Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
Carl Reagle, @reagle_c: Do you think MLB needs to institute a salary floor?
Zeise: The MLBPA and the agents who represent the players have been very short-sighted in fighting so hard against a salary cap. The reason there are 100 free agents or so still looking for work and the reason many free agents have signed for a lot less than their value is there is no salary cap. Teams like the Pirates have figured out they don’t have to spend money on free agents; they can wait until late in the process and get desperate players for next to nothing. The MLBPA should insist on a system like the NBA has — a salary cap that comes with a salary floor and allows teams to go above the cap on a maximum contract to sign their own free agents. There might not be the way over-the-top, 10-year deals that are thrown around to the top players now, but the top players will always get paid. The thing it would do is force teams to spend money on players in order to get above the salary floor. Teams couldn’t get away with $68 million payrolls, and the mid-tier and low-tier free players would all make more money. It is a long answer, but unequivocally, the answer is yes.
Bruno, @BrunoGarrett1: The Broncos only had to give up a fourth round pick for a SB winning QB (Joe Flacco) still in his prime ... why should the Steelers expect anything better in return for a 31-year old malcontent prima donna troublemaking WR like AB?
Zeise: I would disagree, wholeheartedly, that Joe Flacco is still in his prime. If he were in his prime, he wouldn’t have lost his job to a quarterback who hasn’t shown any ability to throw the ball at a high level yet. Flacco has a year or two left, maybe, and that’s about it. He is a stopgap player for the Broncos until they can find a young QB to build around. That being said, your larger point about Antonio Brown is correct. I don’t see the Steelers getting a king’s ransom — or anything close — for Brown. He has destroyed his own value, and I can’t imagine he has many more years of playing at a high level. My prediction is he will never have it as good as he has had it with the Steelers.
Rick Notari, @TheBigBlueDevil: Why does [Antonio Brown] think he can pick his next team or even have a next team? Does he not know how the system works? He is under contract for the next three seasons. The Steelers don't have to move him anywhere.
Read More
Zeise: You are asking me to get inside the mind of Antonio Brown? If I could do that, I could make a whole lot of money. He is a self-centered individual, and he believes the world revolves around him. Why would he think anything different? He clearly doesn’t care about rules, regulations and procedures, so this is not a surprise. The Steelers should trade him for whatever they can get and move on. It is that time. There is no turning back now.
Michael River, @river_michael: Can the Steelers package trade Brown and Bell to the Pats? It would be like a Trojan horse!
Zeise: This would probably not be something I’d advise them to do. Could you imagine if Tom Brady got Bell and Brown and they were both motivated to prove to everyone they got a bad rap? I mean, if they were going to be selfish, statmongers it would be one thing, but I bet Bill Belichick and country would persuade them to buy into the team concept — and that would make the Patriots extremely dangerous for the next two or three seasons.
BostonsCommon, @BostonsCommon: Where is the light at the end of the tunnel? After a promising start, this Pitt team has fallen apart. McGowens has regressed, X is out of control more than he’s in, and as a team, defense and rebounding seem optional. Capel said it’s not his job to coach effort, intensity and details — but someone has to, no?
Zeise: I disagree with any coach who says “it isn’t my job to coach effort” because, yeah, it is. Some players need to be motivated a little more than others. Sometimes the grinding season wears players down and they need to be pushed through it. I get the sentiment —that players need to motivate themselves — but I sometimes they need a little extra. It is pretty clear to me the freshmen are struggling right now. That is to be expected, and the light at the end of the tunnel is that the three freshmen will become sophomores, and there will be more talent added to the team in the offseason. Capel is building something; it just is going to take some time.
Matt Krisnosky, @MattKriz: What do you think are reasonable expectations for Pitt’s basketball team next season?
Zeise: Honestly, I have to see what the recruiting class is like but I am fairly certain they will be too high. The ACC is a really difficult league in which to build a program. I am sure people will expect a big jump, but I wouldn’t expect that until Year 3. I think if they get to 6-12 or 7-11 in the ACC next season it will be considered a success. They have a lot of holes to fill, and they are losing two of their best players to graduation as well. This is going to be a process, one that takes some patience and a few seasons. I fully expect Capel to get the thing on track, but I don’t think it will happen as soon as some people hope.
Jared Starks, Greentree: With Matt Murray getting injured so often, do you think the Penguins should invest in a 1-A type back-up, similar to what Boston has with Halak?
Zeise: Yes but it won’t happen. The Penguins seem to be committed to Casey DeSmith and Tristan Jarry. I don’t think either of them are good enough to lead the Penguins on a long playoff run if Murray gets hurt, but Jim Rutherford and company seem to. It would be a mistake for them not to find a backup goaltender who has proven he can win in the playoffs, but I don’t think they will.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.