could have brought in a better player if he had more money to spend. He told anyone who would listen, though, that the combination of Kevin Newman and Gonzalez would be better than anyone he could have gone out and got — and much cheaper.
Huntington would have been better off trying to keep Jordy Mercer than playing with this duo. Mercer doesn’t have the range of Gonzalez, but he is steady, made the routine plays and was a veteran who knew how to turn double plays. Had Mercer played Monday instead of Newman, I am positive the Pirates wouldn’t have given up six unearned runs. Mercer is also a better hitter than either, though I am sure some Huntington apologists will point out he has gotten off to a slow start this year.
Read More
That’s only one spot, though, and if Gonzalez is playing, it is their best defensive position in the infield. Take a look at the options at the other three positions and try to come up with a solid defensive unit that can also be productive at the plate.
It would seem that the Pirates’ best options at first, second and third are Josh Bell, Adam Frazier and Jung Ho Kang. All three seem to be capable, albeit inconsistent, hitters, but defensively that infield — the Pirates’ best — is below average.
A bad defense can be overcome if a team has an explosive offense and a pitching staff loaded with strikeout artists. The Pirates have neither, which means they won’t score a lot of runs and the ball will be in play a lot.
That’s a bad formula for success.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.