The Steelers appear to be staying the course with the rest of their defensive coaching staff after firing outside linebackers coach Joey Porter. That would mean Keith Butler returns for at least one more season and that the scheme is unlikely to change much, if at all.
There is something to be said for the Steelers’ model of coaching stability. It is admirable. It is also a concept stuck in a different time, and it — like many things about the way the Steelers do business — needs to change in order to reflect the modern NFL.
That’s a discussion for a different day, though, as the Steelers’ offseason focus needs to be fixing — or at least dramatically improving — the defense. The fact Butler and almost all of his staff are likely to return means there won’t be a change or upgrade schematically — so, the unit has to be improved by adding players.
They have a glaring need at cornerback and inside linebacker. Anybody who is paying attention can see that. The Steelers have an excellent corner in Joe Haden but no legitimate starter for a playoff contender on the other side. The Steelers have also tried to fill the void left by Ryan Shazier’s injury with very little success. Jon Bostic is a stopgap at best and the other players — like Tyler Matakevich — are not every-down players for a title-worthy team.
That’s not to say guys like Coty Sensabaugh, Matakevich and Bostic aren’t serviceable, somewhat effective NFL players. They just aren’t quite good enough to give the Steelers defense a chance to become one of the best in the NFL.

Sure, statistically they look good; they were the No. 6 ranked unit in the NFL in yards against. They gave up only 327.2 yards per game. They also ranked in the top 10 in both passing yards against (231.1, 10th) and rushing yards against (96.1, sixth).
Read More
Those numbers appear to tell a tale of a unit that doesn’t need much help. They’re actually proof of a quote popularized by Mark Twain — “There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies and statistics.”
A closer look shows a defense that almost never forced turnovers. It was also a unit that tied the Lions for No. 16 in the most important category: points against (22.5 per game). The unit also couldn’t hold late leads against the Browns, Raiders, Broncos, Chargers and Saints and likely wouldn’t have against the Patriots without some fortunate holding calls.
The Steelers defense is reasonably good at not allowing other teams to move the ball and excellent at getting sacks, but it couldn’t force turnovers or hold leads and gave up too many points. That speaks volumes about the unit’s biggest need: a big-time, high-impact difference-maker.
Think Khalil Mack or Aaron Donald. Think James Harrison in his prime, or Troy Polamalu. The Steelers don’t have that player, and they don’t have many candidates.
T.J. Watt, for instance, led the team in sacks with 13 and has developed into an excellent pass rusher with room to grow — but how many games did he change with a strip sack, an interception or a big hit on a critical third down? Watt is the closest thing the Steelers have to that high-impact playmaker, but he isn’t quite there.
Those players don’t grow on trees, though. That’s especially true for a team that has traditionally drafted in the late 20s. The Steelers, by virtue of missing the playoffs, will draft No. 20 in April, but that probably isn’t high enough to ensure one of those difference-makers. I know the Steelers don’t traditionally move up in the draft, but they need to do it. There are simply too many high-impact defensive players available. They aren’t likely to sign a big-name free agent, and it is hard to trade for one, so moving up is their best option.
If they do, the defense will have a chance to make marked improvement next year. If they don’t, I don’t see how it improves, given that the schemes and the coach calling the defenses won’t change.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.