The Pirates have a number of important position battles this spring training, but none are as important as the one at third base. Jung Ho Kang and Colin Moran are both angling to become the starter, and it seems like this is a competition that could go on deep into the preseason.

For the Pirates’ sake, I hope that isn’t the case.

Kang needs to establish himself as the best player at that position and win the job sooner rather than later. The Pirates won’t be nearly as good if Kang can’t beat out Moran because Kang is the far better option both in the field and at the plate. He also fits the profile of a corner infielder on a contender, and the Pirates front office has made it clear they plan on contending this season.

Moran is still relatively young and will make a nice bench player. He is a solid pinch-hitter with a little bit of power. He is not an everyday third baseman on a contending team, though, at least not yet. He is a liability in the field and he is a liability against left-handed pitching. He feasts on right-handed pitchers, though, so he is a good option to give Kang a day off here and there.

Advertise with us

And before you get all emotional about it — I understand that Moran is a fan favorite, and he is indeed an excellent clubhouse guy — ask yourself, on how many other teams in the National League would Moran be the everyday third baseman?

Kang is a much better fielder than Moran and that’s where this discussion should end. The Pirates pitch to contact, but they have had a subpar defensive infield for the past few seasons and those two things seem to counter each other. Kang isn’t Brooks Robinson, but he is a credible and competent fielder and has relatively decent range; Moran has no range.

The combination of Kang at third and, say, Erik Gonzalez at shortstop would give the Pirates a solid left side of the infield. Their defense on that side would be well above average, and that would improve the overall team defense.

Kang also represents the best power threat and gives the Pirates a legitimate cleanup hitter. If he can stay healthy, he could be the 30-home run player the Pirates desperately need. The only other player that seems to have anywhere close to that potential is Josh Bell, and he is coming off a season where he struggled to hit the ball out of the park.

The other thing about Kang is that he has generally hit right-handed and left-handed pitchers at a similar rate. He doesn’t need to be platooned.

Advertise with us

Neal Huntington and Clint Hurdle have made it clear that they don’t want to have a platoon situation at third, and that is the correct approach to take. The more Kang is in the lineup — assuming he is something close to what he was before he essentially had two seasons wiped out with legal and injury issues — the better the Pirates will be.

On Sunday, Kang showed what he could be this year by hitting two home runs in a spring training game against the Marlins. It is spring training, I get it. The pitching was suspect, I get it. The wind was blowing out, too, and I get all of that. The fact is he has looked really good swinging the bat so far and, by all accounts, he has been incredibly relaxed.

Everyone seemed enamored with the homers, but that wasn’t even the best sign that Kang could be poised for an excellent season and return to form. Kang made a couple of plays in the field in which he had to react and move and then deliver strong, accurate throws. That is important because he did have a major knee injury and a major wrist injury, but it appears as if he has recovered well and there aren’t any lingering ailments.

I was skeptical of Kang ever playing for the Pirates again after his string of DUI’s and his injuries. I was actually even skeptical that he’d ever play in the major leagues again. It appears I was wrong on both counts.

The Pirates are hoping so, at least, because a healthy and productive Kang could change their fortunes.