Major League Baseball Players Association leader Tony Clark scoffed at Rob Manfred’s idea that all teams are trying to win. He also questioned why fans in some cities would buy tickets to see their favorite teams play.

Clark has had it — and so have many of the players. The current market is nonsense. Players have less control and have less ability to cash in on their success than ever before. Roughly 100 free agents are still on the market, and a number of others settled for far less money than they are worth.

Manfred and the owners cite the use of analytics as the reason clubs are hesitant to sign free agents. He suggests that players are no longer going to get paid based on their past performance but rather what they are likely to do based on their age and a number of other factors.

“We’ve had a lot of change in the game,” Manfred said recently. “People think about players differently. They analyze players differently. They negotiate differently.”

Advertise with us

Manfred is blowing a lot of hot air here. Teams have figured out that they are profitable regardless of whether they win or lose or how many tickets they sell. The addition of wild cards to the playoffs has made it seem like far more teams are contending than actually are, and that helps justify lower payrolls as well.

Most teams, for the most part, assume they will never be among the top 10 in payroll anyway, so they are willing to try to catch lightning in a bottle with a lot less money. That’s because lower payroll means more money in the owners’ pockets and less in the pockets of players.

The Pirates are the model franchise in this regard. They are always near the bottom of the league in payroll and yet have fielded somewhat competitive teams over the past six years. They haven’t won a thing and haven’t been to the playoffs since 2015, but they are competitive enough to stay somewhat in the playoff chase thanks to wild cards.

The Pirates, as of now, have a $68 million to $70 million payroll this year, which is near the bottom of the league. They claim the reason is they have a lot of young, cheap talented players who haven’t reached arbitration yet. But that’s precisely why now is the time to spend money on free agents. A $100 million payroll is still not even in the top 20 in the league, and yet it would represent an increase of more than $30 million.

Frankly, if players are truly no longer going to get paid based on past performance, when exactly will they get paid? The current system of pre-arbitration/arbitration years means clubs can hold players hostage and underpay them for the first six or seven years of their careers.

Advertise with us

A player like Jameson Taillon is entering his prime and is going to be one of the best pitchers in baseball. He will make $575,000 this year and will have to wait through three years of arbitration after this year before he can get paid. He will be 31, though, when he becomes a free agent and apparently analytics gurus will spit out a formula suggesting that he is over the hill and past his best years.

Players must take a stand because the owners have way too much control and make way too much of the money. The union should fight for a number of things in 2021 when it negotiates the next collective bargaining agreement. Players need to recognize they have power and be willing to go the distance to make the system work better for them.

They should fight to eliminate the six or seven years of initial control by teams. A player’s clock should start the first day he gets called up to the majors, and from that point he should get one pre-arbitration year and two arbitration years. A player should be a full-fledged free agent at the end of three seasons.

This would allow more players to become free agents when they are 25 to 27 years old, and that would increase their bargaining power because they’d still have most of their prime left.

The union should also insist on a salary cap and a salary floor. The current system means the top-end free agents get paid but the mid- and lower-tier players are all getting nickle-and-dimed by teams. A salary floor of, say, $120 million coupled with a salary cap of, say, $200 million would create a lot more money for a lot more players and ensure a more competitive league. The union could fight for the NBA rule where there is a max contract and teams can go above the salary cap to sign their own free agents.

Advertise with us

There is plenty of money in baseball, the sport is healthy and the revenues have never been higher. The players need to cash in on their fair share of that money, and the current system isn’t allowing them to.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise