Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Charlie Bilt, Mt Oliver: Why isn’t Colbert as much or even more than Tomlin held accountable for the failure of the past few years? Isn’t he a key decision-maker for the talent they draft? Which one would you say is most responsible for the Steelers’ draft misses, especially on defense?

Zeise: Kevin Colbert and Mike Tomlin work together. I think there is no question at this stage that Tomlin likely has the final say over a player. He has earned that much as the coach, and I would be willing to bet Colbert and him probably are on the same page for the most part. That’s why it has worked with those two for so long. They respect each other and seem to get along well. I think one reason that Colbert doesn’t get as much of the grief as Tomlin is he is really behind the scenes. He is the least visible —by far — of the three general managers in town, and so he is sometimes forgotten about. I think Colbert has done a good job, though, and the proof is that the Steelers are in the playoff chase every year. He and Tomlin have to have drafted some really good players on both sides of the ball, or Tomlin is the greatest coach in the history of football. I do think they could do better drafting defensive players than they have, but it is not an exact science and it isn’t easy to draft in the mid-to-late 20’s every year and still get a “can’t-miss” type of player.

Advertise with us

Jesse Lynn, Morningside: You wrote that Mike Tomlin gets the most out of his players and motivates them. If this is true, why do they continue to lose to 2-10 teams and teams they should beat?

Zeise: One thing has nothing to do with the other. Did you watch the Raiders game? Did you really think the problem was the team wasn’t playing hard or fighting their tails off to win? If so, we watched two different games. Did Chris Boswell miss kicks because he wasn’t trying? I think one of the laziest narratives in sports is that a team isn’t playing hard enough when they get upset or don’t play well. One of the worst things about the analytics era of sports is that people tend to forget that these are humans - not robots - playing these games. They just didn’t play well in Oakland. That has nothing to do with Tomlin’s ability to motivate his players. He is one of the best in the business at getting his players to grind and fight every week.

Harold Umtopion, Point Breeze: Do you really think this Patriots team is a Super Bowl contender? I am less than impressed by them and don’t think they will win a playoff game. I think the Steelers, Chiefs, Colts and Chargers and maybe even Ravens are all better than them.

Zeise: Here is my caveat - it is foolish to call ANY team with Bill Belichick and Tom Brady a non-Super Bowl contender. As long as those two are around and get into the playoffs, they are a threat to get to the Super Bowl. That being said, I think this is not a good version of the Patriots. I think Rob Gronkowski is old, Julian Edelman is old, the offensive line is average, the defense lacks playmakers and it is a team devoid of scary players. I agree that they are probably the fifth or sixth best team in the AFC, but as long as that coach and that quarterback are together, you cannot discount them until they are eliminated.

Jared Starks, Greentree: Why is Tomlin so stubborn when it comes to Chris Boswell? Does he honestly believe that there is nobody out there that can make above 61% of their FG tries?

Advertise with us

Zeise: Hey, my man, you obviously don’t read my columns! I think I addressed this adequately Tuesday with this column. Chris Boswell has been a great kicker for the Steelers until this year. Tomlin believes in him. Tomlin also knows the Steelers’ best chances of having a great kicker is to get Boswell right. I have no issues with him standing behind Boswell. Ben Roethlisberger has had a stretch of bad games in the past and he found his way out of it. Just about every player has had slumps and Boswell is no different.

Robert Harcher, Pittsburgh: At the end of the Oakland game, couldn't Switzer have fair-caught the kickoff and get the ball at the 25 instead of burning 6 or 7 seconds on the return?? Maybe I'm thinking of college.

Zeise: Yes, that is a college rule not an NFL rule. In college you can fair catch kickoffs anywhere inside the 25 and get the ball on the 25.

Tristian Chrassoni, Washington, Pa: Shamiel Stevenson just transferred from Pitt. I thought he was one of their best players but it didn’t seem he got a chance from Jeff Capel. Do you think this could be a sign of some issues inside the program already?

Zeise: No, I think it is a sign of a first-year coach and a program with some growing pains. Part of those growing pains is you lose players who transfer because they don’t fit or don’t have a role. It is not uncommon and not unique to Pitt. Capel will bring his own players in and build the roster that way. That is just how it is. Some players make the transition to a new coach well, others do not. The fact that Stevenson is leaving is not a statement about anything other than he saw that his role was greatly diminished and wants a chance to go somewhere else to play.