Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lars Eller and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Jared Starks, @JaredStarks3: Why is Tomlin still living on the edge by employing Chris Boswell? Travis Coons, who has a career FG percentage of 87.5, is still out there. Just saying. …

Starkey: I hear you, Mr. Starks. The iconic Mr. Coons has fared well enough in his brief NFL career, including four field goals against the Steelers (for the Browns) in a game that I have zero memory of. He is also the answer to a trivia question: Which player did the LA Rams waive so they could sign long-retired Eric Dickerson to a one-day contract?

Dickerson, incidentally, was clearly one of the top five running backs of all-time (why is he never in the discussion?) and maybe the coolest-looking athlete ever, with the neck roll and goggles and straight-up running style.

Advertise with us

May I interject here with the next four coolest-looking athletes of all-time?

4. Bill Walton: Literally could have gone straight from a game to a Dead show and not looked out of place.

3. UL Washington: The man played major league baseball with a toothpick in his mouth!

2. Slick Watts: Bald head, tilted head band. Legend. Take your pick here:

1. Julius Erving. Still can’t get over the knee pads with holes. What was the point? To look cool, of course — a precursor to the jeans-with-holes look. Enjoy this:

Advertise with us

As for Boswell, the pertinent question is this: Were the Steelers vindicated, by his performance Sunday, in how they handled their kicking situation?

The answer is a resounding no. Boswell missed a chip shot and made a 48-yarder. That’s a bad day. Might the clutch kick turn his season around? It might. He obviously has the pedigree — and it was difficult to watch him struggle as he did. If you didn’t feel for him after the miss, you have no heart.

However, I would have released Boswell after the Raiders game and gone with Kai Forbath, who reportedly had a good tryout here, subsequently signed with Jacksonville and made all three of his kicks Sunday (two field goals, extra point).

Your point on Coons is that other capable kickers are out there. I get it. But he also was just 7-for-11 beyond 40 yards in his year with the Browns and missed three extra points in two years.

Maybe that 48-yarder changes everything. Maybe Boswell said, “Screw it, I’ve got nothing left to lose” and just blasted it. We’ll see if Kevin Colbert and Mike Tomlin were correct. There will surely be more clutch kicks to be had Sunday in New Orleans.

Advertise with us

The fact for now is that they are sticking with a kicker who has missed more kicks than anyone in the league and is having one of the worst full seasons for any kicker in recent memory.

Tomlin discusses win over Patriots

Pittsburghish, @PGH_Sports8: Which running back will be more productive for the Steelers for the rest of this season — Jaylen Samuels or James Conner?

Starkey: I’m going with Samuels, Mr. @PGH_Sports 8. If indeed Conner is battling a high-ankle sprain, that’s a tough injury to come back from.

As for Samuels, he literally looked like a different human being against the Patriots. He looked lean and quick, whereas against Oakland, he looked plodding and heavy on running plays. It was a weird transformation.

Confidence and decisiveness apparently made the difference, combined with an excellent game plan that featured a number of misdirection plays. The Patriots never figured it out. And suddenly the guy they were calling Le’Veon Lite in training camp actually looked like our old friend Le’Veon Bell.

Advertise with us

Dan A, @hypothermicyeti: Why is the Penguins’ power play horrid?

Starkey: Horrid is a great word to describe the club’s second-period power play in a 2-2 game Monday night, Mr. @hyperthermicyeti. The power play has had its moments, for sure. But for all the sublime talent on hand, there is no way it should be ranked 11th in the NHL with a league-worst eight short-handed goals against.

To your question, it would be appear to be some combination of indifference, over-passing, other teams figuring some things out and the absence of Patric Hornqvist.

Pick and choose from those as you would from Hoss’s salad bar.

Alex #SteelersNation, @Alex_S: Should the Steelers begin running a 2 RB offense with Conner and Samuels?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Both could play at the same time, Alex, but that might mean Samuels split wide (which I’m not against). I don’t think you’ll see both lined up in the backfield together. That’s not what the Steelers do (unless Rosie Nix gets a rare snap, and could we please stop hearing from those who want Nix to be the featured ball-carrier?).

Jon Linder, @LinderShowMiami: If there was a Pittsburgh Mount Rushmore of ornery athletes, I got: Barry Bonds, Jack Lambert, Tom Barrasso, Phil Kessel. Who do you have?

Starkey: Wonderful question, Mr. Linder. Barrasso is a first-ballot Hall of Famer in this category. I never dealt much with Bonds and Lambert (other than a few letters he sent to me, one of which was a response to something I’d written that didn’t sit well; he finished it with: “Hugs and kisses, Jack Lambert.”). Kessel seems more agitated and/or disinterested than ornery when it comes to interacting with media.

My team is on the floor:

4. James Harrison. Only spoke on Fridays, and even then it often did not go well.

Advertise with us

3. James Neal. Is there something about guys named James?

2. Marlon Byrd. A tad volatile, one could say.

1. Barrasso. Once challenged me to come out on the ice and take shots on him. (My internal response was, “How about I take one from the red line, like Tom Fitzgerald?” but I thought better of it.)

Bernie Rafferty, @BernieRafferty: What is the most yinzer thing you do/say/like?

Starkey: Does overreacting to sporting events count?

Advertise with us

Zack Hough, @Hogaie7187: Will the Pirates grab a power bat this offseason?

Starkey: Not really, no.

Spencer J, @Soman9: Is there a current offensive NFL player who looks more uncomfortable with the football than Jesse James?

Starkey: Not really, no (although he is having a nice season; did you know he leads the team in yards per catch at 14.1?).

Christopher Matich, @PghMatich: If the Pirates are picking up another shortstop, of Freddy Galvis or Troy Tulowitzki, which do you prefer?

Advertise with us

Starkey: I like Freddy Galvis — got a glove and a little bit of pop. I also like Nick Ahmed for the same reasons, plus he had a pretty good season. Tulowitzki has been beset with bone spurs, which, from what I understand, come in handy if you’re trying to avoid military service but not so much when you’re attempting to play professional baseball.

Pitt_Bayless, @BaylessPitt: Q: Are you happy?

Starkey: Not as happy as you, Skip, after that big prediction Sunday. Nice job.

Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).